It is.Hungary Jack wrote:No. I actually enjoy the show, but now I feel like a half-wit after reading Pebbles' blistering condemnation of it.
But applying his criteria, 99% of all television is a worthless pile of stinking do-do.
Lie To Me
- Smith Corks One
- All-Star
- Posts: 1426
- Joined: April 27 10, 11:08 pm
Re: Lie To Me
- sighyoung
- Mayor of GRB
- Posts: 38643
- Joined: April 17 06, 7:42 pm
- Location: Louisville
Re: Lie To Me
It's fine to enjoy it. He's assailing the failure of the police procedural to live up to the tradition of American realism: a literary mode that tries to represent the experiences of daily life and perspectives of average people confronting moral crises in contemporary America. Ideally, such realism challenges and broadens our perspectives as viewers.Hungary Jack wrote:No. I actually enjoy the show, but now I feel like a half-wit after reading Pebbles' blistering condemnation of it.
But applying his criteria, 99% of all television is a worthless pile of stinking do-do.
You're celebrating the procedural's competing roots in the classic detective story--popular literature that follows a formula in which a genius solves crimes. Such formulaic plots express broader anxieties about contemporary life, social alienation, the threat of crime, and the fears that institutions such as the police or government agencies will fail to protect us, or worse yet, will false accuse us. The formulaic endings of procedurals are meant to soothe us or silence qualms, rather than challenge, complicate, or disturb.
- Hungary Jack
- Mother Earth
- Posts: 19536
- Joined: July 24 06, 6:03 am
- Location: In Cognito
Re: Lie To Me
I don't always agree with pebs, but he's one of my favorite posters for his intellect, which I think is considerable.
But I was able to watch two more episodes last night and enjoy them without a pang of guilt.
Now I want to be like Lightman, because he catches bad guys simply by looking at them [expletive]-eyed and asking them if they had the fish or the chicken at Rotary dinner last week.
Seriously, I see Lightman as a Christ-figure who knows of all our sins, and he is actually paying for them by having to live in an ugly world where the truth is always known. He must reconcile this knowledge while trying to forge a functional relationship with his daughter, his hot but bat-[expletive] crazy ex, and his partner.
But I was able to watch two more episodes last night and enjoy them without a pang of guilt.
Now I want to be like Lightman, because he catches bad guys simply by looking at them [expletive]-eyed and asking them if they had the fish or the chicken at Rotary dinner last week.
Seriously, I see Lightman as a Christ-figure who knows of all our sins, and he is actually paying for them by having to live in an ugly world where the truth is always known. He must reconcile this knowledge while trying to forge a functional relationship with his daughter, his hot but bat-[expletive] crazy ex, and his partner.


