Junior Seau

A forum for non-baseball sports
Post Reply
Socnorb11
The Last Word
Posts: 21909
Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am

Re: Junior Seau

Post by Socnorb11 »

Arthur Dent wrote:
Socnorb11 wrote:My point is that employees in other industries experience long-term effects of their job, post-employment, but they're not filing law suits.
I'm pretty sure they actually are filing those cases. Asbestos has already been mentioned, but there are plenty of other examples.

You're probably right.

I guess the difference here is that those employees impacted by asbestos didn't know that they were walking into a lion's den. Football players did know, really.

User avatar
lukethedrifter
darjeeling sipping elite
Posts: 37260
Joined: October 17 06, 11:19 am
Location: Huis Clos

Re: Junior Seau

Post by lukethedrifter »

Do you think that coal miners didn't recognize that it was very dangerous to work in a coal mine?

Socnorb11
The Last Word
Posts: 21909
Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am

Re: Junior Seau

Post by Socnorb11 »

lukethedrifter wrote:Do you think that coal miners didn't recognize that it was very dangerous to work in a coal mine?

I would imagine so.

Are they filing post-employment lawsuits (I honestly don't know, I guess).

User avatar
lukethedrifter
darjeeling sipping elite
Posts: 37260
Joined: October 17 06, 11:19 am
Location: Huis Clos

Re: Junior Seau

Post by lukethedrifter »


Socnorb11
The Last Word
Posts: 21909
Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am

Re: Junior Seau

Post by Socnorb11 »


Fair enough. I still think there's a bit of a difference between "equipment failures" and "inherent danger the the employee knew existed".

It just seems like a bit of a slippery slope. Every time a football player has post-career issues (suicidal, medical issues, or whatever), is it going to be OK to blame it on the NFL?

User avatar
StL Dan
banned
Posts: 8159
Joined: June 14 06, 9:40 pm
Location: St. Louis in spirit

Re: Junior Seau

Post by StL Dan »

lukethedrifter wrote:Sure just like coal miners are responsible for their own deaths.
They took the risk of taking a job with a high risk of catastrophic loss. Mines collapse all the time. If you don't like the idea of potentially suffocating to death or inhaling poisonous gases or being crushed by tons of earth, I'd avoid the job.

User avatar
StL Dan
banned
Posts: 8159
Joined: June 14 06, 9:40 pm
Location: St. Louis in spirit

Re: Junior Seau

Post by StL Dan »

Popeye_Card wrote:
StL Dan wrote:
Popeye_Card wrote:
StL Dan wrote:I don't have a problem with the NFL doing what they can to help protect the health of the players. The players just need to remember they signed up for the gig under their own free will. Ultimately, they, and they alone, assume responsibility for their own health in a profession the promises to put them in harm's way every single play of every single game of their career. It is what it is. Like it or leave it.
Popeye_Card wrote:
StL Dan wrote:Couldn't agree more.
Joe Shlabotnik wrote:You know what, I have empathy to some extent for these ex-NFL players. But nobody held a gun to their heads and they knew and enjoyed the fact that football is a manly sport where dealing with pain is a point of pride.

If I was a judge, I'd throw the suit out PDQ. Players should expect long term consequences for alloowing their bodies to be abused like they are in football.
A lot of dangerous industries could have said this in the past though. "You knew the risk when you took a job at a steel plant." Does not prevent OSHA from regulating these dangerous industries to provide for worker safety, in the face of bravado. Why is the NFL exempt from doing all they can to protect their employees?
Again, you sign up for any line of work and you can like it or leave it.

Say you work somewhere where there is a constant risk of falling objects. Your employer provides a list of company provided hard hats that you can use, but does not actively promote the one that can actually save your life if something falls on you, even though it may look dorky. Wouldn't you want your company to require the one that may save your life?
Sure, IF they knew about the life threatening situation at the time of my hiring. In that case, I would know about it too. Therefore, the initial assumption of risk is on me. Therefore, I'm agreeing to work for a company and under circumstances that I know are potentially perilous - even fatal - to me. So, in your example, if my employer comes to me and says, "Wear this, and your risk of catastrophic loss is decreased to less than 10% (or whatever number).", I'd have to think about it. Accepting that "solution" is still on me, though, because I realize it's not a 100% guarantee of safety. There is still risk involved.

Bottom line - it is up to every individual to weigh personal risk of injury in any activity or job because noone but yourself or a family member cares about your own health as much as you. Noone.
So you are basically agreeing with me that the NFL has a responsibility to assess the risks of their workplace, and provide information to their employees about the best equipment to minimize those risks.
Yes.
Popeye_Card wrote:They have not been doing that. That is the issue. What you are insinuating is that it is up to the employee to assess the risks, and quit his job if he feels like it is unsafe. OSHA doesn't regulate that way. Company holds the responsibility for providing a safe workplace and minimize dangers.
I have a difficult time believing the NFL has not been diligent in working with helmet companies to design and manufacture the best equipment possible for reducing injuries to the head. Same with pads. If so, then, shame on the NFL.

User avatar
Popeye_Card
GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
Posts: 31090
Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am

Re: Junior Seau

Post by Popeye_Card »

Socnorb11 wrote:
Popeye_Card wrote:
StL Dan wrote:
Popeye_Card wrote:
StL Dan wrote:I don't have a problem with the NFL doing what they can to help protect the health of the players. The players just need to remember they signed up for the gig under their own free will. Ultimately, they, and they alone, assume responsibility for their own health in a profession the promises to put them in harm's way every single play of every single game of their career. It is what it is. Like it or leave it.
Popeye_Card wrote:
StL Dan wrote:Couldn't agree more.
Joe Shlabotnik wrote:You know what, I have empathy to some extent for these ex-NFL players. But nobody held a gun to their heads and they knew and enjoyed the fact that football is a manly sport where dealing with pain is a point of pride.

If I was a judge, I'd throw the suit out PDQ. Players should expect long term consequences for alloowing their bodies to be abused like they are in football.
A lot of dangerous industries could have said this in the past though. "You knew the risk when you took a job at a steel plant." Does not prevent OSHA from regulating these dangerous industries to provide for worker safety, in the face of bravado. Why is the NFL exempt from doing all they can to protect their employees?
Again, you sign up for any line of work and you can like it or leave it.

Say you work somewhere where there is a constant risk of falling objects. Your employer provides a list of company provided hard hats that you can use, but does not actively promote the one that can actually save your life if something falls on you, even though it may look dorky. Wouldn't you want your company to require the one that may save your life?
Sure, IF they knew about the life threatening situation at the time of my hiring. In that case, I would know about it too. Therefore, the initial assumption of risk is on me. Therefore, I'm agreeing to work for a company and under circumstances that I know are potentially perilous - even fatal - to me. So, in your example, if my employer comes to me and says, "Wear this, and your risk of catastrophic loss is decreased to less than 10% (or whatever number).", I'd have to think about it. Accepting that "solution" is still on me, though, because I realize it's not a 100% guarantee of safety. There is still risk involved.

Bottom line - it is up to every individual to weigh personal risk of injury in any activity or job because noone but yourself or a family member cares about your own health as much as you. Noone.
So you are basically agreeing with me that the NFL has a responsibility to assess the risks of their workplace, and provide information to their employees about the best equipment to minimize those risks.

They have not been doing that. That is the issue.

What do you mean they haven't been doing that? Pads & helmets have been requirements of the league as far back as I can remember.

I'm not entirely sure what else you're asking them to do. Getting hit repeatedly is bad for your body. We really expect the NFL to be responsible for telling players that? Doesn't common sense factor in, at some point?
So you think the NFL is doing all they should be doing as an employer in terms of safety for their employees by giving them pads and helmets? They have no responsibility to research and require helmets that help prevent concussions? Outlaw unsafe work practices by their fellow employees like hits to the head?

The NFL fined a player for a dangerous hit, then turned around and sold photographs of that hit for profit. That's like BP selling photos of the Deepwater rig exploding.

User avatar
Popeye_Card
GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
Posts: 31090
Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am

Re: Junior Seau

Post by Popeye_Card »

StL Dan wrote: I have a difficult time believing the NFL has not been diligent in working with helmet companies to design and manufacture the best equipment possible for reducing injuries to the head. Same with pads. If so, then, shame on the NFL.
They aren't even close to working with helmet companies to design the best equipment. They don't even bother to mandate using the best equipment that is already available, or have fit requirements.

Read the first part of this article for the NFL's general attitude toward concussion prevention. It is a couple years old, but not much has changed.

http://sports.espn.go.com/espn/page2/st ... ortCat=nfl

StL_Dan
Single A Minor League Player
Posts: 22
Joined: August 15 13, 3:07 pm
Location: StL in spirit

Re: Junior Seau

Post by StL_Dan »

Popeye_Card wrote:
StL Dan wrote: I have a difficult time believing the NFL has not been diligent in working with helmet companies to design and manufacture the best equipment possible for reducing injuries to the head. Same with pads. If so, then, shame on the NFL.
They aren't even close to working with helmet companies to design the best equipment. They don't even bother to mandate using the best equipment that is already available, or have fit requirements.

Read the first part of this article for the NFL's general attitude toward concussion prevention. It is a couple years old, but not much has changed.

http://sports.espn.go.com/espn/page2/st ... ortCat=nfl
That's ridiculous. The NFL should definitely be involved in the process. That they aren't is ridiculous. At the same time, any NFL player that knows he is using equipment that is not as protective as it should be, and decides to play anyway, has to assume some personal responsibility.

"Ya, I know the NFL doesn't care about safety, but I'm going to play anyway."

Stuuuuuuupid

Post Reply