Socnorb11 wrote:Nobody really likes him, so they're not going to give him the benfit of the doubt (for better or worse). I think we can all agree on that.
I agree with this and would be concerned if I thought Jay gave a [expletive]. He clearly doesn't, so I'm assuming it won't affect his play moving forward.
Socnorb11 wrote: He certainly looked like he had checked out mentally.
This is the kind of thing I take exception to. Why is this an acceptable assumption? You don't know him. You don't know how to read him. Just because someone has a dumb, blank look on their face doesn't bely their actual mind set.
His history tells me that he had "probably" checked out. There's the John Lynch story. There's the Shanahan/Elway story. Cutler seems to lose interest in what's going on around him pretty easily.
I think your summary above is pretty accurate. He doesn't care. I don't think there's much that he DOES care about. He's an overhyped player without much personality. I think it's pretty easy to see why people don't care much for him.
InvincibleCakeEater wrote:You hear more about Cutler because he doesn't like the media. And if you don't like the media, they don't like you.
And the fans don't like you when you're not very good. Chicago has embraced many a bad boy. Cutler is not one of them.
I'm more interested in why it is that players and former players seem to really not like him. Justified or not, they all leapt at the chance to rag on him. And that doesn't have anything to do with how he treats the media.
I'd give actual players and former players' words and opinions more credence over that of fans and the media combined.
Freed Roger wrote:Cutler's ability to run was a big part of his game
If cutler comes out of this injury with any less mobility- his chances of ever bercoming a top shelf QB are gone
He should recover fine, but Cutler's ability to scramble has never been anything to write home about, at least during his time here. Arm strength might be his greatest asset, and if he improves his footwork and his reads, he won't need to scramble.
Freed Roger wrote:Cutler's ability to run was a big part of his game
If cutler comes out of this injury with any less mobility- his chances of ever bercoming a top shelf QB are gone
He should recover fine, but Cutler's ability to scramble has never been anything to write home about, at least during his time here. Arm strength might be his greatest asset, and if he improves his footwork and his reads, he won't need to scramble.
He never was a Fran Tarkenton by any stretch. But if he were to become more of a statue in the pocket - he'll be completely toast -ala Jeff George, a guy who had great arm but no mobility and was also the petulant type that opponents loved to hit.
Also -the nature of the NFL is to attack weakness. Like sharks when blood is in the water-defensive coordinators will be coming after him more than ever.
And sometimes it has been said offensive lineman can be less motivated to block for certain QBs. If there is any credibility to this urban legend, then I would think Cutler would be one of those certain QBs.
Some of you people need to learn when you play the most important position in the NFL, you are compensated for it and it is up to the player to act like a leader among men and meet your teammate expectations. Many fine Quarterbacks have played with much more serious injuries than Cutler had.
Cutler wasn't going to get it done against Green Bay whether he had a injury or not. He was awful and it is my opinion he used the injury as an excuse to leave the game (regardless of the spin from the coaches, doctors, players, media).
I'm sorry but you are wrong fan. Plenty of reason not to like Cutler, but it sounds like he had a moderate to severe MCL (grade II) - enough to make an NFL player not be able to perform at the level he would need to to complete. You can work through pain, and well paid players damn better well work through paing. But when you are talking about the stability of a joint - and I have no doubt that the stability of the knee was compromised - there is no toughing that out.
I'm hearing so much information about this it's driving me nuts .. yes he "only" had a sprain. Willis McGhee in the Orange Bowl also had "only" a sprain. Say what you want about Cutler in the first half, but it's ridiculous to criticize him for not playing in the second half. Now if he had a mild sprain (I or maybe a mild II) then I would be [expletive] too. But the reports i'm hearing is that he had a clear grade II sprain - one that takes 4 weeks to heal.
I don't like Cutler. I think he's head case full of himself, and he may never live up to his physical talents because of some of that. But he didn't wimp out. He was hurt. Simple as that.
jim wrote:I don't like Cutler. I think he's head case full of himself, and he may never live up to his physical talents because of some of that. But he didn't wimp out. He was hurt. Simple as that.
This pretty well sums up my opinion about this whole thing.
I think he was hurt, but I'm still skeptical about how badly he was hurt.
On his last play of the first half, he backpedalled, planted, and fired a 40+ yard rope that was intercepted.
On his first pass attempt in the second half, he backpedalled HARD and threw an incomplete pass.
He was able to move laterally. He was able to plant. He was able to throw.
If he was a good quarterback, I think they may have given him a chance to play. But considering how awful he had been to that point, I don't blame them for telling him to have a seat.