Rant: Yale M.D. somehow stymied by insurance forms
- StatmanCrothers
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 6461
- Joined: April 17 06, 6:50 am
- Location: Boston burbs
- Contact:
Rant: Yale M.D. somehow stymied by insurance forms
Christ on a cracker.
We just moved to Mass. from Ill. in December.
A new doctor, an M.D. supposedly a grad of Yale school of Medicine according to the benefits web site (not why I chose her, it was location nearby, but still... some of them get their degrees from Rangoon and other places I wonder about)
Blah blah blah long story, doctor is doing her own paper work, but apparently doesn't want to try very hard to get it right.
Upshot, she's now sending me a bill for $450 saying the claims have been denied twice each.
Now admittedly, medical insurance is complex. They have different addresses for different things, tons of forms, etc.
I called the CORRECT phone number and they say "yes i'm covered" and "yes i'm in the system." and "did you tell her she needs to use the member's SSN?" and "does she know tos end it to such and such address?" .... I thought I had walked her through all these things, last time I was there we called the number TOGETHER on my phone and she jotted all the info down.
Apparently, she only submitted one claim to this correct address, and must have filled it out wrong. I called and had to get all nicey-nice with her "please if you could just call this number..." ... the whole time she had never CALLED, and still I have to beg her to call the number. Once I get it taken care of I'm dropping her like a hot potato and switching to some Harvard doctor. Or Rangoon.
We just moved to Mass. from Ill. in December.
A new doctor, an M.D. supposedly a grad of Yale school of Medicine according to the benefits web site (not why I chose her, it was location nearby, but still... some of them get their degrees from Rangoon and other places I wonder about)
Blah blah blah long story, doctor is doing her own paper work, but apparently doesn't want to try very hard to get it right.
Upshot, she's now sending me a bill for $450 saying the claims have been denied twice each.
Now admittedly, medical insurance is complex. They have different addresses for different things, tons of forms, etc.
I called the CORRECT phone number and they say "yes i'm covered" and "yes i'm in the system." and "did you tell her she needs to use the member's SSN?" and "does she know tos end it to such and such address?" .... I thought I had walked her through all these things, last time I was there we called the number TOGETHER on my phone and she jotted all the info down.
Apparently, she only submitted one claim to this correct address, and must have filled it out wrong. I called and had to get all nicey-nice with her "please if you could just call this number..." ... the whole time she had never CALLED, and still I have to beg her to call the number. Once I get it taken care of I'm dropping her like a hot potato and switching to some Harvard doctor. Or Rangoon.
- sighyoung
- Mayor of GRB
- Posts: 38643
- Joined: April 17 06, 7:42 pm
- Location: Louisville
Re: Rant: Yale M.D. somehow stymied by insurance forms
She doesn't have office staff to do this? That's pretty bad.StatmanCrothers wrote:Christ on a cracker.
We just moved to Mass. from Ill. in December.
A new doctor, an M.D. supposedly a grad of Yale school of Medicine according to the benefits web site (not why I chose her, it was location nearby, but still... some of them get their degrees from Rangoon and other places I wonder about)
Blah blah blah long story, doctor is doing her own paper work, but apparently doesn't want to try very hard to get it right.
Upshot, she's now sending me a bill for $450 saying the claims have been denied twice each.
Now admittedly, medical insurance is complex. They have different addresses for different things, tons of forms, etc.
I called the CORRECT phone number and they say "yes i'm covered" and "yes i'm in the system." and "did you tell her she needs to use the member's SSN?" and "does she know tos end it to such and such address?" .... I thought I had walked her through all these things, last time I was there we called the number TOGETHER on my phone and she jotted all the info down.
Apparently, she only submitted one claim to this correct address, and must have filled it out wrong. I called and had to get all nicey-nice with her "please if you could just call this number..." ... the whole time she had never CALLED, and still I have to beg her to call the number. Once I get it taken care of I'm dropping her like a hot potato and switching to some Harvard doctor. Or Rangoon.
- clevername
- Bringer of FRBG
- Posts: 10380
- Joined: April 16 06, 7:13 pm
- Location: Alabama
Re: Rant: Yale M.D. somehow stymied by insurance forms
I wouldn't know where to start on how to get the insurance company to actually send me money for my services beyond I mark an x on the billing sheet, sign it, and it goes into the magical part of the office that handles all that stuff.
I understand some solo practices have the need for small staffs. I was in a solo practice for a little while. We had myself, the nurse, and the receptionist. I still didn't handle any of the insurance filing then (though I probably should have been more hands on than I was there).
Does this doc answer her own phone calls to the office? Is she the only one there?
I understand some solo practices have the need for small staffs. I was in a solo practice for a little while. We had myself, the nurse, and the receptionist. I still didn't handle any of the insurance filing then (though I probably should have been more hands on than I was there).
Does this doc answer her own phone calls to the office? Is she the only one there?
- StatmanCrothers
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 6461
- Joined: April 17 06, 6:50 am
- Location: Boston burbs
- Contact:
Re: Rant: Yale M.D. somehow stymied by insurance forms
Pretty much. Shoe-string budget I guess. It's a psychiatric practice; I go so I can get my ADD meds.clevername wrote:I wouldn't know where to start on how to get the insurance company to actually send me money for my services beyond I mark an x on the billing sheet, sign it, and it goes into the magical part of the office that handles all that stuff.
I understand some solo practices have the need for small staffs. I was in a solo practice for a little while. We had myself, the nurse, and the receptionist. I still didn't handle any of the insurance filing then (though I probably should have been more hands on than I was there).
Does this doc answer her own phone calls to the office? Is she the only one there?
Maybe she had someone and decided she couldn't afford them any longer. Or she just branched out on her own from a group practice. In any case, I don't think she has a clue how to handle it when there is any kind of problem with the claim. Or just doesn't want to deal with it probably. Its easier to pressure the patient with a full billing I suppose, and get them to do the sorting out.
- JackofDiamonds
- Bringer of Boston Baked Blue Balls
- Posts: 15010
- Joined: April 16 06, 9:15 pm
Re: Rant: Yale M.D. somehow stymied by insurance forms
How's the rest of her work? Once you get this settled, you've already put the grunt work in, you might as well work with her.StatmanCrothers wrote:Pretty much. Shoe-string budget I guess. It's a psychiatric practice; I go so I can get my ADD meds.clevername wrote:I wouldn't know where to start on how to get the insurance company to actually send me money for my services beyond I mark an x on the billing sheet, sign it, and it goes into the magical part of the office that handles all that stuff.
I understand some solo practices have the need for small staffs. I was in a solo practice for a little while. We had myself, the nurse, and the receptionist. I still didn't handle any of the insurance filing then (though I probably should have been more hands on than I was there).
Does this doc answer her own phone calls to the office? Is she the only one there?
Maybe she had someone and decided she couldn't afford them any longer. Or she just branched out on her own from a group practice. In any case, I don't think she has a clue how to handle it when there is any kind of problem with the claim. Or just doesn't want to deal with it probably. Its easier to pressure the patient with a full billing I suppose, and get them to do the sorting out.
- wart57
- just can't quit you.
- Posts: 25076
- Joined: April 18 06, 4:33 pm
- Location: Lost
- StatmanCrothers
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 6461
- Joined: April 17 06, 6:50 am
- Location: Boston burbs
- Contact:
Re: Rant: Yale M.D. somehow stymied by insurance forms
so the doctor called them. hooray.
however. i just talked to the claims department and it turns out once she started sending them to the correct place, the problems were all at the insurance end.
apparently we simultaneously have an expired account (from Illinois) and a new account (for Massachusetts). Although its the same account, really.
but their automated system is automatically processing all claims received according to the old account and then telling the doctors the claim is denied.
If the doctor resubmits, it is simply seen as a duplicate and is not reprocessed.
So the new system is supposed to be:
1) submit the claim
2) wait for it to get denied
3) call up and ask someone to fix it.
Every time? Ridiculous. I'm supposed to get a call-back from a supervisor. There has to be a way to tell their system to ignore the old account. The only "account number" is the SSN so that's the same for both accounts.
this can't be the first time an employee moved to a new state.
however. i just talked to the claims department and it turns out once she started sending them to the correct place, the problems were all at the insurance end.
apparently we simultaneously have an expired account (from Illinois) and a new account (for Massachusetts). Although its the same account, really.
but their automated system is automatically processing all claims received according to the old account and then telling the doctors the claim is denied.
If the doctor resubmits, it is simply seen as a duplicate and is not reprocessed.
So the new system is supposed to be:
1) submit the claim
2) wait for it to get denied
3) call up and ask someone to fix it.
Every time? Ridiculous. I'm supposed to get a call-back from a supervisor. There has to be a way to tell their system to ignore the old account. The only "account number" is the SSN so that's the same for both accounts.
this can't be the first time an employee moved to a new state.
- lukethedrifter
- darjeeling sipping elite
- Posts: 37260
- Joined: October 17 06, 11:19 am
- Location: Huis Clos
Re: Rant: Yale M.D. somehow stymied by insurance forms
ftr, Bill Haas went to Yale law so there's only so much they can be responsible for.






