Popeye_Card wrote:OK, drop the adjectives then. The Cubs lost a top-of-the-rotation starter who they've replaced with a top-of-the-rotation starter. They've lost a top closer and replaced with a potential question mark at closer. Pretty much treading water.
The Cardinals had a pretty big add in the OF with Ozuna. They lost Lynn and Rosenthal, who they haven't really replaced on a production level yet. Maybe the internal options or marginal guys they signed will replace that production. Probably not, but we'll see.
The Cubs replaced Rondon, Davis, and Uehara with Morrow, Cishek, and Alvarez. They will also get a full year from Wilson and a full bullpen-year from Montgomery. I don't see how that's different than us replacing Rosenthal/Nicasio, Broxton/Duke, Siegrist, and Oh with Gregerson, Leone, and Norris. We do have far more elite minor leaguers to replace guys with as well. I'm content with the Norris signing now that we have Leone.
All three signees have better than 10 K/9, which only Lyons did last year (and Rosenthal). Brebbia and Cecil are not far off. K's in the bullpen make up for a lot of luck-driven batted ball data.