GatewayRedbirds.com

First off I agree with you and AK. The 'talent' never gets paid anything close to those behind the seens responsible for the marketing. LL Cool J gets about 87 cents for every $10 CD he sales. Jack Black's salary is less than 8% of the movies gross revenue. The guys doing the marketing and work behind the seens get paid more than the talent on the field. However, if for some reason the Rays can land a fish stick deal that gives them significantly more revenue, the players on that team will get their cut by way of bidding more or extending their star players to higher contacts than they would had they not landed that extra money. Teams are always trying to maximize their revenue in any way possible, mostly so they can give more money to their star players and keep fielding a winning team.

_________________
Arguing on the internet is like buying a solar-powered flashlight. Think about that.

You mean 19?

The point is the Pirates are one of the most profitable franchises because a) they use the revenue sharing to their advantage, b) They realize that you have diminishing returns the more you spend on player contracts in regard to revenue generation. If you don't care to win, you can still make crazy tons of money convincing people to see your product - because they are still an MLB caliber team thanks to the draft system and paying league minimum.

You don't need to spend more money on contracts. Yes, you need to if you want to be one of the popular teams, but you're better off spending the money on the business side and hiring 30 salesmen and 25 analysts = 55 Salaries x an avg salary of 55,000 a year totaling $3M than hiring Braden Looper to throw some balls around for you for a season.

Now I'm not saying the Pirates are a model franchise, but they do their strategy well, and the Marlins have also taken a crappy team and made it the talk of the town. Look, if MLB was really the selling point of the Marlins, then why is there a giant sculpture in CF, with fish tanks behind the plate, and a dance club in the corner OF? With the new Miami park, the baseball team is really just an attraction because its popular in the sense its a national sports team, but the real goal is just to sell you a bunch of crap you don't need or lure you to be entertained by cheerleaders and fish races.

_________________
"I have had craps that make my leg feel like it is being torn off
by a pack of angry chihuahuas, lets hope that is all it is...." -wart57
"Good lord. This is a family site." - G Keenan

Gateway Redbirds Facebook Group

The Pirates have made a lot of money off of other teams' players, true, but that also makes them accountable to the MLBPA, which has pressured MLB to end that loophole. It's not a viable long term strategy, and neither is a night club in the stadium. The team will always be the product.

_________________

I'd be curious to see how it plays out by profit.


They are using revenues which matters. It seems that the salaries rise pretty close to what happens with the tv revenues. And I wonder how much of that revenue stream is frtom 162 game schedules and the concessions from it. I didn't give it a huge read, but this guy seems to suggests NFL profits are higher on less revenue.

_________________

The article talks about player salaries as a percentage of revenue but comparing baseball to other sports is not apples to apples. The extra cost involved in running scouting, minor league teams, travel expenses for the players/staff/trainers/etc. for 81 road games a year in addition to the extra nights on the road on a long road trip and who knows what else is well above a football team traveling for 8 games a year during the regular season.

I stopped complaining about player salaries a long time ago. They get paid what the market will support. When people stop going to games and watching on TV or listening on the radio then the salaries will go down with revenue. Likewise, when people start buying season tickets to watch a teacher teach (or stop whining and accept higher taxes to pay them) then teachers will make more.

Don't the NBA and NFL also have guys who work to make their product more popular? Don't the NFL and NBA also get taxpayers to build them new stadiums? Aren't there also NFL teams (like the Bengals) that have had long stretches of suckiness?

_________________

Uh, that's not rocket science. Just to throw out some numbers…Say Corporation A brings in $20 billion in revenue, but only $1 billion in profit. And Corporation B brings in $20 billion in revenue but $2 billion of that is profit. The two really aren’t any different in size, but because “B” has $1 billion less in costs, they are twice as profitable.

There could be a number of reasons for this. TV money is just wildly more profitable in general than ticket sales, and that is where the NFL makes the vast majority of its money. Also, the NFL doesn’t have some pesky overhead costs, like a minor league system, to worry about. Their developmental players play for free in the NCAA. MLB has to pay their top developmental players some big money in some cases.

_________________

OTOH, it can be legitimately argued that without the players, the marketers have no product to market.

_________________
"You have to be concerned about the future, but you also have to be more concerned about the present. If you have to give up two or three young kids - who may not be able to play for several years - to get help for your team now, you have to do it." - Bing Devine, 1999

"They call baseball a game because it's too screwed up to be a business." - Jim Bouton, 1971.

"Big deal. Anyone can win games when the other team doesn't score any runs." - Curt Flood to Bob Gibson, circa 1968

IMO - At best this is a case of selective math, at worst just plain bad math.

Using revenue vs pay as a guide, what should a person working on an oil rig be paid? I see it as an over simplified view of the issue.

Now if you could actually list the profits made........

Have a Grateful Day!

The difference, though, between baseball and oil rigs is that in baseball, the players *are* the product. Without the players, you only have a nice patch of grass with seats around it.

With oil rigs, the oil is the product.

The oil rig workers would then be roughly equivalent to the stadium workers, not the players.

_________________
"You have to be concerned about the future, but you also have to be more concerned about the present. If you have to give up two or three young kids - who may not be able to play for several years - to get help for your team now, you have to do it." - Bing Devine, 1999

"They call baseball a game because it's too screwed up to be a business." - Jim Bouton, 1971.

"Big deal. Anyone can win games when the other team doesn't score any runs." - Curt Flood to Bob Gibson, circa 1968