Number of examples where TheMiddle gave some form of validity to GRB posters opinions:
...
I agree w/ Michael that the board should be civil and gentlemanly.
I agree w/ you, Theo, that there are a lot more people giving validity to what I'm saying that I'm giving validity to what they're saying. Mostly because I think the defense of the big boobie thread is silly. And the idea that a double-standard does not exist w/r/t acceptable behavior/what's offensive or inappropriate is equally silly. The idea that there are two sets of rules, one for Social and one for BT, also strikes me as silly. How do you say, hey, over here it's ok to objectify women, it's ok to talk about drunken sex with your brother's girlfriend or whatever, but hey, over here, in BT, we insist on civility?
I still can't figure out why people insist the tone of the baseball forum has changed so much. I can't tell the difference, other than that we are all so frustrated at the team's performance that the complaints about the organization's whipping boys are harder to take as jokes.
It's also worth noting that the master of the passive-aggressive attack on other posters resides on this forum, and I'd wager has never received a single PM from a mod.
TheoSqua wrote:Number of examples where TheMiddle gave some form of validity to GRB posters opinions:
...
I agree w/ you, Theo, that there are a lot more people giving validity to what I'm saying that I'm giving validity to what they're saying. Mostly because I think the defense of the big boobie thread is silly.
Hahaha. Saw this coming a mile away. Really, why would you need to give credence to other people's views when you're right? Especially when discussing a topic where there are clear right and wrong answers, like what tone and rules should exist on a message board.
themiddle54 wrote: And the idea that a double-standard does not exist w/r/t acceptable behavior/what's offensive or inappropriate is equally silly. The idea that there are two sets of rules, one for Social and one for BT, also strikes me as silly. How do you say, hey, over here it's ok to objectify women, it's ok to talk about drunken sex with your brother's girlfriend or whatever, but hey, over here, in BT, we insist on civility?
Dude. Grb exists for the baseball forum. Its a place for very well-worded, logical guys like you to post awesome comments about Cards baseball. And we casual Cards fans to post loud one liners in GDTs.
The social forum is a bonus, a great place for a bunch of dudes (and some very awesome women) to talk about non Cards stuff to people with a mild connection to them. I don't read the financial thread because its not my thing. Poster X doesn't read the movies thread for the same reason. just enjoy some fun baseball chatter, post in a thread or three that interest you otherwise (I'm drunk at a Hawkeye bar!) And have fun.
greenback44 wrote:I think it's a discussion worth having, whether babes threads (and drunken threads, for that matter) are appropriate for the forum.
That said, the point of discussion boards is, well, discussion, and I'm not sure smut is fundamentally contradictory to healthy discussion. There's a clear argument that it's not healthy for us posters, but it's harder for me to see the argument that it leads to unhealthy discussion. OTOH when posters label each other "roto cyber geek" or "the Billy Beane of Guam", that is a problem pretty much by definition. I will miss ICE, as he brought a lot to the board, but there's an opportunity cost to that kind of behavior.
Agree greenback, it is worth having. The social/rants area is a double edged sword - the demeanor in there probably leaks into baseball talk. But on the other hand, you get a sense of friendship with people through there that you probably wouldn't get without it. I'm not so sure I would have taken the leap to actually meet people on here if I didn't have the social forum as some glimpse into what kind of person they were.
I will say I learn alot ... for example I have never heard of the word misogynist before. I'm going to have to look that up sometime. Sounds like a good one.
edit ... damn it it looks like I have no choice but to look this up to follow this thread.
Saying that looking at pictures of beautiful women is objectifying is hyper-PC nonsense.
Anyway, I liked ICE (after I disliked him for a while) and I liked Snayke. They never changed for 10s of thousands of posts but one day they were gone and the forum is worse for it. And a lot of people here are way too [expletive] sensitive and need to not let words on a message board affect them so much. Take a joke. I don't know, I work in restaurants with caustic, obscene lunatics and my friends and I act like we hate each other, so maybe I don't have a good sense of how adults should speak to each other, but if something ICE said in a thread about baseball or otherwise really got to me I'd do some serious self-evaluation. And at least he was honest and funny about his [expletive] disturbing instead of blandly hiding behind letter-of-the-law message board guidelines and passive-aggression.
This place should be about information and entertainment and now we have less of that. It seems like we lose more good posters than vice versa. So whatever, I've said what I think and I mean it with all due respect to people that have to make tough decisions. I'm not turning in my fancard or username, but it's been a frustrating year. I probably care about the Cardinals and this website way too much.
haltz wrote: And a lot of people here are way too [expletive] sensitive and need to not let words on a message board affect them so much.
Actually, I considered ICE to be one of these guys. I felt like I was walking on eggshells, because it was inevitable that certain things were going to set him off. In one regard, he was a lot like me (had trouble letting things go, which is a fault of mine that I'm trying to work on). The difference is that I think he was far more aggressive in "putting people in their place".
You can argue that we have less information and entertainment but you can just as easily argue that we're less obnoxious. It's pretty obvious what the forum will evolve into without "message board guidelines."
cpebbles wrote:
It's also worth noting that the master of the passive-aggressive attack on other posters resides on this forum, and I'd wager has never received a single PM from a mod.