Is there a Masyn Winn thread yet?
-
Magneto2.0
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 18100
- Joined: June 16 07, 2:12 pm
-
Mdcardfan60
- AAA Minor League Player
- Posts: 60
- Joined: August 21 19, 9:05 pm
- Location: Silver Spring, MD
Re: Is there a Masyn Winn thread yet?
I’m guessing Winn gets called up on Aug 15/16 or whichever day it is that keeps him ROY eligible for next year. So manipulate his service time now in order to preserve the possibility of getting rewarded for not manipulating his service time later. I’m also thinking that’s not quite what the players assn had in mind when they got that provision added to the CBA.
-
cardsfantx
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 12220
- Joined: November 6 10, 10:58 am
Re: Is there a Masyn Winn thread yet?
From Bernie...Mdcardfan60 wrote: ↑August 3 23, 8:17 pmI’m guessing Winn gets called up on Aug 15/16 or whichever day it is that keeps him ROY eligible for next year. So manipulate his service time now in order to preserve the possibility of getting rewarded for not manipulating his service time later. I’m also thinking that’s not quite what the players assn had in mind when they got that provision added to the CBA.
If they wait to bring him up to protect the rookie year in 2024, and he ends up finishing in the top 2 in the ROY in 2024, then Winn gets to reach FA a year early. the cards do however pick up an extra draft pick.
If they bring him up now, he loses the rookie status in 2024, BUT the cards lose the shot at the extra draft pick.
So would the cards rather have the extra draft pick (if he finishes in the top 2 in the ROY voting)? or rather have the extra year of control?
This isn’t a money thing, right? No, it isn’t that. If the Cardinals are delaying for a strategic reason, it almost certainly concerns the new rules for rookie eligibility and the possibility of receiving draft-pick compensation.
To be eligible to win NL Rookie of the Year in 2024, Winn would maintain his rookie status as long as he doesn’t exceed 130 at-bats or 45 days on the Cardinals’ active MLB roster in 2023. The Cardinals are aware of that, so the timing of a Winn call-up makes a difference.
If Winn stays eligible and wins Rookie of the Year in 2024, the Cardinals would receive a draft choice (following the first round) in the 2025 MLB Draft. The Cardinals value the draft and would like having an extra early pick.
There’s some risk for the Cardinals as well. If Winn ends up with a top-two spot in the Rookie of the Year voting, he picks up an extra year of service time and can enter free agency a year ahead of schedule. Look at it this way, from the team’s standpoint: if Winn finishes second in the 2024 RoY voting, is it really worth it to lose a season of contract control? The Cardinals could circumvent that by signing Winn to a long-term contract before he reaches free agency … but I’m getting too deep into the shrubbery here.
To summarize, the Cardinals have two basic choices: (1) bring Winn to the majors early, have him exceed his rookie eligibility for 2024, and relinquish the chance to collect an extra draft pick. Or (2) bring Winn up later, have him maintain his 2024 rookie eligibility and possibly lose a year of valuable contract control if he finishes first or second in the Rookie of the Year balloting.
-
Socnorb11
- The Last Word
- Posts: 21909
- Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am
Re: Is there a Masyn Winn thread yet?
I love Winn. I'm as big a fan as anyone here.
That being said, he doesn't strike me as the type that's going to make a ROY type of splash in year 1. He's not going to hit .300 and not going to smash 25 homers. He's going to impact the game in various ways, but won't fill up stat sheets.
I guess my point is that I'm not counting on the ROY opportunity factoring in.
That being said, he doesn't strike me as the type that's going to make a ROY type of splash in year 1. He's not going to hit .300 and not going to smash 25 homers. He's going to impact the game in various ways, but won't fill up stat sheets.
I guess my point is that I'm not counting on the ROY opportunity factoring in.
- haltz
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 22630
- Joined: November 9 06, 6:45 am
- Location: a proud midwestern metropolis
Re: Is there a Masyn Winn thread yet?
An extra year of service time? Is that right? Isn't it just that a partial year becomes a full year?
- Popeye_Card
- GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
- Posts: 31085
- Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am
Re: Is there a Masyn Winn thread yet?
So he's currently hitting .285/.357/.471 with 17 HR's, 16 SB's at AAA in 98 games as a 21 year old.Socnorb11 wrote: ↑August 4 23, 4:24 pmI love Winn. I'm as big a fan as anyone here.
That being said, he doesn't strike me as the type that's going to make a ROY type of splash in year 1. He's not going to hit .300 and not going to smash 25 homers. He's going to impact the game in various ways, but won't fill up stat sheets.
I guess my point is that I'm not counting on the ROY opportunity factoring in.
If he plays full-time at SS in MLB next year and goes .280/.350/.460 while going 20/20 with good D? That's most certainly a ROY contender. Rafael Furcal won ROY in the middle of the steroid era with a lesser season than that.
-
cardsfantx
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 12220
- Joined: November 6 10, 10:58 am
Re: Is there a Masyn Winn thread yet?
A full year of major league service will be credited to players who finish first or second in Rookie of the Year voting in each league by the Baseball Writers’ Association of America, as long as they are among the top 100 prospects by two or more of Baseball America, ESPN.com or MLB.com and did not spend the full season on the big league roster. The top prospects who finish top three in Rookie of the Year or top five in Cy Young or MVP earn teams additional draft picks.
- haltz
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 22630
- Joined: November 9 06, 6:45 am
- Location: a proud midwestern metropolis
Re: Is there a Masyn Winn thread yet?
Yeah I think that means 143 days becomes 172 not 172 becomes 344.
- InvincibleCakeEater
- GRB's obsessive compulsive baseball poster
- Posts: 28275
- Joined: October 12 07, 12:28 pm
- Location: Raptured
Re: Is there a Masyn Winn thread yet?
That’s a lofty line. He’s likely a .260 .300 .410 guy to start, and that’s probably on the high side.Popeye_Card wrote: ↑August 4 23, 5:07 pmSo he's currently hitting .285/.357/.471 with 17 HR's, 16 SB's at AAA in 98 games as a 21 year old.Socnorb11 wrote: ↑August 4 23, 4:24 pmI love Winn. I'm as big a fan as anyone here.
That being said, he doesn't strike me as the type that's going to make a ROY type of splash in year 1. He's not going to hit .300 and not going to smash 25 homers. He's going to impact the game in various ways, but won't fill up stat sheets.
I guess my point is that I'm not counting on the ROY opportunity factoring in.
If he plays full-time at SS in MLB next year and goes .280/.350/.460 while going 20/20 with good D? That's most certainly a ROY contender. Rafael Furcal won ROY in the middle of the steroid era with a lesser season than that.
I’d trade him at his apex this offseason.
- Popeye_Card
- GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
- Posts: 31085
- Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am
Re: Is there a Masyn Winn thread yet?
Yeah, I probably have him projected way on the high side. But his current line, even in an inflated Memphis, is no joke as a 21 year old SS. If his bat is even halfway legit, paired with his D and ++arm at SS he's going to be very good.
As long as Walker's bat has to play with [expletive] D in the OF or at DH, I'm more excited with Winn's potential over the next couple of years.
As long as Walker's bat has to play with [expletive] D in the OF or at DH, I'm more excited with Winn's potential over the next couple of years.

