The way he should have handled the TON situation is a simple benching. Don't acknowledge it to the public, everyone knows why he's on the bench. If asked, tell everyone he needed a breather. Move on.
We lost a potential stud outfielder because Oli can't go through an interview without throwing somebody else under the bus.
It’s amazing Marmol gets blamed when O’Neill was either bad or injured for most of his career.
And Oli Marmol has been what exactly during his whole career?
A puppet for the FO. And as much as we want to criticize Mozeliak and DeWitt (deservedly so), the signings and trades in the off-season have worked for the most part so far - back end of the BP is filthy while Gray and Gibson have performed as expected. The offense has been a huge let down so far.
Marmol is just mediocre. He’s not detrimental like Matheny was to success. But he doesn’t do anything good either. I think TON was mishandled by him last year and Contreras was thrown under the bus by Mozeliak, not Marmol.
Last edited by Lesson on April 25 24, 7:34 am, edited 2 times in total.
Good grief. At some point players need accountability. Just like the front office. Get back to me when O’Neill stays on the field for a full season and he’s not playing for a contract.
TON isn't the point though. How Marmol completely botched the situation is the point. It is pretty clear that he's not a great in-game tactician. He's among the worst managers I have seen in terms of planning for the next game(s). You could maybe forgive these things if he was also a good people leader, but the TON situation amongst dozens of others proves out pretty well that he's sub-par there too. Or else why would we have to prioritize bringing in "veteran leadership".
As for TON, yeah he's always injured and is uber-streaky. But he's also super talented, and we had to give him up for relative peanuts because the manager ruined the relationship. The last few weeks could have looked a lot different with TON in the lineup instead of Siani and Scott swinging a toothpick every day.
This is a really good point.
considering TON was on the IL (AGAIN) it wouldn't have made a difference. That's why I wanted him gone...you depend on him for a spot in the lineup and he's hurt every damn year for significant portions of the season
but yes they way Oli handled the TON and Contreras situations last year were terrible
but yes they way Oli handled the TON and Contreras situations last year were terrible
I agree that he handled TON incorrectly, but when Mozeliak is also throwing Contreras under the bus and made the decision to sign him, I don’t place much blame on Marmol.
TON isn't the point though. How Marmol completely botched the situation is the point. It is pretty clear that he's not a great in-game tactician. He's among the worst managers I have seen in terms of planning for the next game(s). You could maybe forgive these things if he was also a good people leader, but the TON situation amongst dozens of others proves out pretty well that he's sub-par there too. Or else why would we have to prioritize bringing in "veteran leadership".
As for TON, yeah he's always injured and is uber-streaky. But he's also super talented, and we had to give him up for relative peanuts because the manager ruined the relationship. The last few weeks could have looked a lot different with TON in the lineup instead of Siani and Scott swinging a toothpick every day.
This is a really good point.
considering TON was on the IL (AGAIN) it wouldn't have made a difference. That's why I wanted him gone...you depend on him for a spot in the lineup and he's hurt every damn year for significant portions of the season
but yes they way Oli handled the TON and Contreras situations last year were terrible
Just me speculating, but I don't think we trade TON if last year's blow up didn't happen. Unfortunately, it seemed like both sides wanted to move on during this past off season. It's a shame he was traded for at least partially off the field reasons.
but yes they way Oli handled the TON and Contreras situations last year were terrible
I agree that he handled TON incorrectly, but when Mozeliak is also throwing Contreras under the bus and made the decision to sign him, I don’t place much blame on Marmol.
I was pretty invested in the Contreras saga and didn't get that impression. Marmol said it first and Mozeliak backed it down, took OF off the table, said he'd work his way back to catcher and made it obvious that it was the pitching staff driving it.
but yes they way Oli handled the TON and Contreras situations last year were terrible
I agree that he handled TON incorrectly, but when Mozeliak is also throwing Contreras under the bus and made the decision to sign him, I don’t place much blame on Marmol.
I was pretty invested in the Contreras saga and didn't get that impression. Marmol said it first and Mozeliak backed it down, took OF off the table, said he'd work his way back to catcher and made it obvious that it was the pitching staff driving it.
Re-reading some articles, it appears the move to OF/DH involved discussions with Mozeliak, then Marmol made the comments, all of which was done after Flaherty said "That's frustrating, throughout our whole staff — throwing pitches that don't make sense".
So I think you're right that Mozeliak didn't publicly say anything similar to what Flaherty or Marmol did, but he still was apart of the decision making for wanting to move Contreras away from C temporarily. And I don't think Marmol would make those comments if they contradicted his boss' thought process, otherwise he'd have been gone like Shildt, JMO.
Good grief. At some point players need accountability. Just like the front office. Get back to me when O’Neill stays on the field for a full season and he’s not playing for a contract.
It's not the player that's the issue, it's the attitude of the coach, though. If he can do it to O'Neill and not learn a single lesson from it, he'll do it to a player you like next.
Good grief. At some point players need accountability. Just like the front office. Get back to me when O’Neill stays on the field for a full season and he’s not playing for a contract.
It's not the player that's the issue, it's the attitude of the coach, though. If he can do it to O'Neill and not learn a single lesson from it, he'll do it to a player you like next.
The two are not mutually exclusive.
O’Neil’s inability to stay healthy and inconsistency is a problem. Marmol’s handling of him is as well.