Derrick Rose

A forum for non-baseball sports
Post Reply
User avatar
stlouie_lipp
Hallelujah Brother
Posts: 13380
Joined: April 17 06, 7:36 pm

Re: Derrick Rose

Post by stlouie_lipp »

Socnorb11 wrote:Nobody forced him to go to college. That was his decision. In fact, it's somewhat selfish of him to accept a scholarship if he has no intention of working toward a degree.
Why is that? That scholarship was set aside for a basketball player, not some underprivileged kid who wanted to go to school to be an engineer. Memphis gave him that scholarship to boost the revenue generated by the basketball program, and for no other reason. He accepted it to boost his NBA "stock". If you have a problem with the system, that's one thing, but you can't blame him for taking advantage of the opportunity. Just like you can't blame the university for giving it to him.

Socnorb11
The Last Word
Posts: 21912
Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am

Re: Derrick Rose

Post by Socnorb11 »

stlouie_lipp wrote:
Socnorb11 wrote:Nobody forced him to go to college. That was his decision. In fact, it's somewhat selfish of him to accept a scholarship if he has no intention of working toward a degree.
Why is that? That scholarship was set aside for a basketball player, not some underprivileged kid who wanted to go to school to be an engineer. Memphis gave him that scholarship to boost the revenue generated by the basketball program, and for no other reason. He accepted it to boost his NBA "stock". If you have a problem with the system, that's one thing, but you can't blame him for taking advantage of the opportunity. Just like you can't blame the university for giving it to him.

Mostly playing devil's advocate. The point is that the college and the player both gain something from him going to that school. It's not one-sided.

User avatar
cardsfansince82
is shooing asian children away from his fridge.
Posts: 27776
Joined: May 17 06, 10:23 pm
Location: at the gettin' place

Re: Derrick Rose

Post by cardsfansince82 »

Just to clarify my position(s), since there are a couple different discussions happening here.

I like the rule for the simple fact that it makes the college game slightly better and the pro game significantly better. I'm a fan of the product on the field/court and don't care much about the extraneous stuff. There's not enough roster spots in the NBA to have multiple guys per team 2-3 years away from even being physically mature enough to compete. No one seems to care too much about the NFL requirements. Physical maturity is a real factor in basketball too. A lot of guys who have been "forced" to go to college have found out they aren't quite as good as they thought, and some even decide they like college and the pros can wait beyond one year. In my estimation, in the last ten years the only guys ready to play straight from high school with zero question marks or anything to gain from going to college at least one year are Lebron and Dwight Howard. That's the list. Even Rose had to go through some growing pains in college and his first year or two in the league.

The NCAA is a joke and the romantic notion of the student athlete (or amateur athlete for that matter) is mostly gone. There's too much money at stake to pretend otherwise. The NBA and NFL use the NCAA as their primary minor league system because it is not profitable or viable to develop their own. This is true with or without the age rule, the rule only officially acknowledges what was already true. College and pro basketball are both billion dollar businesses based entirely on entertaining their customers. The rule benefits them both and inconveniences literally a handful of guys at most each year. And as far as I can tell, not a single guy that would have been drafted out of high school didn't eventually get drafted anyway and they were better prepared to succeed right away. Barring a freakish injury that doesn't happen much at all in basketball, no one really loses. Greg Oden continues to make millions solely from being really tall.

I don't begrudge Rose for not taking classes seriously, or getting paid or anything else like that. College football and basketball programs are littered with guys like that, many of whom don't even have a future in the pros. I still reserve the right to chastise the ones that are dumb enough to get caught, because I'm a jerk like that. They move on to make millions and screw over the people they leave behind. Don't get caught.

One last minor quibble. I disagree with the notion that Rose deserves extra credit/leniency/admiration because he grew up in a bad neighborhood. It's slightly insulting to athletes from wherever who have done things the right way and hugely insulting to people from those same neighborhoods that made something of themselves without the benefit of winning the genetic lottery and a surefire ticket to professional sports.

User avatar
The Third Man
It rubs the lotion on its skin.
Posts: 8935
Joined: July 17 06, 1:00 pm

Re: Derrick Rose

Post by The Third Man »

Socnorb11 wrote: Mostly playing devil's advocate. The point is that the college and the player both gain something from him going to that school. It's not one-sided.
No, just something like 98/2 in favor of the school for a player of Rose's ability.

User avatar
cardsfansince82
is shooing asian children away from his fridge.
Posts: 27776
Joined: May 17 06, 10:23 pm
Location: at the gettin' place

Re: Derrick Rose

Post by cardsfansince82 »

The Third Man wrote:
Socnorb11 wrote: Mostly playing devil's advocate. The point is that the college and the player both gain something from him going to that school. It's not one-sided.
No, just something like 98/2 in favor of the school for a player of Rose's ability.
Individual programs aren't swimming in cash. The only big winners are the coaches and CBS by far. Payouts for making and advancing in the NCAA tournament are divided equally among every school within a conference and are not that substantial. Even the very best basketball programs only make $20 million a year total. $5 million goes to the big name coach. They then spend $200K plus per player on charters, badass food, nice hotels, and boatloads of free clothes and shoes. They also pay for assistant coaches, strength and conditioning coaches, facilties, etc etc. Basketball is more or less revenue neutral and a lot of the money brought in ends up benefiting the player either directly or indirectly. When you add in education, room and board and every thing else college basketball players are compensated pretty fairly. Football is the only sport that brings in big dollars (for some programs) and the excess from that is needed to fund the non-revenue sports.

User avatar
longhornbaseball
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 5527
Joined: April 18 06, 10:37 pm

Re: Derrick Rose

Post by longhornbaseball »

cardsfansince82 wrote:Individual programs aren't swimming in cash. The only big winners are the coaches and CBS by far. Payouts for making and advancing in the NCAA tournament are divided equally among every school within a conference and are not that substantial. Even the very best basketball programs only make $20 million a year total. $5 million goes to the big name coach. They then spend $200K plus per player on charters, badass food, nice hotels, and boatloads of free clothes and shoes. They also pay for assistant coaches, strength and conditioning coaches, facilties, etc etc. Basketball is more or less revenue neutral and a lot of the money brought in ends up benefiting the player either directly or indirectly. When you add in education, room and board and every thing else college basketball players are compensated pretty fairly. Football is the only sport that brings in big dollars (for some programs) and the excess from that is needed to fund the non-revenue sports.
You are forgetting to factor in changes in student enrollment due to athletic success. That's where the big money is, IMO. A national spotlight on your football or basketball team greatly increases the prestige of the school, and that probably increases enrollment, which is highly profitable. Here is enrollment data for Mizzou over the last 10 years. Notice anything after 2007?

Code: Select all

Year   Students    % change y-o-y
2002   26,124      
2003   26,805      2.6%
2004   27,003      0.7
2005   27,985      3.6
2006   28,253      1.0
2007   28,477      0.8
2008   30,200      6.1
2009   31,314      3.7
2010   32,415      3.5
2011   33,805      4.3
This probably isn't isolated to football, either. I would guess schools like Gonzaga and Butler have experienced something similar with the success of their basketball programs. The positive externalities associated with being an athletic powerhouse are substantial.

greenback44
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 11665
Joined: June 26 06, 8:54 pm
Location: In a Small Town with Jack and Diane

Re: Derrick Rose

Post by greenback44 »

cardsfansince82 wrote:When you add in education, room and board and every thing else college basketball players are compensated pretty fairly.
I won't argue if you want to maintain that colleges squander most of the revenue generated by a Derrick Rose-type player. But the notion that the great college players are receiving millions in benefits during their time in school is horribly false.

User avatar
Popeye_Card
GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
Posts: 31097
Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am

Re: Derrick Rose

Post by Popeye_Card »

bobby bo wrote:
Socnorb11 wrote:
bobby bo wrote:Child labor laws notwithstanding, most companies are allowed to hire the employees they want regardless of age.

The NBA is "allowed to" also, they've just chosen to institute a policy that they're not going to. Nobody is prohibiting them for doing it except for themselves........ just like most companies.
Exactly. Which is why it's a dumb rule that they should change. That's all anyone has been saying. Except Popeye, who has been saying they should live with it forever because it exists.
That's not exactly what I'm saying. In fact it isn't what I'm saying at all.

I said I don't think it is a bad rule per se, for the reasons cardsfansince82 cites. My point had nothing to do with the rule though. My point was that the guy's argument was really dumb. It is an age requirement, not a college requirement. Every major sports league has one. Nobody is forcing anyone to go to college to fill any requirements, even though that is the best course of action for an 18 year old basketball player. Just as no one forces a 17 year old kid from Hamilton to continue to go to high school and play in the OHL. Or that no one forces a kid in Texas to stay in high school and play on a travelling baseball team.

If the writer disagrees with the age 19 requirement, that's fine. He can delve into all the reasons he thinks the rule is silly. But his analogy to no one making golf players or tennis players (individual sports, mind you, where play in every tournament is more or less optional--so apples and oranges) go to college was stupid, and I was calling it out as such.

AWvsCBsteeeerike3
"I could totally eat a pig butt, if smoked correctly!"
Posts: 27578
Joined: August 5 08, 11:24 am
Location: Thinking of the Children

Re: Derrick Rose

Post by AWvsCBsteeeerike3 »

Socnorb11 wrote:
Nowhere in the CBA does it state that you have to be better than 99% of all other basketball players. That's the NBA hiring standard, not a requirement.
Well, in that case... You don't have to be an engineer to be hired as an engineer, again, you just have to find a hiring manager stupid enough to hire you. You don't have to be an accountant to be hired as an an accountant. You don't have to be a lawyer to be hired by a law firm to be a lawyer. You don't have to be a pilot to fly a plane. You don't have to be a captain to navigate an oil tanker. All of these are hiring standards as you can get hired to do any of these jobs without the necessary training. You'll just suck ass and be fired immediately, probably killing people before you do in a lot of the scenarios.

Socnorb11
The Last Word
Posts: 21912
Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am

Re: Derrick Rose

Post by Socnorb11 »

AWvsCBsteeeerike3 wrote:
Socnorb11 wrote:
Nowhere in the CBA does it state that you have to be better than 99% of all other basketball players. That's the NBA hiring standard, not a requirement.
Well, in that case... You don't have to be an engineer to be hired as an engineer, again, you just have to find a hiring manager stupid enough to hire you. You don't have to be an accountant to be hired as an an accountant. You don't have to be a lawyer to be hired by a law firm to be a lawyer. You don't have to be a pilot to fly a plane. You don't have to be a captain to navigate an oil tanker. All of these are hiring standards as you can get hired to do any of these jobs without the necessary training. You'll just suck ass and be fired immediately, probably killing people before you do in a lot of the scenarios.
Yeah, I'm pretty sure that it is a requirement to possess a pilot's license to fly a plane. And I assume it's a requirement that you have to be licensed to captain an oil tanker. To be an accountant, you have to pass the CPA exam. You have to have a license to practice law, also. All of those things are mandated.

Post Reply