Thank you God for protecting me, sucks for the guy who died

The forum for ranting, raving, complaining and praising
Locked
Socnorb11
The Last Word
Posts: 21913
Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am

Re: Thank you God for protecting me, sucks for the guy who d

Post by Socnorb11 »

slide_into_first wrote:If a group of sinners treats one another with love and kindness, will they be saved?

If they accept Jesus as their Savior, then yes, of course. Each and every one of us is a sinner.

Socnorb11
The Last Word
Posts: 21913
Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am

Re: Thank you God for protecting me, sucks for the guy who d

Post by Socnorb11 »

TAZ wrote: But hey, maybe this is because it's all too deep for us to understand. Maybe you can say "well, we can't know god's nature!" Ok, fine. But STAY CONSISTENT! If I then ask you why love exists - you can't then immediately say "'Cause God is good yo!" You JUST SAID you can't know god's nature, a consistent answer to "why love?" would be "we don't know, there must be a higher purpose." You don't hear that answer much.
Christians believe in the Bible, and the Bible tells us what God' nature is. I don't think Christians typically answer a question with "well, we can't know God's nature". At least they shouldn't. And they'll never tell you that God "can't" control all things, they'll simply tell you that he doesn't.

User avatar
wart57
just can't quit you.
Posts: 25076
Joined: April 18 06, 4:33 pm
Location: Lost

Re: Thank you God for protecting me, sucks for the guy who d

Post by wart57 »

I've flown from one side of this galaxy to the other, and I've seen a lot of strange stuff, but I've never seen *anything* to make me believe that there's one all-powerful Force controlling everything. 'Cause no mystical energy field controls *my* destiny. It's all a lot of simple tricks and nonsense.

User avatar
Fat_Bulldog
likes to grate his own cheese
Posts: 12883
Joined: May 9 06, 12:41 pm
Location: Drunk

Re: Thank you God for protecting me, sucks for the guy who d

Post by Fat_Bulldog »

Imagine

User avatar
vinsanity
Chili dog truther
Posts: 8836
Joined: July 3 06, 2:19 pm
Location: Indianapolis

Re: Thank you God for protecting me, sucks for the guy who d

Post by vinsanity »

Fat_Bulldog wrote:Imagine
This is a surprisingly deep fat_bulldog post.

User avatar
wart57
just can't quit you.
Posts: 25076
Joined: April 18 06, 4:33 pm
Location: Lost

Re: Thank you God for protecting me, sucks for the guy who d

Post by wart57 »

vinsanity wrote:
Fat_Bulldog wrote:Imagine
This is a surprisingly deep fat_bulldog post.
Pinko commie!

jim
Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
Posts: 50393
Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm

Re: Thank you God for protecting me, sucks for the guy who d

Post by jim »

Almost didn't read taz post because there were too many words. But the hate the belief live the believer was catchy so I continued. That was a pretty good post. Very thought provoking which is what I'm trying to avoid but very interesting.

Fat Strat
Official GRB Sponsor of Larry Bigbie
Posts: 28010
Joined: April 17 06, 9:16 pm
Location: No. 16 on the Cards Top 15 Prospect List

Re: Thank you God for protecting me, sucks for the guy who d

Post by Fat Strat »

I don't know why I'm opening this can of worms again, since I'm not going to have time today to help close it, but what can I say? I'm a sucker for a good discussion.
TAZ wrote:The OP is right on track. If you believe the generic Abrahamic theology, then god is the starter of all things, the controller of all things, and is bound by nothing. Afterall, if you say, "Well God still has to do X in order to do Y" then no, you don't believe in the basic tenet of theistic thought, which is god is unbound, even by the rules that god set up for himself. Bad [expletive] still happens though, meaning god is in control of that. But yet we're supposed to know god is good. The reason this "mystery" is here is because the premise is flawed in the first place.
I'll admit to being a little lost here. What do you mean that "God still has to do X in order to do Y"? My best guess -- and this is just a guess -- is that you're implying what Jesus did as the X. Jesus died (X) in order to save us (Y). It's interesting that you mention Abraham. I'm not sure what you mean by Abrahamic theology, but if Abraham had a theology it can only be one thing -- covenant. God made a binding and permanent covenant with Abraham -- that God will be the "Father" to all of his "children". In what way? In faith. Abraham was made "righteous" -- he was redeemed -- through his faith, by believing what God said. That's the way that all are saved -- by believing God.

You're also correct to say that God is "unbound". Except, that God chooses to bind himself by his own nature. The old argument is "can God create a stone that's too heavy for him to lift?" The answer is yes. He's boundless -- he can create something bigger than him. But, to do so would violate his own nature. So, why would he? He won't.

I possess the ability to kill my wife and my children. But, it would be against my nature to do that. I love my wife and kids.

To the rest of your argument about free will and electrocuting kindergarteners, I guess I don't see the point. If you want to blame God for sin and suffering in the world because he created the world and gave us free will (and even put the temptation to act on that free will right in front of us), then I don't really have a problem with that. We shouldn't deny or de-emphasize personal responsibility but if you want to blame God for giving us the chance to choose poorly, then go ahead. As I said earlier (I think it was here), God fully knew and understood the ramifications of creating humanity and chose to do it anyway. He found it better to do that, even with the mess of sin that came after, than to not create humanity or not give us choice.

If you want to ask me how it was better, I'm not smart enough or well-read enough to answer it in any other way than the way I answered it... Life, love, feeling, emotion, experience... everything about life is an unbelievably amazing thing! I'm sure there are more thoughtful and well-reasoned answers to that question, unfortunately, I'm not much of an expert in what we call "apologetics" -- to make a defense -- so I've never cared to look into it. My experience with God, my life, the created world, the way that God has worked in my life... those things are more than sufficient for me to find that question irrelevant.

And that also speaks to your question of evidence. When I was younger, I thought the same thing -- what's the evidence for all this stuff? I wasn't raised in the church -- we went some, but it wasn't a significant part of our lives. I came to know God on my own. I started by making a decision very early in life (early elementary age) - that God is real. Look around? How can he not be real? That's what I thought. Creation was all the evidence I needed. As I got older, I started to make some other decisions. If God and Jesus are real, what does that mean for me? To me, it meant that I needed to consider what he said about the way I should live. Again, I wasn't active in church or anything, but I started to seek God. And even from late elementary, I knew that God wanted me to devote my life to him, to learn about him, and to serve his will the best I could. It's funny, but even though I rarely went to church, was shy and hated speaking in public, I knew that I was going to be a Christian pastor. I didn't read the Bible, but when I was faced with decisions, I found myself thinking -- "I don't think God would want me to do that." And I acted that way.

Later in high school, I remember arguing with someone in a similar way that you've argued -- What's the evidence for all this? I believed in God and Jesus -- my experience in life and with God made that an absolute to me -- but I did not think the Bible was "the infallible Word of God." Left for college (a liberal arts, public university), studied history and philosophy/religion, sat under some amazingly smart theologians and historians -- most of them from a pretty liberal point of view on scripture. Learned what the Bible said, what it meant, what theology was. They taught me how to interpret it and how vital it was to understand the context of the writings. I pretty quickly discovered that I my original high-school level view of the Bible was wrong.

I didn't find many inconsistencies, errors, issues, or breakdowns. I assumed they were there. But, my own study convinced me otherwise. And now, after 7 years of college, grad, and doctoral level theology/history, and 12 years of preaching and teaching out of the scripture, I haven't found anything that has convinced me otherwise.

So, you ask about evidence? That's my evidence. I came into it believing in God, but little else. I've come out of it, through independent thought and intense study, more convinced than ever that it is the truth. It is sufficient evidence to understand God, salvation, and how he wants us to live.

User avatar
vinsanity
Chili dog truther
Posts: 8836
Joined: July 3 06, 2:19 pm
Location: Indianapolis

Re: Thank you God for protecting me, sucks for the guy who d

Post by vinsanity »

Fat Strat wrote:What do you mean that "God still has to do X in order to do Y"?
I'll take a stab because I think it's a good question either way. He's saying that statement and this one:
You're also correct to say that God is "unbound".
Is contradictory. If God were unbound, he wouldn't have to do anything. If God were unbound he wouldn't have to send himself to a virgin to suffer for our sins against him so he could forgive us. If he were unbound, he could just forgive us.

To put it differently, humans are bound by physical laws. You can't pass through a door, you must first open or move it to make a clear passage. One thing must follow another. Or in a formal argument, If A and B are true, then C must be true as well. God shouldn't have to do anything in order for another thing to follow, if he's unbound. He shouldn't have to open/move the door to pass through the passage. So why did he have to send a son so he could forgive us? If he was unbound, could he not forgive the sin of his own volition?
So, you ask about evidence? That's my evidence. I came into it believing in God, but little else. I've come out of it, through independent thought and intense study, more convinced than ever that it is the truth. It is sufficient evidence to understand God, salvation, and how he wants us to live.
You aren't proselytizing and seem to recognize faith is deeply personal, I respect that and am not trying to sway you. However, it's called faith for a reason. If there was sufficient evidence to understand God, it would be called fact. If a beautiful day and all of creation is all of the evidence you need to support your own faith, I can respect that, I'd just be careful about what conclusions can be drawn with your evidence.

Fat Strat
Official GRB Sponsor of Larry Bigbie
Posts: 28010
Joined: April 17 06, 9:16 pm
Location: No. 16 on the Cards Top 15 Prospect List

Re: Thank you God for protecting me, sucks for the guy who d

Post by Fat Strat »

vinsanity wrote:
Fat Strat wrote:What do you mean that "God still has to do X in order to do Y"?
I'll take a stab because I think it's a good question either way. He's saying that statement and this one:
You're also correct to say that God is "unbound".
Is contradictory. If God were unbound, he wouldn't have to do anything. If God were unbound he wouldn't have to send himself to a virgin to suffer for our sins against him so he could forgive us. If he were unbound, he could just forgive us.
God chooses to bind himself by his own character. Holiness is one defining aspect of his character -- perfection. Christians believe we were created in perfection (perfect holiness). That's our live pre-sin in the Garden of Eden. But sin entered. By defintion, it is imperfection -- it creates a void of separation between us and God. We have chosen an imperfect path rather than God's perfection. The stain of that is complete... Any imperfection is enough to make something (in this case us) less than perfect.

God could choose to forgive us in our present state of sin -- he has the absolute authority to do that. But, that would be a violation of his character -- his holiness. How can a holy God who surrounds himself with holiness, allow unholiness into his presence eternally? It would be against his nature to do that. Therefore God choose -- he didn't have to, he chose to -- cover our imperfection with his own perfection. He has chosen to make allowance for that through death and resurrection. God allows our imperfection to fully die (literally, we all die) and then be raised back up to his presence in perfect holiness, re-created in our original perfect state.

Locked