Socnorb11 wrote:Yeah, I think Vin is right. Goodell can't just ignore this. Of course there are other issues in the league, but ignoring this one isn't going to solve any of those other ones.
When a cop pulls you over for going 60 in a 55, using the defense that "everyone else is going 57, why aren't you giving them a ticket?" isn't going to fly.
I can't fathom why anyone would think that this should be brushed under the rug.
Sure, and if you got that ticket for going 60 in a 55 when everyone else was going 57, you would probably be upset when you're thrown in jail for a year and fined a year's salary.
I think the issue here is the weight of these suspensions for crossing such a thin line.
Socnorb11 wrote:Yeah, I think Vin is right. Goodell can't just ignore this. Of course there are other issues in the league, but ignoring this one isn't going to solve any of those other ones.
When a cop pulls you over for going 60 in a 55, using the defense that "everyone else is going 57, why aren't you giving them a ticket?" isn't going to fly.
I can't fathom why anyone would think that this should be brushed under the rug.
$100 fine is not equal to a years salary and more importantly javing to sit out of football and practices for a year then trying to come back on the wrong side of 30 to play one of the if not the most physically demanding positions in one of the most physically demanding games in America. (Vilma)
Suspend him a game? Sure. Force him into early retirement? Not cool and Goodell probably shouldn't even have that power. But as soc would say, nothing to see here, just $100 fine he got.
AWvsCBsteeeerike3 wrote:Suspend him a game? Sure. Force him into early retirement? Not cool and Goodell probably shouldn't even have that power.
Maybe something in-between? Fine and 6-10 game suspension? 4-8? I'm really not sure what evidence Goodell has on Vilma or what evidence he has on others so it's hard to know what's fair.
But as you say, it's part of the 'culture'. If we want that culture to go away, if we want to stop having coaches reward players for injuring - not just hitting hard - other players, the punishments need to be severe and public. A one game suspension wouldn't end the practice.
Or are you suggesting there's nothing wrong with the culture of paying players to injure other players simply because it's football and you 'know the risks'?
vinsanity wrote:But as you say, it's part of the 'culture'. If we want that culture to go away, if we want to stop having coaches reward players for injuring - not just hitting hard - other players, the punishments need to be severe and public. A one game suspension wouldn't end the practice.
There is an extremely thin line here though. Hitting hard and hitting hard with intent to injure. Hard to have proof of the latter. Everyone is paid handsomely to do the former as best they can.
So it is very difficult to reward on one side of this thin line, but once crossed you have extreme punishments. I do understand that in this case they have strong evidence of wrongdoing. But much like the steroid culture of baseball in the 90's, programs like this were likely around all over the place.
Popeye_Card wrote:There is an extremely thin line here though. Hitting hard and hitting hard with intent to injure. Hard to have proof of the latter. Everyone is paid handsomely to do the former as best they can.
So it is very difficult to reward on one side of this thin line, but once crossed you have extreme punishments. I do understand that in this case they have strong evidence of wrongdoing. But much like the steroid culture of baseball in the 90's, programs like this were likely around all over the place.
Aye and to me, that's the difference. You can only act on evidence. I don't care if it happened in other locker rooms if there's not evidence of it.
I do think it's difficult to punish Vilma et al on intent (other than Williams who stated intent) but should punish them under the non-contract bonuses that were allegedly used as encouragement. Then, make the punishment for that crime more severe. You don't have to distinguish between hard hitting and intent to injure. The intent would then be purely self-driven and you can't eliminate that. Encouraging a player who otherwise wouldn't have gone for Favre's ankle shouldn't be tolerated.
You have bad mother [expletive] that want to hit other bad mother [expletive] harder than they have ever been hit. They want to do this not only to get on Sportscenter and NFL big hit highlight reels, but also to get more attention/praise/respect and therefore money. And, the main reason they do this, imo, is because they want to be the baddest mother [expletive] amongst a group of the baddest mother [expletive]. Every hit they put on someone has an intent to hurt someone as much as they can. They're not pillow fighting out there.
It's not for a $10K bounty, it's for a large contract and the recognition of being the best.
But, throw an extra $10k on there and that's a one way ticket out of the league. Despite the fact that the sport is absolutely dangerous and has like a thousand lawsuits against it precisely for that reason.
Transmogrified Tiger wrote:"Don't have programs with financial incentives to reward injuries that you cause, and don't lie when we ask you about it" is not a thin line at all.
Yes, in this case it is clear. But is that the line these suspensions are intended to police? Don't be this blatant about it?
I'm talking about future penalties for hitting hard vs. Intending to injure. Extremely thin line in the NFL. You try to hurt them with every hit. Instilled in players since pee wee. Hurt but don't injure? Thin line.