Page 2 of 6

Re: Build the ultimate Cardinal team for $33

Posted: February 1 19, 1:07 pm
by MrCrowesGarden
TGantz wrote:C-Matheny $1
1B-Pujols $5
2B-Wong $1
3B-Rolen $4
SS-Smith $5
LF-Holliday $3
CF-McGee $4
RF-Musial $5
SP-Carpenter $3
RP-Rosenthal $1
MGR- Matheny $1

Player-Manager Mike Matheny leads the Cards to the WS and saves DeWallet's money

Edit- I have a free dollar because I counted Matheny twice. Upgrade McGee to Edmonds
Hell no you don't, that's the Matheny tax.

Re: Build the ultimate Cardinal team for $33

Posted: February 1 19, 1:12 pm
by haltz
You can make a case for Pujols I guess, but Mize for $3 is definitely the best pick at 1B - 171 OPS+ as a Cardinal. McGwire is a terrible value in the middle of those two at $4.

Re: Build the ultimate Cardinal team for $33

Posted: February 1 19, 1:14 pm
by CardsofSTL
haltz wrote:You can make a case for Pujols I guess, but Mize for $3 is definitely the best pick at 1B - 171 OPS+ as a Cardinal. McGwire is a terrible value in the middle of those two at $4.
I guess it depends on if you are getting 1998 Big Mac or career Big Mac...and as Fat said earlier; career numbers you go for Mize. But I wouldn't begrudge anyone taking Pujols when you think about this as a Cardinal team; you are thinking about the player in their Cardinal career.

Re: Build the ultimate Cardinal team for $33

Posted: February 1 19, 1:22 pm
by MrCrowesGarden
I definitely built my team just by feel, it didn't seem a lot of fun to go diving into B-R and really put a ton of thought into this for me anyways.

I'm not going to say there are no wrong answers on building your team because there definitely are, but there's a lot of right ones too.

Re: Build the ultimate Cardinal team for $33

Posted: February 1 19, 1:29 pm
by TheoSqua
C - Matheny - $1
1b - Mize - $3
2b - Hornsby - $5
SS - Ozzie - $5
3b - Carpenter - $3
RF - Musial - $5
CF - Pham - $1
LF - Holliday - $3

SP - Carpenter -$3
RP - Rosenthal - $1

Manager - Red - $3

Re: Build the ultimate Cardinal team for $33

Posted: February 1 19, 1:33 pm
by Fat_Bulldog
I'm not playing. I wanted Rod Booker and Tim Jones to round out my middle infield.

Re: Build the ultimate Cardinal team for $33

Posted: February 1 19, 1:34 pm
by haltz
I'm looking at some 5 year peaks on BRef and that makes Pujols's case a stronger one. He edges Mize by about 10 WAR.

Hornsby has a video game peak of 49.9 WAR from 1921-25, .402(!)/.474/.690 204 OPS+. Pay him his $5 already.

Re: Build the ultimate Cardinal team for $33

Posted: February 1 19, 1:36 pm
by CardsofSTL
haltz wrote:I'm looking at some 5 year peaks on BRef and that makes Pujols's case a stronger one. He edges Mize by about 10 WAR.

Hornsby has a video game peak of 49.9 WAR from 1921-25, .402(!)/.474/.690 204 OPS+. Pay him his $5 already.
Hornsby gets his fiver as a player; but as a manager he loses value.

Re: Build the ultimate Cardinal team for $33

Posted: February 1 19, 2:10 pm
by cardsfantx
I’m an owner of today; give me all the $1 guys and I’ll pocket the rest

Re: Build the ultimate Cardinal team for $33

Posted: February 1 19, 5:39 pm
by CardsofSTL
cardsfantx wrote:I’m an owner of today; give me all the $1 guys and I’ll pocket the rest
Shaddup