NCAA is discussing a football playoff

A forum for non-baseball sports
User avatar
vinsanity
Chili dog truther
Posts: 8836
Joined: July 3 06, 2:19 pm
Location: Indianapolis

Re: NCAA is discussing a football playoff

Post by vinsanity »

Transmogrified Tiger wrote:
JoeMcKim wrote:Do you really want to be playing the most important College Football games of the year at cold weather locations like Michigan, Ohio State, Penn State or wherever?
Yes, a thousand times yes, presuming that Columbia, MO is not an option. Especially when the alternative is playing in Miami or Dallas in front of a crowd of 25 thousand while everyone waits to see if their team wins to make a trip for the title game.
Ya, I don't think most students/boosters/alumni are making a trip to Miami for a semi-final only to go to Atlanta/Indy/Dallas/Pheonix/Pasedena etc for a Nat'l Championship game.

Besides the weather in Michigan/Ohio/Pennsylvania isn't all that much different in January than it is at the end of November/start of December. I mean the Big 12 played Championship games at Arrowhead in December.

I think it would be cool for the campuses to host it, and I think they would be able to handle it. My only nitpick would be mild concern over some schools like Boise or TCU getting snubbed from hosting due to polls and lose a road game even if they were the better team.

User avatar
Popeye_Card
GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
Posts: 31100
Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am

Re: NCAA is discussing a football playoff

Post by Popeye_Card »

JoeMcKim wrote:Do you really want to be playing the most important College Football games of the year at cold weather locations like Michigan, Ohio State, Penn State or wherever? You have to make the games hosted at one of the current BCS bowl venues and have the championship game either at one of those or rotating between warm weather/domed cities. I don't think the games should take place on campus.
Do I want the SEC to have to travel north to play in a championship game for once? Yes.

User avatar
cards2468
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 14745
Joined: October 28 06, 11:10 pm
Location: LOVE IT OR LEAVE IT

Re: NCAA is discussing a football playoff

Post by cards2468 »

Yea, for just a semifinal, college stadiums should be fine. National Championship, neutral site where the area can support two teams traveling with all their fans and media.

User avatar
JoeMcKim
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 9248
Joined: September 8 09, 10:56 pm
Location: South County, St. Louis

Re: NCAA is discussing a football playoff

Post by JoeMcKim »

Having the game being in a neutral site for the championship game should be a must since you would have a lot more limited time in knowing where the location would be to start selling tickets. You could sell a lot of tickets like they do with the super bowl not knowing who's going to the game, just the spectacle of the game itself is enough to draw in people.

User avatar
pioneer98
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 22007
Joined: July 15 08, 8:24 pm
Location: High A Minors

Re: NCAA is discussing a football playoff

Post by pioneer98 »

vinsanity wrote:I think it would be cool for the campuses to host it, and I think they would be able to handle it. My only nitpick would be mild concern over some schools like Boise or TCU getting snubbed from hosting due to polls and lose a road game even if they were the better team.
Last time I checked, we already had lots of concerns over Boise St. or TCU getting snubbed within the current system.

User avatar
pioneer98
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 22007
Joined: July 15 08, 8:24 pm
Location: High A Minors

Re: NCAA is discussing a football playoff

Post by pioneer98 »

Joe Shlabotnik wrote:
pioneer98 wrote: So I say let the higher seed host the semifinal games, and then put out the championship game to the lowest bidder and rotate it each year like the Super Bowl.
What do you do when the Boise State's of the world get there andtry to host in their relatively puny stadiums. And do you really want to go to Michigan or Pennsylvania to play football in January? Yeah the pros do it but I'm not so keen for the college bowls to go that route.

I'd like to see a 16 team playoff using existing bowls. That's 15 of the biggest bowls involved in the playoffs. The biggest bowls could rotate the 7 quarter/semi/finals.
Yes, I absolutely would love to see Boise St. host a huge football game!!! It would be the biggest thing to happen in Idaho, ever. It might even inspire them to build a bigger stadium someday. Plus, if they ever get awarded a game like that, they earned it, no doubt. Why not let Boise get all the spoils (i.e. cash) that goes with hosting a game like that? Why does it have to go somewhere else?

I would also love to see Michigan, Ohio State (and Iowa) host one of these games. Why make BOTH sets of fans travel halfway across the country to see the most important game of the year? The NCAA (basketball and football) and the Super Bowl are the only instances where the biggest games of the entire season are not played on someone's home field. MLB, NHL, NBA and all but 1 NFL game are all hosted at a "home" venue.

Why is the NCAA so different? The answer is because this is the source of the NCAA's and bowl games' power and revenue. At the lower levels of the NCAA, the games are played at a "home" venue. For example, in D3 basketball, the top seed in a bracket will host 4 teams at their venue. It acts as a home court advantage for the games involving the top seed, and acts as a neutral site for the games they are not involved in. And it works out just fine. Granted, basketball is different than football because more games and teams are involved. The NCAA basketball tournament is a big enough deal now they can get away with neutral sites. That being said, way, way fewer fans of the teams will travel 1,000 miles to see a 1st round basketball game. It only works for the NCAA basketball tournament because it is such a spectacle. But even then it still kind of stinks. In a lot of cases, these guys end up playing in front of a ton of people who look downright bored, if they even bothered to fill a seat.

The idea of a 16 team tournament played entirely at neutral sites for football is nuts. The winning team would have to travel across the country potentially 4 times to win it all. That just makes no sense. Unless they play consecutive games at some venue, which also makes little sense...because then why not just play the consecutive games on your home field? It costs way less and would draw way more fans.

Do we play bowl games to create tourism revenue for southern states? Or do we play bowl games for the players and fans?

User avatar
Joe Shlabotnik
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 24294
Joined: October 12 06, 2:21 pm
Location: Baseball Ref Bullpen
Contact:

Re: NCAA is discussing a football playoff

Post by Joe Shlabotnik »

pioneer98 wrote:
Joe Shlabotnik wrote:
pioneer98 wrote: I'd like to see a 16 team playoff using existing bowls. That's 15 of the biggest bowls involved in the playoffs. The biggest bowls could rotate the 7 quarter/semi/finals.
The idea of a 16 team tournament played entirely at neutral sites for football is nuts.
That's it. I'm out of here.

User avatar
vinsanity
Chili dog truther
Posts: 8836
Joined: July 3 06, 2:19 pm
Location: Indianapolis

Re: NCAA is discussing a football playoff

Post by vinsanity »

pioneer98 wrote:
vinsanity wrote:I think it would be cool for the campuses to host it, and I think they would be able to handle it. My only nitpick would be mild concern over some schools like Boise or TCU getting snubbed from hosting due to polls and lose a road game even if they were the better team.
Last time I checked, we already had lots of concerns over Boise St. or TCU getting snubbed within the current system.
Right....my only concerns over campuses hosting the semi-finals vs having the semi's and national championships on neutral sites is continuing to prevent teams like Boise and TCU from making it to the national title game by making them play on the road.

Since seeds are determined by voting and voters knock those teams for 'not playing anyone' and 'someone' won't schedule them for fear of a loss, I don't think it'd be fair for say an undefeated #3 Boise State team to have to travel to Gainesville/Tuscaloosa/Columbus etc to play a road game against a one loss #2 team.

It was a minor nitpick, not an argument against having a semi-final...

User avatar
slide_into_first
is unaware that dangerous is the real Tyler Durden
Posts: 14433
Joined: June 10 09, 11:31 pm
Location: In Chula Vista hanging with the Surenos

Re: NCAA is discussing a football playoff

Post by slide_into_first »

The Big Ten, and by extension Wisconsin, chiefly wants two things: to preserve the sanctity of the Rose Bowl and have semifinals played on campuses.

http://www.buckys5thquarter.com/

User avatar
pioneer98
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 22007
Joined: July 15 08, 8:24 pm
Location: High A Minors

Re: NCAA is discussing a football playoff

Post by pioneer98 »

They just couldn't wrestle it away from the bowl games.

http://sports.yahoo.com/news/ncaaf--col ... ality.html

Post Reply