Plagiarism
- ghostrunner
- GOAT
- Posts: 30873
- Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm
Re: Plagiarism
Seems like it ought to be so easy to spot check this stuff though. Just type some random selections in a search engine and you're likely to get something if it's been copied.
- TheoSqua
- Next Gen Wart
- Posts: 8951
- Joined: April 22 06, 6:53 pm
- Location: St. Louis
- Contact:
Re: Plagiarism
I once had a politics class that had us write a 4 page book report on some book detailing the Presidential run of John Kerry. Most boring book I've ever read. I just couldn't get into it and struggled to find any competent points to discuss on the book.
So I ended up writing an article that basically started off saying how terrible and boring the book was and the difficulty I had getting any valid analysis out of the book because of how poorly written it was on a rather uninteresting subject. I made a couple weak analytical points and a very bland conclusion. I figured if I got a D or C on the report (was 25% of our grade) i'd still pass and be good to go.
I get my paper back and the guy gave me an A. I asked him about it and he told me that over half the essays turned in ripped off the opinions of the only review article that came up in a google search. So he gave everyone who didn't rip off the ideas of that article an A.
Win one for being honest and lazy! (And yes, you can tell it was a fluff class lol)
So I ended up writing an article that basically started off saying how terrible and boring the book was and the difficulty I had getting any valid analysis out of the book because of how poorly written it was on a rather uninteresting subject. I made a couple weak analytical points and a very bland conclusion. I figured if I got a D or C on the report (was 25% of our grade) i'd still pass and be good to go.
I get my paper back and the guy gave me an A. I asked him about it and he told me that over half the essays turned in ripped off the opinions of the only review article that came up in a google search. So he gave everyone who didn't rip off the ideas of that article an A.
Win one for being honest and lazy! (And yes, you can tell it was a fluff class lol)
- sighyoung
- Mayor of GRB
- Posts: 38643
- Joined: April 17 06, 7:42 pm
- Location: Louisville
Re: Plagiarism
That was pretty much it. It was so obvious it was sad. The better students would simply cite a scholar and riff on it. "So-and-so says this, and this is how I can extend that idea." I told them that (I'm not sure she showed up to hear it). This student, though, uses all her ingenuity to put in minimal effort, and then sneak around. She's a student who would put in more time arguing about a grade than writing the paper.ghostrunner wrote:Seems like it ought to be so easy to spot check this stuff though. Just type some random selections in a search engine and you're likely to get something if it's been copied.
Don't get me wrong--I understand that my class isn't necessarily a priority. That doesn't bother me at all. But her phoniness, in particular, seems to be the sign of a problem--insecurity, arrogance, I'm not sure what.
- sighyoung
- Mayor of GRB
- Posts: 38643
- Joined: April 17 06, 7:42 pm
- Location: Louisville
Re: Plagiarism
Some parts of the university use a similar system, but our department doesn't. There was a question of intellectual property with some sites that gave faculty pause. I'm also in a department with a Ph.D. program in Composition and Rhetoric, and some plagiarism issues are shades of gray rather than black-and-white. The composition faculty is kind of against it--I never follow their arguments, though.cardinalkarp wrote:Does the university you work for use the site http://www.turnitin.com? At lindenwood university they made us submit our papers through this which would basically eliminate any possible chance at plagiarism. This site would compare your paper to any other paper/sources that were out on the Internet. Made it nearly impossible to plagerise. Our teacher once showed us a handout of how our papers look to him after we turn them in, any sequence of words that came from another source would be listed on the draft. Obviously, short sequences are fine, but if he started to see paragraphs that were nearly identical except for the changing of a few words/ideas you were nailed.
As ghostrunner said, a lot is easy to catch on Google nowadays. But now it means I have to rethink assignments. I was reluctant to let students write a take-home exam this time. Won't do it anymore. I'll need to develop some assignments very specific to the class (not too difficult to do), but I also typically let students prepare for exam questions a week in advance. I've always done that. May not be able to anymore.
- G. Keenan
- Sucking on the Rally Nipple
- Posts: 23719
- Joined: April 16 06, 6:03 pm
- Location: Chicago
- Tambourine Man
- accepts no jimitators
- Posts: 11413
- Joined: April 21 06, 3:31 pm
- Location: I Read the News Today Oh, boy
Re: Plagiarism
Hah, those are good.
The potato literally encouraged the Irish to overbreed.
- G. Keenan
- Sucking on the Rally Nipple
- Posts: 23719
- Joined: April 16 06, 6:03 pm
- Location: Chicago
Re: Plagiarism
SuperDuperCardsFan wrote:Hah, those are good.The potato literally encouraged the Irish to overbreed.
Please keep in mind while reading the following; I am in no way trying to be racist. It may come off like that, but it is just to support what I think. Instead of accepting that Hispanics and white will be one, I want Hispanics to stop coming to America, and go back to where they came from. This sounds bad, but I just wants best for me and everyone I know.
-
MrSaigon
Re: Plagiarism
If y'all know any literary agents, here's and exerpt from this memwar I'm writing about being a academic guy:
I'm usually a very mild-mannered teacher, and I always stress to my students that if they run into a problem with the class or any papers that I assign, that they should speak to me. I invite them to give me drafts to look at, and even give them the chance to revise for full credit.
But this semester I had a student who never bothered to read the assigned material, never bothered to meet with me about her drafts, often didn't come to class, and lo! here she comes with three revised papers. I take a look at one--it starts out poorly, then all of a sudden, the prose is great. Big long words, flowing sentences, and I'm thinking . . . wait . . . you don't write this. You don't think like this. Let me Google this . . .
So far, I've caught her plagiarizing from five different sources, and this is just the tip of the iceberg. Two different papers are plagiarized, and I haven't even gotten to her final paper. Worse yet, she's a real phony-baloney, and I fully expect crocodile tears. But off to the dean she goes.
I'm usually a very mild-mannered teacher, and I always stress to my students that if they run into a problem with the class or any papers that I assign, that they should speak to me. I invite them to give me drafts to look at, and even give them the chance to revise for full credit.
But this semester I had a student who never bothered to read the assigned material, never bothered to meet with me about her drafts, often didn't come to class, and lo! here she comes with three revised papers. I take a look at one--it starts out poorly, then all of a sudden, the prose is great. Big long words, flowing sentences, and I'm thinking . . . wait . . . you don't write this. You don't think like this. Let me Google this . . .
So far, I've caught her plagiarizing from five different sources, and this is just the tip of the iceberg. Two different papers are plagiarized, and I haven't even gotten to her final paper. Worse yet, she's a real phony-baloney, and I fully expect crocodile tears. But off to the dean she goes.
- ghostrunner
- GOAT
- Posts: 30873
- Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm
Re: Plagiarism
This is the best. General ignorance garnished with misspellings.
The rebel and onion armies showed grose negligence by having many of their battles right inside national parks, like Gettysburg.
- cards2468
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 14745
- Joined: October 28 06, 11:10 pm
- Location: LOVE IT OR LEAVE IT
Re: Plagiarism
lol, it's very well possible he wrote that just to be a dickghostrunner wrote:This is the best. General ignorance garnished with misspellings.
The rebel and onion armies showed grose negligence by having many of their battles right inside national parks, like Gettysburg.
I had a paper I wrote in high school where I thought the mandated topic was ridiculous, so I decided to be ridiculous with my point of view. The teacher told me the writing quality was A material, but she gave me a D because "your concepts are communist".

