movies
-
Jocephus
- 99% conan clips
- Posts: 64992
- Joined: April 18 06, 5:14 pm
Re: movies
k russell is a badass
- go birds
- -go birds
- Posts: 32057
- Joined: February 5 10, 9:54 am
Re: movies
Moon has to rank up there as far as sci-fi goes. At least it does on my list.
- JL21
- NPR & THT Contributor
- Posts: 36109
- Joined: April 18 06, 7:44 am
- Location: Chocolate City
Re: movies
If AI is anywhere near a list of "great sci-fi", then we're probably not going to reach consensus. I like a lot of the rest of your list, though. Notably Brazil, La Jetee, the Tarkovsky Solaris, and The Fly (take either version- the original or the remake).
I think you're grossly underestimating the social statement and impact of some of those earlier films. Within their proper context of their era, they were major achievements, and films like Blade Runner wouldn't even exist without them.
I think you're grossly underestimating the social statement and impact of some of those earlier films. Within their proper context of their era, they were major achievements, and films like Blade Runner wouldn't even exist without them.
-
Michael
- GRB Founder
- Posts: 35304
- Joined: December 31 69, 6:00 pm
- Location: Chicago, IL
- Contact:
Re: movies
It's Spielberg goo and it sucks. I was almost expected the movie to flash to a robot Tom Hanks crying and asking if he led a good life.The Third Man wrote:Even Kubrick didn't think Kubrick would ace that movie; would've been too hollow.
I'll let Jonathan Rosenbaum do the talking for me:
It sounds like typical Spielberg goo — for better and for worse — and when you’re watching the film it feels that way. But the minute you start thinking about it, it’s at least as grim as any other future in Kubrick’s work. Humankind’s final gasp belongs to a [expletive] boy robot with an Oedipus complex who’s in bed with his adopted mother and who finally becomes a real boy at the very moment that he seemingly autodestructs — assuming he vanishes along with her, though if he survives her, it could only be to look back in perpetual longing at their one day together. Real boy or dead robot? Whatever he is, his apotheosis with mommy seems to exhaust his reason for existing. As Richard Pryor once described the death of his father while having sex, “He came and went at the same time.” Like the death of 2001‘s HAL, which might be regarded as David’s grandfather, it’s the film’s most sentimental moment, yet it’s questionable whether it involves any real people at all.
I think Kubrick would have nailed that scene and what Rosenbaum points out would have been much, much clearer. Well, it's Kubrick so clear might not be the right word.
That said, I actually really like A.I. and I understand why you put it on your list. Unfortunately the ending is very, very wrong for me.
-
Jocephus
- 99% conan clips
- Posts: 64992
- Joined: April 18 06, 5:14 pm
Re: movies
the ending should have been robot sex
- The Third Man
- It rubs the lotion on its skin.
- Posts: 8935
- Joined: July 17 06, 1:00 pm
Re: movies
I don't do era adjustments for art. You hold up or you don't, and unlike timelining in baseball there's no need for a "what-if" where we ask, "Well, if they played today...?" They do play today, in high definition on my 40" TV, on which Blade Runner still looks [expletive] phenomenal and visionary and something like, say, the original War of the Worlds, looks straight-up laughable. (Oh, add the Spielberg War of the Worlds to my list of recent sci-fi stuff I love.) Combine that with the fact that sci-fi more than basically any other genre relies on its aesthetics to effectively sell ideas - of the future/technology/etc. - and yeah, I frankly have a hard time taking a lot of older stuff seriously, or at least seriously enough to put it in the same class as the inner circle. I mean, I still enjoy Planet of the Vampires or A Trip to the Moon et al plenty. It just isn't convincing enough to remain serious or profound. Metropolis is about the one major exception I've seen.JL21 wrote:If AI is anywhere near a list of "great sci-fi", then we're probably not going to reach consensus. I like a lot of the rest of your list, though. Notably Brazil, La Jetee, the Tarkovsky Solaris, and The Fly (take either version- the original or the remake).
I think you're grossly underestimating the social statement and impact of some of those earlier films. Within their proper context of their era, they were major achievements, and films like Blade Runner wouldn't even exist without them.
- JL21
- NPR & THT Contributor
- Posts: 36109
- Joined: April 18 06, 7:44 am
- Location: Chocolate City
Re: movies
I think that's a short-sighted view of the medium. You're basically asking a movie that was made 30, 40, and 50 years ago to speak to you on the same level as the people it was made for (your parents and your parents' parents), and to do so without the tools of modern filmmaking. And in many cases, the only reason we have many of the tools of modern filmmaking is because of the existence of those movies. Yes, good art holds up, but only to a degree. There's always going to be something era-specific that isn't going to translate, and especially when you look at something like sci-fi.
- The Third Man
- It rubs the lotion on its skin.
- Posts: 8935
- Joined: July 17 06, 1:00 pm
Re: movies
I don't think we're really disagreeing so much as we're arguing two different things. Yeah, sure, ray-gun era sci-fi films can still be important and remain influential and should be credited as such, but all that ultimately matters to my enjoyment is the end-user experience - the stuff that makes it onto the screen. Which is to say, the same screen I'm watching e.g. Blade Runner and 2001 and Alien on, which are as fresh and relevant now as the day they were released, if not more so; their timeliness is if anything increasing with the passing of time. So unless the competition has managed to remain contemporary, I'm gonna have a hard time putting them in a class with the stuff that has. Yeah, that's a steep hill to climb, but we're talking about the best-of-the-best in the most important new art form of the past century. It should be [expletive] hard to break into that select company.
- cardsfansince82
- is shooing asian children away from his fridge.
- Posts: 27776
- Joined: May 17 06, 10:23 pm
- Location: at the gettin' place
Re: movies
*Unless you show ScarJo naked.The Third Man wrote: It should be [expletive] hard to break into that select company.
-
Vidor
- You've just been hit by...VidorSmarm™
- Posts: 22956
- Joined: June 10 10, 7:50 pm
Re: movies
That ending comes from Kubrick's original outline.Michael wrote:Great movie until Spielberg had to go all Spielberg in the last 10 minutes.The Third Man wrote:A.I. Artificial Intelligence (the most harshly judged and underrated great movie in recent memory, I'd say)
Kubrick would have aced that movie.


