NBA 2011-2012 Y'ALL
- BW23
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 12896
- Joined: July 7 06, 11:08 pm
Re: NBA 2011-2012 REGULAR SEASON, YA'AL
This won't turn into Bowie over Jordan, but it could be pretty close.
- stlouie_lipp
- Hallelujah Brother
- Posts: 13380
- Joined: April 17 06, 7:36 pm
Re: NBA 2011-2012 REGULAR SEASON, YA'AL
and I was in the Oden camp, yukBW23 wrote:This won't turn into Bowie over Jordan, but it could be pretty close.
-
MrSaigon
Re: NBA 2011-2012 REGULAR SEASON, YA'AL
Everyone knew Durant would score in this league. It wasn't clear that he would become a dominant all-around player and leader. He could have been a Jerry Stackhouse or a Jamal Crawford.BW23 wrote:This won't turn into Bowie over Jordan, but it could be pretty close.
It wasn't clear that Oden had pipe cleaners and duct tape for knees either. A dominant big man changes the game in so many ways. Roy/Aldridge/Oden with two role players that could play a little d and shoot some threes would have been an incredible team.
It wasn't a stupid decision, just the wrong one in the end. Jordan, OTOH. I guess you can make similar arguments--but Bowie wasn't the dominant specimen Oden was and had more red flags too. In rethinking that draft, I wish we would have had Hakeem (who went ahead of Bowie), not Jordan. Put him on those early 90s Blazers teams...
- thrill
- bronoun enthusiast
- Posts: 30539
- Joined: April 14 06, 10:45 pm
- Location: barely online
Re: NBA 2011-2012 REGULAR SEASON, YA'AL
Well, you're not wrong other than the HIGHlarious notion that given the choice you'd have drafted Akeem over M Jeff. In the words of Stacey King, stop it. Seriously, taking size over production is what got you into this mess in the first place. So you're not totally wrong, but you're making it sound like there weren't plenty of concerns regarding Oden's body because there were a ton and you're making it sound like a lot of people thought Durant wouldn't be special because they didn't.MrSaigon wrote:Everyone knew Durant would score in this league. It wasn't clear that he would become a dominant all-around player and leader. He could have been a Jerry Stackhouse or a Jamal Crawford.BW23 wrote:This won't turn into Bowie over Jordan, but it could be pretty close.
It wasn't clear that Oden had pipe cleaners and duct tape for knees either. A dominant big man changes the game in so many ways. Roy/Aldridge/Oden with two role players that could play a little d and shoot some threes would have been an incredible team.
It wasn't a stupid decision, just the wrong one in the end. Jordan, OTOH. I guess you can make similar arguments--but Bowie wasn't the dominant specimen Oden was and had more red flags too. In rethinking that draft, I wish we would have had Hakeem (who went ahead of Bowie), not Jordan. Put him on those early 90s Blazers teams...
As I recall, there was a ton of comparisons to the '85 class for reasons beyond the Trailblazers being involved as well as plenty of consensus saying that Durant is the safer bet, but it's hard to pass up a skilled center. It was as much a coin toss as the Bulls picking Rose over Beasley was. The Bulls just had the luxury of Beasley being 6'8 and not the magical, compelling status of being a 'footer which made the choice much easier. Then again, Durant isn't 6'3 like Rose. He's 6'10. So maybe that isn't a good comparison and the Blazers just made a god awful choice.
- lukethedrifter
- darjeeling sipping elite
- Posts: 37260
- Joined: October 17 06, 11:19 am
- Location: Huis Clos
Re: NBA 2011-2012 REGULAR SEASON, YA'AL
Seems to me that a quick check of the history of dominant 7 footers that there have been like 4 or 5 great ones then it drops off to a bunch of kinda okay guys, a few careers ruined by injury and a buncha stiffs. The odds weren't good.
-
MrSaigon
Re: NBA 2011-2012 REGULAR SEASON, YA'AL
I guess it's easier for me to swap out Duckworth for Hakeem and see how it works in my mind than to replace Kersey with Drexler and Drexler with Jordan. I could think about it some more, but that good Blazers team in the early 90s, I think they'd be better if you add Hakeem than if you were to add Jordan. If you take Drexler and move Drexler it's a different story. But we were building around Drexler and he was deserving of being built around.
Oden had the wrist thing and his legs were different lengths. But as I recall, most of the concern was just because he was a big guy. Also the experts were saying the leg lengths would impact his hips. There were concerns about Durant's body type, ability to defend and rebound (things he's doing really well). Yes it was an awful choice, and I don't think the ease of it is especially comporable to Rose and Beasley. Most analysts wanted Rose, just like most wanted Oden--but I think most would say Rose was the easier choice.
Oden had the wrist thing and his legs were different lengths. But as I recall, most of the concern was just because he was a big guy. Also the experts were saying the leg lengths would impact his hips. There were concerns about Durant's body type, ability to defend and rebound (things he's doing really well). Yes it was an awful choice, and I don't think the ease of it is especially comporable to Rose and Beasley. Most analysts wanted Rose, just like most wanted Oden--but I think most would say Rose was the easier choice.
- thrill
- bronoun enthusiast
- Posts: 30539
- Joined: April 14 06, 10:45 pm
- Location: barely online
Re: NBA 2011-2012 REGULAR SEASON, YA'AL
Um, what? Re-check your history and keep an eye on the correlation between big men and titles. Jordan's Bulls, Isiah's Pistons and that's about it sans at least above-average post play.lukethedrifter wrote:Seems to me that a quick check of the history of dominant 7 footers that there have been like 4 or 5 great ones then it drops off to a bunch of kinda okay guys, a few careers ruined by injury and a buncha stiffs. The odds weren't good.
-
MrSaigon
Re: NBA 2011-2012 REGULAR SEASON, YA'AL
If you thought the Oden choice was awful at the time, good on you. Very few did and they were a very quiet few. Plenty (but still a minority) would have taken Durant over Oden, but there weren't a lot of people saying 'taking Oden now is an awful choice.'
- thrill
- bronoun enthusiast
- Posts: 30539
- Joined: April 14 06, 10:45 pm
- Location: barely online
Re: NBA 2011-2012 REGULAR SEASON, YA'AL
I agree, and I also believe that if there were people saying that, that they are dumb. They're right, but dumb.MrSaigon wrote:there weren't a lot of people saying 'taking Oden now is an awful choice.'
- lukethedrifter
- darjeeling sipping elite
- Posts: 37260
- Joined: October 17 06, 11:19 am
- Location: Huis Clos
Re: NBA 2011-2012 REGULAR SEASON, YA'AL
Well, my reply was premature - and likely offmark- but I wasn't referring to simply above average post play but Oden wearing the mantle of Jabbar/Shaq/Chamberlain/Russell, etc. And though you can hardly get postplayerier than Tim Duncan he doesn't resonate as NBA Big Man.bobby bo wrote:Um, what? Re-check your history and keep an eye on the correlation between big men and titles. Jordan's Bulls, Isiah's Pistons and that's about it sans at least above-average post play.lukethedrifter wrote:Seems to me that a quick check of the history of dominant 7 footers that there have been like 4 or 5 great ones then it drops off to a bunch of kinda okay guys, a few careers ruined by injury and a buncha stiffs. The odds weren't good.
Maybe I gave too much weight to Sampson and Bowie and Ming, but Oden seemed riskier to me.
I'm going to go crawl back in my hole.


