movies
- The Third Man
- It rubs the lotion on its skin.
- Posts: 8935
- Joined: July 17 06, 1:00 pm
Re: movies
Scorsese isn't glorifying Belfort; Belfort, the unreliable narrator, is. It's established early on - as when Belfort, in the middle of describing his sports car, decides to change its color, or when he flippantly mentions the suicide of one of his colleagues after regaling us with the good-times story of his marriage to the office slut - that Belfort is totally tone-deaf, drugged out, and clueless about how ugly his behavior was. Witness also the path of destruction he leaves while driving his Lambo on the world's worst Qualuudes trip, oblivious to the fact that he'd hit anything at all.
A focus on the FBI stuff would've been both A) way more boring and boilerplate, in my opinion (see: American Gangster), and B) emotionally dishonest. Wolf of Wall Street isn't a movie about how awful being a rich person is; it's a movie about how being that rich can be totally awesome but make you a completely terrible person. The onus is placed on the viewer to reject what Belfort is selling, but few are able to, hence why the film ends with Belfort himself presenting DiCaprio-as-Belfort to a room full of average joes who are totally entranced by his "Sell me this pen" challenge, and why Kyle Chandler's moral victory is both underlined and arguably rendered hollow by the relative laxity of Belfort's punishment and that shot of him slumming it on the subway with the rest of the blue-collars.
As for its length, well, I would hope that sort of lifestyle would exhaust you.
A focus on the FBI stuff would've been both A) way more boring and boilerplate, in my opinion (see: American Gangster), and B) emotionally dishonest. Wolf of Wall Street isn't a movie about how awful being a rich person is; it's a movie about how being that rich can be totally awesome but make you a completely terrible person. The onus is placed on the viewer to reject what Belfort is selling, but few are able to, hence why the film ends with Belfort himself presenting DiCaprio-as-Belfort to a room full of average joes who are totally entranced by his "Sell me this pen" challenge, and why Kyle Chandler's moral victory is both underlined and arguably rendered hollow by the relative laxity of Belfort's punishment and that shot of him slumming it on the subway with the rest of the blue-collars.
As for its length, well, I would hope that sort of lifestyle would exhaust you.
- AdmiralKird
- MBA, CPA, CFA, CFP, JD, PE, MD
- Posts: 10178
- Joined: March 7 07, 4:50 pm
- Location: Tycho Crater, Luna
Re: movies
Mmm Scorsese did shoot a few things that seemed to glorify Belfort. The scene that namely comes to mind is the FBI agent on the subway on the ride home right after he lead the FBI storm into Stratton Oakmont, as if it implies the character is contemplating he might have rather taken up Belfort on his earlier insinuated bribe. Scorsese could have shown him there contemplating it for a second then shaking his head, smiling, and relaxing - knowing he was at least satisfied that he definitely made the dignified choice.
The movie overall did paint Belfort as a pig. I've gotta go with Michael though that there could have been some expanding of the FBI agents role, at least a bit. The problem with the film, at least from a traditional story perspective, is that there is no one to 'root,' for in the movie. To that extent, the movie kind of feels like a hollywood version of an awful reality show like Jersey Shore where you just watch a cast of nincompoops. The agent is too.. dull and unfleshed out of a character to really be behind him. He also seems fairly... incompetent; it takes Belfort to make mountains of mistakes for him to get any kind of prosecutable legal case.
The movie overall did paint Belfort as a pig. I've gotta go with Michael though that there could have been some expanding of the FBI agents role, at least a bit. The problem with the film, at least from a traditional story perspective, is that there is no one to 'root,' for in the movie. To that extent, the movie kind of feels like a hollywood version of an awful reality show like Jersey Shore where you just watch a cast of nincompoops. The agent is too.. dull and unfleshed out of a character to really be behind him. He also seems fairly... incompetent; it takes Belfort to make mountains of mistakes for him to get any kind of prosecutable legal case.
- JL21
- NPR & THT Contributor
- Posts: 36109
- Joined: April 18 06, 7:44 am
- Location: Chocolate City
Re: movies
I don't disagree that the hedonism is over the top (and frequently uncomfortable to watch). But the minor downfall is literally the point of the movie. Society didn't punish Belfort. The government didn't punish him. He basically got away scot-free. Why should the film present a reality that didn't exist? Scorsese didn't show much of a downfall because there wasn't much of one for white collar criminals in this country. Certainly not for Belfort, who has paid back only a very small portion of what the government asked him to pay back.Michael wrote:I just finished Wolf of Wall Street and I think it's one of Scorsese's minor films. Not bad, but nowhere near great. Spoilers:
The final sequence in the film, with the camera reflecting the audience and Belfort still there fleecing them, says it all.
- cardsfansince82
- is shooing asian children away from his fridge.
- Posts: 27776
- Joined: May 17 06, 10:23 pm
- Location: at the gettin' place
Re: movies
WoWS had some great scenes but I can't call it a great movie. Spent way too much time on pointless minutiae of his life. Either cut out 30-45 minutes or tell a better story with that time.
-
Michael
- GRB Founder
- Posts: 35304
- Joined: December 31 69, 6:00 pm
- Location: Chicago, IL
- Contact:
Re: movies
Thanks for the feedback, folks.
I totally got the final sequence/audience thing, which is amazing because I'm pretty dense about stuff like this. But I hadn't considered the brevity of the downfall chapter also reenforced that he got off easy. Good stuff.
Regardless, I'm not sure I totally like how Scorsese enforces his minor downfall. I also think his downfall could have been presented in a more interesting manner. The payoff just didn't stir me in any way. I also still feel the first 2 1/2 hours grew tiresome. The whole Switzerland plot line could have been cut and I don't think the movie would have been worse off.
I wonder how well this movie will hold up after repeat viewings. Will it be Goodfellas or The Departed? My bet is on The Departed.
Thanks again.
JL21 wrote:I don't disagree that the hedonism is over the top (and frequently uncomfortable to watch). But the minor downfall is literally the point of the movie. Society didn't punish Belfort. The government didn't punish him. He basically got away scot-free. Why should the film present a reality that didn't exist? Scorsese didn't show much of a downfall because there wasn't much of one for white collar criminals in this country. Certainly not for Belfort, who has paid back only a very small portion of what the government asked him to pay back.Michael wrote:I just finished Wolf of Wall Street and I think it's one of Scorsese's minor films. Not bad, but nowhere near great. Spoilers:
The final sequence in the film, with the camera reflecting the audience and Belfort still there fleecing them, says it all.
I totally got the final sequence/audience thing, which is amazing because I'm pretty dense about stuff like this. But I hadn't considered the brevity of the downfall chapter also reenforced that he got off easy. Good stuff.
Regardless, I'm not sure I totally like how Scorsese enforces his minor downfall. I also think his downfall could have been presented in a more interesting manner. The payoff just didn't stir me in any way. I also still feel the first 2 1/2 hours grew tiresome. The whole Switzerland plot line could have been cut and I don't think the movie would have been worse off.
I wonder how well this movie will hold up after repeat viewings. Will it be Goodfellas or The Departed? My bet is on The Departed.
Thanks again.
- ghostrunner
- GOAT
- Posts: 30871
- Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm
Re: movies
Is it heresy to prefer Departed over Goodfellas? Goodfellas feels to me like a rote tale of excess and caution, with an emphasis on the excess. Violence, sex, drugs or some combination thereof. Basic downward spiral stuff. It seems of a piece with Casino, Requiem for a Dream, Wall Street, Scarface and probably WOWS. I never feel like I get much from those movies. There's sort of an existential commentary, saying "we are what we are" for better or worse, and you never change. I've heard people point to Wolf and say others missed the point, but if it's anything like Goodfellas it's not a cautionary tale. I'd guess it's just presented as is and you're left to interpret as you will.
Departed on the other hand is really unique in my mind. (Spoilers coming). Where those other movies do glamorize (which is not the same as glorifying) much of the lifestyle and excess, Departed is just a long nihilistic drum roll of death. Nobody makes it. I don't feel like you're going to see anyone getting tattoos of those characters or putting their posters on the wall, or quoting them. Gangsters dead. Cops and Feds dead. Good guys, bad guys dead. It's a similar approach but it's less in love with its characters. I don't know. For whatever reason I greatly prefer it. I'd also say the others almost play like biopics, which I nearly universally hate.
Departed on the other hand is really unique in my mind. (Spoilers coming). Where those other movies do glamorize (which is not the same as glorifying) much of the lifestyle and excess, Departed is just a long nihilistic drum roll of death. Nobody makes it. I don't feel like you're going to see anyone getting tattoos of those characters or putting their posters on the wall, or quoting them. Gangsters dead. Cops and Feds dead. Good guys, bad guys dead. It's a similar approach but it's less in love with its characters. I don't know. For whatever reason I greatly prefer it. I'd also say the others almost play like biopics, which I nearly universally hate.
- JL21
- NPR & THT Contributor
- Posts: 36109
- Joined: April 18 06, 7:44 am
- Location: Chocolate City
Re: movies
I'm absolutely curious to see how it'll hold up. Although I think that there's this much to discuss about it speaks favorably for it. It's not a throwaway type of thing.Michael wrote:I totally got the final sequence/audience thing, which is amazing because I'm pretty dense about stuff like this. But I hadn't considered the brevity of the downfall chapter also reenforced that he got off easy. Good stuff.
Regardless, I'm not sure I totally like how Scorsese enforces his minor downfall. I also think his downfall could have been presented in a more interesting manner. The payoff just didn't stir me in any way. I also still feel the first 2 1/2 hours grew tiresome. The whole Switzerland plot line could have been cut and I don't think the movie would have been worse off.
I wonder how well this movie will hold up after repeat viewings. Will it be Goodfellas or The Departed? My bet is on The Departed.
Thanks again.
I think Goodfellas makes for a fascinating comparison because so much of what makes Goodfellas stand out is that it pretty ruthlessly punishes the criminals. It undoes all of the glorification of the gangster genre done by the Godfather (and others). The first half of Goodfellas is all about glorifying the gangster lifestyle. Think about Henry's comments to start the movie- "As far back as I can remember, I always wanted to be a gangster" and "Being a gangster was better than being president of the United States." And then all hell breaks loose in the second half of that movie. Everyone involved ends up dead or in jail, except for Henry who ends up in his own personal hell.
On the flip side, you've got Wolf of Wall Street where... basically nothing changes. There is no punishment. They do some light jail time and then go back to swindling people, preying on the American dream of getting rich quick.
I also think Wolf works as a comedy as much as anything else, which breaks it away a bit from most other Scorsese films. The quaalude scene at the country club is classic slapstick, almost flawlessly executed. Most of the outrageous behavior throughout is played up for laughs. Very uncomfortable laughs at horrible behavior. The scene where he tries to bone his wife's Ab Fab aunt is [expletive] hilarious. Not that other Scorsese films don't have their bits of dark humor, but I don't think it's ever been like it was in Wolf of Wall Street.
Of course, being amused by a film is not the same as glorifying the behavior. At various points:
- JL21
- NPR & THT Contributor
- Posts: 36109
- Joined: April 18 06, 7:44 am
- Location: Chocolate City
Re: movies
I don't know about heresy but I have a strong preference of Goodfellas to Departed. The thing with Goodfellas is that it's a deconstruction of what the gangster film had become, primarily because of films like The Godfather trilogy. And I would absolutely say it's a cautionary tale. Henry's life, and the lives of all around him, devolve into a bucket of paranoia, death, prison... No sin is unpunished.ghostrunner wrote:Is it heresy to prefer Departed over Goodfellas? Goodfellas feels to me like a rote tale of excess and caution, with an emphasis on the excess. Violence, sex, drugs or some combination thereof. Basic downward spiral stuff. It seems of a piece with Casino, Requiem for a Dream, Wall Street, Scarface and probably WOWS. I never feel like I get much from those movies. There's sort of an existential commentary, saying "we are what we are" for better or worse, and you never change. I've heard people point to Wolf and say others missed the point, but if it's anything like Goodfellas it's not a cautionary tale. I'd guess it's just presented as is and you're left to interpret as you will.
Departed on the other hand is really unique in my mind. (Spoilers coming). Where those other movies do glamorize (which is not the same as glorifying) much of the lifestyle and excess, Departed is just a long nihilistic drum roll of death. Nobody makes it. I don't feel like you're going to see anyone getting tattoos of those characters or putting their posters on the wall, or quoting them. Gangsters dead. Cops and Feds dead. Good guys, bad guys dead. It's a similar approach but it's less in love with its characters. I don't know. For whatever reason I greatly prefer it. I'd also say the others almost play like biopics, which I nearly universally hate.
Re: Wolf vs. Goodfellas, see my previous comments. I think they're vastly different in tone.
- ghostrunner
- GOAT
- Posts: 30871
- Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm
Re: movies
It occurs to me the Coens could have made Departed, or some version of it. Don't think you could say that for Goodfellas. Must be something about my own sensibility.
- ghostrunner
- GOAT
- Posts: 30871
- Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm
Re: movies
You could objectively interpret it as cautionary. Though for Henry who is narrator/main character, the big tragedy is that he was caught. He'd go back to it in a second if there were no consequences. I get the feeling he'd do it all over again.JL21 wrote:I don't know about heresy but I have a strong preference of Goodfellas to Departed. The thing with Goodfellas is that it's a deconstruction of what the gangster film had become, primarily because of films like The Godfather trilogy. And I would absolutely say it's a cautionary tale. Henry's life, and the lives of all around him, devolve into a bucket of paranoia, death, prison... No sin is unpunished.ghostrunner wrote:Is it heresy to prefer Departed over Goodfellas? Goodfellas feels to me like a rote tale of excess and caution, with an emphasis on the excess. Violence, sex, drugs or some combination thereof. Basic downward spiral stuff. It seems of a piece with Casino, Requiem for a Dream, Wall Street, Scarface and probably WOWS. I never feel like I get much from those movies. There's sort of an existential commentary, saying "we are what we are" for better or worse, and you never change. I've heard people point to Wolf and say others missed the point, but if it's anything like Goodfellas it's not a cautionary tale. I'd guess it's just presented as is and you're left to interpret as you will.
Departed on the other hand is really unique in my mind. (Spoilers coming). Where those other movies do glamorize (which is not the same as glorifying) much of the lifestyle and excess, Departed is just a long nihilistic drum roll of death. Nobody makes it. I don't feel like you're going to see anyone getting tattoos of those characters or putting their posters on the wall, or quoting them. Gangsters dead. Cops and Feds dead. Good guys, bad guys dead. It's a similar approach but it's less in love with its characters. I don't know. For whatever reason I greatly prefer it. I'd also say the others almost play like biopics, which I nearly universally hate.
Re: Wolf vs. Goodfellas, see my previous comments. I think they're vastly different in tone.


