My Racist Neighbors

The forum for ranting, raving, complaining and praising
Post Reply
jim
Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
Posts: 50393
Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm

Re: My Racist Neighbors

Post by jim »

G. Keenan wrote:One thing I noticed almost immediately here in Argentina is how disparagingly they talk about "Chinese" people. I put Chinese in quotes because they call all Asian people Chinese because, as they freely admit, they can't tell the difference between ethnicities. When referencing someone who is Asian they will frequently do the thing where you take your fingers and give yourself squinty eyes. I find it really distasteful and insensitive and unnecessary. Last week I was with some friends when one of them said/did the things I've just described and I was like, "that's quite racist, you know." She couldn't even really process this comment and went into a long defense of why this type of behavior isn't racist. To make matters worse, another friend of ours, who was at the same table, is an Argentine of Korean descent. She confirmed my impressions about the ubiquity of this behavior and when our other friend left for a minute confirmed to me that it hurts her when she sees it but that it is so common here that people just do it unconsciously.

One defense the Argentine's frequently deploy is that Americans are just overly PC and that here people just speak their minds. This to me seems an inadequate cop out.
I have seen that in Europe as well ... but I'm not sure it's racist. Is it racist to point out a common physical trait if it's true? I mean it's pretty obvious there are genetic differences between people from European/Asian/African/American (native)/Polynesian etc.. Asian's do have distinctive eyes, it's almost universal. Just as people from Africa have darker skin, and different hair color/texture then people from Europe.

I get what you are saying keen to some extent, but on the other hand I get what they are saying too. I don't know what you experienced, but from what I could tell from friends of mine from Europe is that they have it more right than we do .. that we are so PC that we just take it to ridiculous levels.

User avatar
thrill
bronoun enthusiast
Posts: 30539
Joined: April 14 06, 10:45 pm
Location: barely online

Re: My Racist Neighbors

Post by thrill »

G. Keenan wrote: She couldn't even really process this comment and went into a long defense of why this type of behavior isn't racist.
It baffles me when people want to voluntarily be the person who helps keep something offensive alive. I'm all for shock laughs when it's done right, but defending the word [expletive], doing the Chinese eyes, they're today's equivalent of the dumb white guy wanting to keep the n word alive in the 60's.

User avatar
cards2468
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 14745
Joined: October 28 06, 11:10 pm
Location: LOVE IT OR LEAVE IT

Re: My Racist Neighbors

Post by cards2468 »

jim wrote:
G. Keenan wrote:One thing I noticed almost immediately here in Argentina is how disparagingly they talk about "Chinese" people. I put Chinese in quotes because they call all Asian people Chinese because, as they freely admit, they can't tell the difference between ethnicities. When referencing someone who is Asian they will frequently do the thing where you take your fingers and give yourself squinty eyes. I find it really distasteful and insensitive and unnecessary. Last week I was with some friends when one of them said/did the things I've just described and I was like, "that's quite racist, you know." She couldn't even really process this comment and went into a long defense of why this type of behavior isn't racist. To make matters worse, another friend of ours, who was at the same table, is an Argentine of Korean descent. She confirmed my impressions about the ubiquity of this behavior and when our other friend left for a minute confirmed to me that it hurts her when she sees it but that it is so common here that people just do it unconsciously.

One defense the Argentine's frequently deploy is that Americans are just overly PC and that here people just speak their minds. This to me seems an inadequate cop out.
I have seen that in Europe as well ... but I'm not sure it's racist. Is it racist to point out a common physical trait if it's true? I mean it's pretty obvious there are genetic differences between people from European/Asian/African/American (native)/Polynesian etc.. Asian's do have distinctive eyes, it's almost universal. Just as people from Africa have darker skin, and different hair color/texture then people from Europe.

I get what you are saying keen to some extent, but on the other hand I get what they are saying too. I don't know what you experienced, but from what I could tell from friends of mine from Europe is that they have it more right than we do .. that we are so PC that we just take it to ridiculous levels.
Perhaps we are far too PC, but I have a hard time saying Europe is more right than us. Like the US, there's a lot of negativity towards immigrants in some countries as well as a displeasure in the lack of cultural assimilation in immigrants.

In France, a report was released showing that nearly half of the French population believes immigration from eastern Europe is a bad thing, 11% had unfavorable view of Jews and that 8% felt US policy is most influenced by Jews.

In Germany, there's a strong distaste towards immigrants, particularly Turks, that even the toleration of illegal immigrants is openly discussed in the political arena.

We have very similar issues in the US, I just think a lot of people view Europe as being above having racial issues when in fact racism pretty much exists in every country that features multiple cultures.

jim
Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
Posts: 50393
Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm

Re: My Racist Neighbors

Post by jim »

cards2468 wrote:
jim wrote:
G. Keenan wrote:One thing I noticed almost immediately here in Argentina is how disparagingly they talk about "Chinese" people. I put Chinese in quotes because they call all Asian people Chinese because, as they freely admit, they can't tell the difference between ethnicities. When referencing someone who is Asian they will frequently do the thing where you take your fingers and give yourself squinty eyes. I find it really distasteful and insensitive and unnecessary. Last week I was with some friends when one of them said/did the things I've just described and I was like, "that's quite racist, you know." She couldn't even really process this comment and went into a long defense of why this type of behavior isn't racist. To make matters worse, another friend of ours, who was at the same table, is an Argentine of Korean descent. She confirmed my impressions about the ubiquity of this behavior and when our other friend left for a minute confirmed to me that it hurts her when she sees it but that it is so common here that people just do it unconsciously.

One defense the Argentine's frequently deploy is that Americans are just overly PC and that here people just speak their minds. This to me seems an inadequate cop out.
I have seen that in Europe as well ... but I'm not sure it's racist. Is it racist to point out a common physical trait if it's true? I mean it's pretty obvious there are genetic differences between people from European/Asian/African/American (native)/Polynesian etc.. Asian's do have distinctive eyes, it's almost universal. Just as people from Africa have darker skin, and different hair color/texture then people from Europe.

I get what you are saying keen to some extent, but on the other hand I get what they are saying too. I don't know what you experienced, but from what I could tell from friends of mine from Europe is that they have it more right than we do .. that we are so PC that we just take it to ridiculous levels.
Perhaps we are far too PC, but I have a hard time saying Europe is more right than us. Like the US, there's a lot of negativity towards immigrants in some countries as well as a displeasure in the lack of cultural assimilation in immigrants.

In France, a report was released showing that nearly half of the French population believes immigration from eastern Europe is a bad thing, 11% had unfavorable view of Jews and that 8% felt US policy is most influenced by Jews.

In Germany, there's a strong distaste towards immigrants, particularly Turks, that even the toleration of illegal immigrants is openly discussed in the political arena.

We have very similar issues in the US, I just think a lot of people view Europe as being above having racial issues when in fact racism pretty much exists in every country that features multiple cultures.

I agree, I just think we are too far on the PC side of things.

Spider John
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 10953
Joined: May 18 06, 10:09 pm
Location: East of the middle of West Tennessee

Re: My Racist Neighbors

Post by Spider John »

jim wrote:
cards2468 wrote:
jim wrote:
G. Keenan wrote:One thing I noticed almost immediately here in Argentina is how disparagingly they talk about "Chinese" people. I put Chinese in quotes because they call all Asian people Chinese because, as they freely admit, they can't tell the difference between ethnicities. When referencing someone who is Asian they will frequently do the thing where you take your fingers and give yourself squinty eyes. I find it really distasteful and insensitive and unnecessary. Last week I was with some friends when one of them said/did the things I've just described and I was like, "that's quite racist, you know." She couldn't even really process this comment and went into a long defense of why this type of behavior isn't racist. To make matters worse, another friend of ours, who was at the same table, is an Argentine of Korean descent. She confirmed my impressions about the ubiquity of this behavior and when our other friend left for a minute confirmed to me that it hurts her when she sees it but that it is so common here that people just do it unconsciously.

One defense the Argentine's frequently deploy is that Americans are just overly PC and that here people just speak their minds. This to me seems an inadequate cop out.
I have seen that in Europe as well ... but I'm not sure it's racist. Is it racist to point out a common physical trait if it's true? I mean it's pretty obvious there are genetic differences between people from European/Asian/African/American (native)/Polynesian etc.. Asian's do have distinctive eyes, it's almost universal. Just as people from Africa have darker skin, and different hair color/texture then people from Europe.

I get what you are saying keen to some extent, but on the other hand I get what they are saying too. I don't know what you experienced, but from what I could tell from friends of mine from Europe is that they have it more right than we do .. that we are so PC that we just take it to ridiculous levels.
Perhaps we are far too PC, but I have a hard time saying Europe is more right than us. Like the US, there's a lot of negativity towards immigrants in some countries as well as a displeasure in the lack of cultural assimilation in immigrants.

In France, a report was released showing that nearly half of the French population believes immigration from eastern Europe is a bad thing, 11% had unfavorable view of Jews and that 8% felt US policy is most influenced by Jews.

In Germany, there's a strong distaste towards immigrants, particularly Turks, that even the toleration of illegal immigrants is openly discussed in the political arena.

We have very similar issues in the US, I just think a lot of people view Europe as being above having racial issues when in fact racism pretty much exists in every country that features multiple cultures.

I agree, I just think we are too far on the PC side of things.
I agree. Just like the accusation of misogyny about the babes thread.

User avatar
longhornbaseball
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 5527
Joined: April 18 06, 10:37 pm

Re: My Racist Neighbors

Post by longhornbaseball »

jim wrote:I have seen that in Europe as well ... but I'm not sure it's racist. Is it racist to point out a common physical trait if it's true? I mean it's pretty obvious there are genetic differences between people from European/Asian/African/American (native)/Polynesian etc.. Asian's do have distinctive eyes, it's almost universal. Just as people from Africa have darker skin, and different hair color/texture then people from Europe.

I get what you are saying keen to some extent, but on the other hand I get what they are saying too. I don't know what you experienced, but from what I could tell from friends of mine from Europe is that they have it more right than we do .. that we are so PC that we just take it to ridiculous levels.
I think making fun of an entire race of people based on how they look should definitely be classified as racist.

jim
Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
Posts: 50393
Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm

Re: My Racist Neighbors

Post by jim »

longhornbaseball wrote:
jim wrote:I have seen that in Europe as well ... but I'm not sure it's racist. Is it racist to point out a common physical trait if it's true? I mean it's pretty obvious there are genetic differences between people from European/Asian/African/American (native)/Polynesian etc.. Asian's do have distinctive eyes, it's almost universal. Just as people from Africa have darker skin, and different hair color/texture then people from Europe.

I get what you are saying keen to some extent, but on the other hand I get what they are saying too. I don't know what you experienced, but from what I could tell from friends of mine from Europe is that they have it more right than we do .. that we are so PC that we just take it to ridiculous levels.
I think making fun of an entire race of people based on how they look should definitely be classified as racist.
I diisagree with your blanket statement because it depends on context. I think it happens alot, but I also think there are contexts in which it is definitely the opposite of racism. Example .. a Chilean exchange student who lived with us doing her gringo impersonation. Hilarious, partly because she picked up on traits that I didn't even notice. I would say here making fun of an entire race of people (white suburban American) based on how we looked and acted was the opposite of racism .. it was actually bonding between two different cultures.

User avatar
haltz
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 22630
Joined: November 9 06, 6:45 am
Location: a proud midwestern metropolis

Re: My Racist Neighbors

Post by haltz »

I don't know, certain ethnic groups have different features, and recognizing that and even making a joke isn't necessarily racist I don't think. I could probably be swayed, but commenting on something obvious and true even if it involves a punchline doesn't seem the same as viewing someone as inferior based on their race/heritage/sexual orientation/gender.

User avatar
longhornbaseball
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 5527
Joined: April 18 06, 10:37 pm

Re: My Racist Neighbors

Post by longhornbaseball »

jim wrote:I diisagree with your blanket statement because it depends on context. I think it happens alot, but I also think there are contexts in which it is definitely the opposite of racism. Example .. a Chilean exchange student who lived with us doing her gringo impersonation. Hilarious, partly because she picked up on traits that I didn't even notice. I would say here making fun of an entire race of people (white suburban American) based on how we looked and acted was the opposite of racism .. it was actually bonding between two different cultures.
In GK's context it was definitely racist. Your context is involves joking around with someone you have a relationship with. I'm thinking of situations where one race of people is discussing a different race of people among themselves. For example, it would be racist to joke with your white friends about all of the big lipped, nappy headed negros in the city, even though it is generally an accurate description of how black people look. However, calling your black friend a big lipped, nappy headed negro might be funny.

User avatar
thrill
bronoun enthusiast
Posts: 30539
Joined: April 14 06, 10:45 pm
Location: barely online

Re: My Racist Neighbors

Post by thrill »

There are people on this earth who are legitimately bummed out when some insensitive thing they say or do is labeled as hateful. It baffles me how many people prefer to be behind the curve of cultural sensitivity. It's not politically correct, it's just polite you idiots. It shouldn't be up to other people to just assume you're not a hateful person. If you say something borderline, people should just assume you're an ass bag.

Post Reply