Unfortunately that's the real nature of environmental law. The typical case is:jim wrote:Yeah that's kind of complicated and makes my head hurt. But you won, right?
Side A wants to build a power line/water treatment plant/landfill, which involves getting a number of permits and meeting a ton of technical criteria. Applying for a permit means any affected party (usually neighbors) can sign up to contest the application.
Side B doesn't want the power line/water treatment plant/landfill built. Side B includes a coalition of neighbors with money who are generally NIMBYs (understandably; their property will lose a lot of value if the thing gets built) but who align with an environmental group for political cover as well as expertise in using the technical/scientific permit criteria to prevent the permit from being issued. The environmental group needs those wealthy landowners both to have standing for their suit, as well as funding for the lawyers.
I've represented parties on both sides. It's kind of the nature of the field. Neither has exclusive rights to wear the white hat of environmental sainthood, but if the process works right, projects that are really needed get approval, but with sufficiently strict controls and permit terms.




