jim wrote: He said go for 2, play to win, it's the NFL.
You're not playing to win, the game is already won. There's no critical thinking involved that necessitates a high level of football knowledge. If you go for two there you are either a dick or a slave to what a card says.
Or you are worried about your team, your job, and securing a place in the Super Bowl.
The NFL is a cut throat place for coaches. Look how quickly Mike Martz got run out of town after 2 Super Bowls.
At that point in the game, the single extra point did nothing to put the Cardinals away, and missing out on that extra point didn't hurt Carolina's chances either, but getting 2 points there could make it exponentially harder for the Cardinals to make a come back. It is simple math, stop putting emotion in to the mathematical calculation of when to go for 2. Logic said go for 2 there, so they went for 2. Newton could have blown out his knee when he ran for the T.D., should they have not called that play? They were up by 20 at that point in the 3rd.
There's nothing about the simple math when you're up 26 or 27. You're assuming a lot of 2 point conversions by Arizona, dismissing a lot of potentional missed 2 point conversions, etc.
When an NFL team ever comes back from a 25 point deficit with 5 minutes left, get back to me and we'll reconsider. When another NFL coach ever goes for 2 points with 5 minutes left, up by 25 points, get back to me and we'll reconsider. Until then, I'm not buying that Ron Rivera and you and jim know something that every other coach in the last 22 years of football (since the 2 point conversion was implemented) miscalculated.
This is the first year the other team can return a missed PAT for a 2 point score of their own. It happened to Rivera and his team a month ago and it was the first time it had ever happened.
That's not really a factor. You can return a missed 2-point conversion (fumble or interception) for a 2 point score, also. So nothing is really gained there by going for 2.
But it also does not hurt if you miss the extra try. The positives of gaining 2 outweighed the positives of getting one or not getting a point at all.
The only thing you risk by going for 2 there is hurting some feelings or a possible injury, and players can get hurt on extra points kick's too. while still increasing your chance of winning and going to the super bowl. Your Q.B. could get hurt today getting out of the shower.
The only thing you risk by going for 2 there is hurting some feelings or a possible injury, and players can get hurt on extra points kick's too. while still increasing your chance of winning and going to the super bowl. Your Q.B. could get hurt today getting out of the shower.
The next time a star quarterback gets hurt on an kick, or getting out of the shower, get back to me. The next time an NFL team comes back from 25 points down with 5 minutes left, get back to me.
It wasn't a dick move broncos. You might disagree with going for it because injury risk or whatever, but he wasn't doing it to be a dick. He was doing it because he wanted to seal the deal, leave no stone unturned, etc... He wanted to win, that's why he did it.
The only thing you risk by going for 2 there is hurting some feelings or a possible injury, and players can get hurt on extra points kick's too. while still increasing your chance of winning and going to the super bowl. Your Q.B. could get hurt today getting out of the shower.
The next time a star quarterback gets hurt on an kick, or getting out of the shower, get back to me. The next time an NFL team comes back from 25 points down with 5 minutes left, get back to me.
I'd prefer to talk about things that are real.
Do you lock your doors on your house at night?
If you do, why do you? Has anyone ever broken in to your house?
jim wrote:It wasn't a dick move broncos. You might disagree with going for it because injury risk or whatever, but he wasn't doing it to be a dick. He was doing it because he wanted to seal the deal, leave no stone unturned, etc... He wanted to win, that's why he did it.
You are free to believe that. As I said, when ANY other NFL coach does that, get back to me. Unless Rivera knows something that they don't?
The only thing you risk by going for 2 there is hurting some feelings or a possible injury, and players can get hurt on extra points kick's too. while still increasing your chance of winning and going to the super bowl. Your Q.B. could get hurt today getting out of the shower.
The next time a star quarterback gets hurt on an kick, or getting out of the shower, get back to me. The next time an NFL team comes back from 25 points down with 5 minutes left, get back to me.
I'd prefer to talk about things that are real.
Do you lock your doors on your house at night?
If you do, why do you? Has anyone ever broken in to your house?
I don't. I live in a small town though.
If I did lock my doors, it would be because houses have been broken into before.
Again, I prefer to talk about things that have actually happened.
jim wrote:It wasn't a dick move broncos. You might disagree with going for it because injury risk or whatever, but he wasn't doing it to be a dick. He was doing it because he wanted to seal the deal, leave no stone unturned, etc... He wanted to win, that's why he did it.
You are free to believe that. As I said, when ANY other NFL coach does that, get back to me. Unless Rivera knows something that they don't?
Done what? Gone for 2? Gone for 2 with a lead? Gone for 2 with a 25 point lead? Gone for 2 with a 25 point lead with 5:13 left? Gone for 2 with a 25 point lead with 5:13 left on a chilly but comfortable night? Gone for 2 with a 25 point lead with 5:13 left on a chilly but comfortable night in an NFC championship game?
What exactly are you referring to that has NEVER EVER been done by an NFL coach? EVER.
jim wrote:It wasn't a dick move broncos. You might disagree with going for it because injury risk or whatever, but he wasn't doing it to be a dick. He was doing it because he wanted to seal the deal, leave no stone unturned, etc... He wanted to win, that's why he did it.
You are free to believe that. As I said, when ANY other NFL coach does that, get back to me. Unless Rivera knows something that they don't?
Done what? Gone for 2? Gone for 2 with a lead? Gone for 2 with a 25 point lead? Gone for 2 with a 25 point lead with 5:13 left? Gone for 2 with a 25 point lead with 5:13 left on a chilly but comfortable night? Gone for 2 with a 25 point lead with 5:13 left on a chilly but comfortable night in an NFC championship game?
What exactly are you referring to that has NEVER EVER been done by an NFL coach? EVER.
Gone for 2 with a 25 point lead, for starters.
More specifically, gone for 2 with a 25 point lead in the 4th quarter.