Poll: Matheny's Job Security

Discuss all things Cardinals Baseball
Post Reply

When does Matheny get fired?

Before the end of this season
3
6%
After the season is over
11
23%
Mid-season 2018
7
15%
After the 2018 season
10
21%
Before his contract is up in 2020
4
9%
They'll officially part ways when his contract expires
5
11%
Never: we got him as long as we wants to be here
7
15%
 
Total votes: 47

tlombard
tl;dr
Posts: 5053
Joined: May 21 09, 12:41 pm

Re: Poll: Matheny's Job Security

Post by tlombard »

Honest question here because I don't really follow the Giants but I get the impression that most would consider Bruce B. out in San Francisco a better manager than Matheny by far... but what's the deal with the collapse of the Giants? The Giants and Cards were trading World Series appearances and facing off in the NLCS for a few years there but now they finished with the worst record in the majors this year and are way below .500 since the all star break last season.

Is he suddenly a bad manager?

User avatar
InvincibleCakeEater
GRB's obsessive compulsive baseball poster
Posts: 28035
Joined: October 12 07, 12:28 pm
Location: Raptured

Re: Poll: Matheny's Job Security

Post by InvincibleCakeEater »

tlombard wrote:Honest question here because I don't really follow the Giants but I get the impression that most would consider Bruce B. out in San Francisco a better manager than Matheny by far... but what's the deal with the collapse of the Giants? The Giants and Cards were trading World Series appearances and facing off in the NLCS for a few years there but now they finished with the worst record in the majors this year and are way below .500 since the all star break last season.

Is he suddenly a bad manager?
Haven't watched enough of him to decide one way or another, but they're bad because they're a poorly built team.

User avatar
Transmogrified Tiger
Puppy Murderer
Posts: 9334
Joined: April 25 06, 6:07 pm
Location: Across the River

Re: Poll: Matheny's Job Security

Post by Transmogrified Tiger »

The 2016 Giants got 10.4 fWAR from Bumgarner and Cueto in 66 starts. The 2017 Giants got 2.9 fWAR from Bumgarner and Cueto in 42 starts.

The 2016 Giants got 10.0 fWAR from full seasons of Crawford and Belt. The 2017 Giants got 4.3 fWAR from full seasons of Crawford and Belt.

That's a ton of productivity to lose from the top of your roster, and the Giants haven't had the farm system to offer up alternative impact players. Plus their bullpen continued to be the problem it was in 2016 even though they added Melancon.

I don't think Bochy is a managing savant and I don't think he's particularly a mastermind who brought together the even year championships, so at the same time I don't think he bears much blame for overseeing that core's downturn, even if it was a bit unexpected.

EDIT: Let's put it another way. Imagine losing 100% of Pham and Martinez's value from the 2017 Cards without being able to replace their playing time. No manager in the world is going to make that team successful. What Bochy dealt with was worse than that from a value standpoint.
Last edited by Transmogrified Tiger on October 7 17, 11:02 am, edited 2 times in total.

User avatar
CardsofSTL
All Hail the GDT Master
Posts: 47817
Joined: April 26 11, 6:06 am
Location: Columbus, OH

Re: Poll: Matheny's Job Security

Post by CardsofSTL »

I have heard people talking about Bochy as a great manager ever since he won his first game managing the Padres it seems. I don't see anything particularly special about his management skills; but at the same time I don't see anything he does that is particularly detrimental to the club. I would have to follow West coast teams a bit closer to be 100 percent sure; but I think he is a capable manager when he has talent. I would argue there are some managers; one in particular comes to mind that is currently managing in the postseason; that when they have talent they abuse it or squander it. I don't think Bochy is that kind of guy.

TimChopsula
Veteran Player
Posts: 712
Joined: August 8 16, 10:48 pm

Re: Poll: Matheny's Job Security

Post by TimChopsula »

tlombard wrote:Honest question here because I don't really follow the Giants but I get the impression that most would consider Bruce B. out in San Francisco a better manager than Matheny by far... but what's the deal with the collapse of the Giants? The Giants and Cards were trading World Series appearances and facing off in the NLCS for a few years there but now they finished with the worst record in the majors this year and are way below .500 since the all star break last season.

Is he suddenly a bad manager?
What TTiger said probably explains a lot of what happened, but here were the other common talking points in the Bay Area this summer:

-The Giants have not evolved with the game over the past couple of years. While most other teams have become homer-happy, the Giants have been seriously lacking in power.
-Their front office has presented the team as a pitching/defensive team, but neither of those facets of their game were good.
-Crawford lost his sister-in-law early in the season, and that kind of loss can understandably have a big impact on one's professional performance, regardless of their line of work.
-Melancon supposedly created a big rift in the clubhouse. Word is that he came into the clubhouse with a me-first attitude, ultimately cancelling the bullpen's tradition of stretching and working out together. This changed the clubhouse atmosphere, close on the heels of another big change in clubhouse chemistry that happened in 2016 when Matt Duffy was traded. Things got so bad that the team supposedly picked up Sandoval just to try to infuse some positive clubhouse energy (and to sell some Panda hats).

Largely, most of this isn't on Bochy; they lost key bullpen pieces (Affeldt, Casilla, good-Romo, etc.) and didn't adequately replace them. Pence is getting old, Posey isn't protected in the lineup, ect. That said, one could easily argue that the clubhouse chemistry problems are Bochy's responsibility.

The Giants have a lot of holes, without many internal solutions... their farm is nothing to get excited about. The locals are beginning to feel like a complete rebuild will be necessary for the Giants to return to glory.

Spider John
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 10619
Joined: May 18 06, 10:09 pm
Location: East of the middle of West Tennessee

Re: Poll: Matheny's Job Security

Post by Spider John »

Reading the highlights of Hummel's chat, and he said flatly that if Cards miss the playoffs Matheny would not be back. He doesn't say that his opinion, or if someone has told him that. Odd that he would be that direct about it.

User avatar
Hoot45
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 4008
Joined: October 8 14, 11:41 am

Re: Poll: Matheny's Job Security

Post by Hoot45 »

I'm sorry guys, I couldn't resist.
TimJomsula wrote:The Giants have not evolved with the game over the past couple of years. While most other teams have become homer-happy, the Giants have been seriously lacking in power.
Sounds familiar. See: Aggressive pursuit of Stanton.
TimJomsula wrote:Their front office has presented the team as a pitching/defensive team, but neither of those facets of their game were good.
Sounds familiar. See: Focus on pitching and defense in Jupiter, spring 2017.
TimJomsula wrote:Crawford lost his sister-in-law early in the season, and that kind of loss can understandably have a big impact on one's professional performance, regardless of their line of work.
Sounds familiar. See: Stephen Piscotty.
TimJomsula wrote:Pence is getting old, Posey isn't protected in the lineup, ect. That said, one could easily argue that the clubhouse chemistry problems are Bochy's responsibility.
Sounds familiar. See: Aging stars, aggressive pursuit of a middle of the order bat.

MDCardsFan
All-Star
Posts: 2008
Joined: May 24 06, 10:48 am
Location: Annapolis, MD

Re: Poll: Matheny's Job Security

Post by MDCardsFan »

Spider John wrote:Reading the highlights of Hummel's chat, and he said flatly that if Cards miss the playoffs Matheny would not be back. He doesn't say that his opinion, or if someone has told him that. Odd that he would be that direct about it.

If they go out and spend 300 Million on Stanton, Matheny's leash will be shorter than ever.

TimChopsula
Veteran Player
Posts: 712
Joined: August 8 16, 10:48 pm

Re: Poll: Matheny's Job Security

Post by TimChopsula »

Hoot45 wrote:I'm sorry guys, I couldn't resist.
TimJomsula wrote:The Giants have not evolved with the game over the past couple of years. While most other teams have become homer-happy, the Giants have been seriously lacking in power.
Sounds familiar. See: Aggressive pursuit of Stanton.
TimJomsula wrote:Their front office has presented the team as a pitching/defensive team, but neither of those facets of their game were good.
Sounds familiar. See: Focus on pitching and defense in Jupiter, spring 2017.
TimJomsula wrote:Crawford lost his sister-in-law early in the season, and that kind of loss can understandably have a big impact on one's professional performance, regardless of their line of work.
Sounds familiar. See: Stephen Piscotty.
TimJomsula wrote:Pence is getting old, Posey isn't protected in the lineup, ect. That said, one could easily argue that the clubhouse chemistry problems are Bochy's responsibility.
Sounds familiar. See: Aging stars, aggressive pursuit of a middle of the order bat.
Well done. Somehow, I didn't recognize those parallels when I typed my original message.

User avatar
Jocephus
99% conan clips
Posts: 63660
Joined: April 18 06, 5:14 pm

Re: Poll: Matheny's Job Security

Post by Jocephus »


Post Reply