Joe Shlabotnik wrote:You know what, I have empathy to some extent for these ex-NFL players. But nobody held a gun to their heads and they knew and enjoyed the fact that football is a manly sport where dealing with pain is a point of pride.
If I was a judge, I'd throw the suit out PDQ. Players should expect long term consequences for alloowing their bodies to be abused like they are in football.
A lot of dangerous industries could have said this in the past though. "You knew the risk when you took a job at a steel plant." Does not prevent OSHA from regulating these dangerous industries to provide for worker safety, in the face of bravado. Why is the NFL exempt from doing all they can to protect their employees?
I think there is a difference. Football is a game. Parents get their kids playing it. It makes a "man" out of boys and all that crap. They teach kids to put up with the pain. That's part and parcel of the whole football thing. The whole POINT of football is to be proud of how much punishment you can take and how much you can dish out.
Nobody glorifies mine work or sees it as a game. So here's some flame-bait: You protect mineworkers because they add something to the economy. You don't protect football players because it is entertainment that adds nothing to the economy and the players willingly take part in the culture of pain given and taken.
Joe Shlabotnik wrote:You know what, I have empathy to some extent for these ex-NFL players. But nobody held a gun to their heads and they knew and enjoyed the fact that football is a manly sport where dealing with pain is a point of pride.
If I was a judge, I'd throw the suit out PDQ. Players should expect long term consequences for alloowing their bodies to be abused like they are in football.
A lot of dangerous industries could have said this in the past though. "You knew the risk when you took a job at a steel plant." Does not prevent OSHA from regulating these dangerous industries to provide for worker safety, in the face of bravado. Why is the NFL exempt from doing all they can to protect their employees?
I think there is a difference. Football is a game. Parents get their kids playing it. It makes a "man" out of boys and all that crap. They teach kids to put up with the pain. That's part and parcel of the whole football thing. The whole POINT of football is to be proud of how much punishment you can take and how much you can dish out.
Nobody glorifies mine work or sees it as a game. So here's some flame-bait: You protect mineworkers because they add something to the economy. You don't protect football players because it is entertainment that adds nothing to the economy and the players willingly take part in the culture of pain given and taken.
The NFL is a huge business though, entertainment industry or not. This is a job for these players. Because their job is structured around a "game" is a flimsy excuse for not protecting employees.
I can't understand this. I suppose it's like the shift in the gay rights issue. Maybe more people need to have someone affected to understand the need for protecting against unnecessary risk.
Joe, isn't the fact that it's entertainment make it MORE important that unnecessary risks are not taken?
Joe Shlabotnik wrote:You know what, I have empathy to some extent for these ex-NFL players. But nobody held a gun to their heads and they knew and enjoyed the fact that football is a manly sport where dealing with pain is a point of pride.
If I was a judge, I'd throw the suit out PDQ. Players should expect long term consequences for alloowing their bodies to be abused like they are in football.
A lot of dangerous industries could have said this in the past though. "You knew the risk when you took a job at a steel plant." Does not prevent OSHA from regulating these dangerous industries to provide for worker safety, in the face of bravado. Why is the NFL exempt from doing all they can to protect their employees?
Worker safety is one thing. If a player is injured while playing, I suspect that they are compensated, just like any worker on the job would be.
We're talking about chronic aches and pains here, though. The steel industry isn't going to pay for your back surgery long after you've retired, even if you think your back problems were propogated by heavy lifting that you did during your working years.
Football players are contributing to the pussification of America. Sheesh. Suck it up and deal with your melting brain. I'm sick of all the whining, like just because they can't function anymore they deserve something.
I don't have a problem with the NFL doing what they can to help protect the health of the players. The players just need to remember they signed up for the gig under their own free will. Ultimately, they, and they alone, assume responsibility for their own health in a profession the promises to put them in harm's way every single play of every single game of their career. It is what it is. Like it or leave it.
Popeye_Card wrote:
StL Dan wrote:Couldn't agree more.
Joe Shlabotnik wrote:You know what, I have empathy to some extent for these ex-NFL players. But nobody held a gun to their heads and they knew and enjoyed the fact that football is a manly sport where dealing with pain is a point of pride.
If I was a judge, I'd throw the suit out PDQ. Players should expect long term consequences for alloowing their bodies to be abused like they are in football.
A lot of dangerous industries could have said this in the past though. "You knew the risk when you took a job at a steel plant." Does not prevent OSHA from regulating these dangerous industries to provide for worker safety, in the face of bravado. Why is the NFL exempt from doing all they can to protect their employees?
Joe Shlabotnik wrote:You know what, I have empathy to some extent for these ex-NFL players. But nobody held a gun to their heads and they knew and enjoyed the fact that football is a manly sport where dealing with pain is a point of pride.
If I was a judge, I'd throw the suit out PDQ. Players should expect long term consequences for alloowing their bodies to be abused like they are in football.
A lot of dangerous industries could have said this in the past though. "You knew the risk when you took a job at a steel plant." Does not prevent OSHA from regulating these dangerous industries to provide for worker safety, in the face of bravado. Why is the NFL exempt from doing all they can to protect their employees?
Worker safety is one thing. If a player is injured while playing, I suspect that they are compensated, just like any worker on the job would be.
We're talking about chronic aches and pains here, though. The steel industry isn't going to pay for your back surgery long after you've retired, even if you think your back problems were propogated by heavy lifting that you did during your working years.
They're going to get sued if they didn't provide protections against asbestos exposure, and years later you get cancer.
StL Dan wrote:I don't have a problem with the NFL doing what they can to help protect the health of the players. The players just need to remember they signed up for the gig under their own free will. Ultimately, they, and they alone, assume responsibility for their own health in a profession the promises to put them in harm's way every single play of every single game of their career. It is what it is. Like it or leave it.
Popeye_Card wrote:
StL Dan wrote:Couldn't agree more.
Joe Shlabotnik wrote:You know what, I have empathy to some extent for these ex-NFL players. But nobody held a gun to their heads and they knew and enjoyed the fact that football is a manly sport where dealing with pain is a point of pride.
If I was a judge, I'd throw the suit out PDQ. Players should expect long term consequences for alloowing their bodies to be abused like they are in football.
A lot of dangerous industries could have said this in the past though. "You knew the risk when you took a job at a steel plant." Does not prevent OSHA from regulating these dangerous industries to provide for worker safety, in the face of bravado. Why is the NFL exempt from doing all they can to protect their employees?
Again, you sign up for any line of work and you can like it or leave it.
Say you work somewhere where there is a constant risk of falling objects. Your employer provides a list of company provided hard hats that you can use, but does not actively promote the one that can actually save your life if something falls on you, even though it may look dorky. Wouldn't you want your company to require the one that may save your life?