"We recommend taking it to the dealer..."

The forum for ranting, raving, complaining and praising
Fat Strat
Official GRB Sponsor of Larry Bigbie
Posts: 28010
Joined: April 17 06, 9:16 pm
Location: No. 16 on the Cards Top 15 Prospect List

Re: "We recommend taking it to the dealer..."

Post by Fat Strat »

jim wrote:I'm a little surprised you got the take to the dealer comment. Cooling systems in a old Buick? You aren't replacing a transmission in a Mercedes for crying out loud. I really don't know what to tell you, sometimes you are just at the mercy of whatever. I'd be kind of ticked that I dropped $300 at a place and when it wasn't fixed they just kind of shrugged their shoulders and told you to take it somewhere else.
That's along the same lines that I was thinking, Jim -- and what inspired the rant. I just got back from the shop and talked to them. I wish I understood this stuff more, but they basically said that they were baffled by what was going on. There was no evidence of the coolant system leaking, of any gasket problems, or that kind of thing. The system would just build up pressure, they would bleed it off, but it would start heating up again... it was happening intermittently, which fits with what I was experiencing.

Anyway, they didn't charge me for the new thermostat or the coolant flush!

They said it could be a blockage somewhere that they weren't able to find, but normally flushing the system out takes care of those blockagaes. The dealer, they suggested, might have a bulletin or info that they don't have and be able to better tell me exactly what's going on right away; whereas they would have to start ripping things apart hoping they found something.

So, my problem isn't fixed, but I'm in a much better mood about it knowing that I haven't already dropped $300 into it.

jim
Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
Posts: 50393
Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm

Re: "We recommend taking it to the dealer..."

Post by jim »

Fat Strat wrote:
jim wrote:I'm a little surprised you got the take to the dealer comment. Cooling systems in a old Buick? You aren't replacing a transmission in a Mercedes for crying out loud. I really don't know what to tell you, sometimes you are just at the mercy of whatever. I'd be kind of ticked that I dropped $300 at a place and when it wasn't fixed they just kind of shrugged their shoulders and told you to take it somewhere else.
That's along the same lines that I was thinking, Jim -- and what inspired the rant. I just got back from the shop and talked to them. I wish I understood this stuff more, but they basically said that they were baffled by what was going on. There was no evidence of the coolant system leaking, of any gasket problems, or that kind of thing. The system would just build up pressure, they would bleed it off, but it would start heating up again... it was happening intermittently, which fits with what I was experiencing.

Anyway, they didn't charge me for the new thermostat or the coolant flush!

They said it could be a blockage somewhere that they weren't able to find, but normally flushing the system out takes care of those blockagaes. The dealer, they suggested, might have a bulletin or info that they don't have and be able to better tell me exactly what's going on right away; whereas they would have to start ripping things apart hoping they found something.

So, my problem isn't fixed, but I'm in a much better mood about it knowing that I haven't already dropped $300 into it.
Well then it sounds like they were honest by giving you the money back. It is going to be a bit more expensive at a dealer, but if you don't have an ace mechanic that might be your best bet. You almost have to do it, because trading/selling a car that doesn't work is going to cost you as well. Basically this breakdown has cost you, so I think you just have to get it fixed and then try to look for a good time to make a change.

But really fat, you are too young to be driving a Buick. You need to start a thread when you go looking for your next car so your friends here can put you in something proper (just kidding Buick fans...).

Fat Strat
Official GRB Sponsor of Larry Bigbie
Posts: 28010
Joined: April 17 06, 9:16 pm
Location: No. 16 on the Cards Top 15 Prospect List

Re: "We recommend taking it to the dealer..."

Post by Fat Strat »

Basically this breakdown has cost you, so I think you just have to get it fixed and then try to look for a good time to make a change.
You're absolutely right that this has cost us regardless; I'm curious to see what the dealer says about repair costs before I mentallly commit to either repairing it or getting something different.
But really fat, you are too young to be driving a Buick.
I know, I know. I drew the line at "no minivans" and the Rendezvous gave us comparable functionality without the "van" label. We lived in Tulsa for 10 years and both my wife and I had 20+ min. commutes. The Rendezvous was a good price, had a third seat, still under warranty, and got decent gas mileage for an early '00's mid-sized SUV (24 mpg). Was a car that I felt we could run into the ground commutting.

We've done that (by GM standards). Now we live 5 mins from my workplace. My wife works from home and only drives back and forth to pick up the kids at their various schools -- which are all within a few miles of us. My next vehicle was going to be something "more" than any of our vehicles before.

In fact, the more that I've thought about it today, the more I've decided that I don't need to replace this vehicle for awhile regardless of repairs. I've been stressing over transportation since Sunday because my wife is out of town on business, but once she gets back (tomorrow night), there's really no reason that we can't share a vehicle until we get to the point where we're ready to pull the trigger on a new(er) car.

User avatar
StatmanCrothers
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 6461
Joined: April 17 06, 6:50 am
Location: Boston burbs
Contact:

Re: "We recommend taking it to the dealer..."

Post by StatmanCrothers »

if your radiator is leaking, you can add horse manure and the overheating will stop for a while. the horse manure dissolves--sort of--and when it tries to leak out the leaky places it clogs them up and the leak is fixed. You can keep adding horse manure for quite a while before it totally gums up the gears, so to speak. On the farm growing up in the 80's we had an old green Chevy we didn't want to sink any money in to for repairs, and my dad kept it going for an extra year or two with this trick.

PS it helps if you have horses.

Post Reply