I've been offered Johnny Damon, Garrett Jones, Carlos Zambrano, and Jake Peavy for Ichiro Suzuki and Jonathan Broxton. What say you, GRB?
I'd probably do it if you can stand to lose Suzuki in terms of counting stats.
Jason Heyward and Yunel Escobar for Hanley Ramirez and Rod Barajas.
The guy with Heyward is in 4th place one point out of 3rd with horrible catchers (2 starting on each team in the league). The guy with HanRam is 6th, 7 points out of 3rd place with Michael Stanton and Strausburg weighing him down right now making it tough to keep up in counting stats.
In a keeper league I could see the benefit to having Heyward, but HanRam is probably more valuable for the next couple years at least (assuming Heyward continues to show and improve). Barajas isn't great, but if you're starting two catchers on each team he has a lot of value...I'd probably do it depending on what my OF counting stats looked like on either team.
Now for mine.....
I've been offered B.J. Upton and Jake Peavy for Adam Jones and Dan Haren. I'm in a 12 team all ML rotisserie league with the standard counting stats. I currently have Roy Halladay, Mark Buehrle, Scott Baker, and David Price as my other starters. I could use B.J., but am I giving too much?