These comments came from a chat with MLB Trade Rumors' writer Steve Adams that occurred on September 4. (If you like him, you can find him on Twitter @Adams_Steve and Bluesky @adams-steve.bsky.social.)
One fewer question than last week, and no bonus Q&As yet again. Enjoy and have a great weekend!
The link to the entire chat can be found here: https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2025/09/ ... at-73.html
-----------------------------------------------------------------
The Pirates outlook discussed on this week’s podcast was bleak. Any chance of them going after Mullins or Grisham or will they have to settle for guys like Lane Thomas and Harrison Bader?
Steve Adams
Honestly, I’d be surprised if they even signed Bader, who I think has earned himself at least a two-year deal. Lane Thomas, Max Kepler, Chas McCormick, etc. all feel more plausible.
I do think it was perhaps encouraging that Ben Cherington told Darragh McDonald on our podcast the week prior that there’s some urgency, but I don’t envision Bob Nutting green-lighting the type of three- or four-year deal it might take to get Grisham. If Mullins is amenable to a pillow deal or a two-year deal under $30MM, I guess I can kind of see it, but I don’t find that likely.
Bucs should be looking at guys with more offensive ceiling than Bader, Thomas, Kepler, etc. anyhow. If they’re going to keep rolling on the one-year deal track, I’d say roll the dice on a Conforto rebound — but I think they should just be amenable to trading some pitching for controllable young hitters.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Who are some notable non tender candidates this winter? Garcia, Stephenson, India?
Steve Adams
Assuming that’s Luis Garcia in D.C., yeah, all three of them are NT candidates. Ryan Mountcastle, Trevor Larnach, Adolis Garcia, Jonah Heim all come to mind as well.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Where is Justin Verlander going to pitch in 2026 since he says that he plans to?
Steve Adams
There will be plenty of teams willing to give Verlander a one-year deal. Still sitting 94 mph. 4.29 ERA/4.37 SIERA. K% only a tick below average, good command, average swinging-strike rate.
There’s no real way to predict where that’ll be, but I think any contender with a short-term need in the rotation could work. Return to SF or else the Jays, Red Sox, Orioles, Tigers, Rangers, Cubs … Verlander for a year and $12MM or so ought to intrigue plenty of clubs.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Would a new power bat or new coaching staff benefit the Giants more?
Steve Adams
Kyle Tucker or Bo Bichette (2B) helps more than a new coach(es).
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Do you expect Chaim Bloom to blow things up in STL or mostly stay the course that Mozeliak has laid out for him? Is a mini overhaul on the horizon?
Steve Adams
I think there’s a good chance they move on from some of the Mozeliak-era prospects who’ve yet to really pan out. Nolan Gorman, Jordan Walker, etc.
Winn/Wetherholt is a pair to build around. Liberatore and McGreevy will get rotation looks next year. But I imagine they’ll try to trade Sonny Gray and Nolan Arenado again.
In general, I think there’ll be a fair bit of turnover on next year’s roster. I find the whole slow rollout a bit confounding. If you want Bloom to take over, let him take over. But based on reporting and asking people closer to the situation, it seems like Mozeliak has retained all final say on baseball ops and roster decisions while Bloom has been focused on overhauling the player development department. It just feels a little clumsy, though I’m certainly sensitive to the fact that overhauling an entire player dev operation and managing the day-to-day of a whole organization from the very top seat is a lot (too much) to ask of one guy.
I don’t see why they didn’t just name Bloom an AGM or SVP or whatever, then announce the role changes after the season, but maybe that’d just have entailed the exact same setup with less transparency.
At any rate, weird year for the Cardinals.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Will the Red Sox be a favorite to land Tucker with all that left over Devers money? Would you rather have Devers or Tucker next year if you’re the Sox? Who gets me next year?
Steve Adams
Pitching and third base will (or should) be a bigger focus. They can run with Duran/Rafaela/Anthony in the outfield for the foreseeable future.
I’ll probably be wrong about who signs Tucker when I make my final pick in our free agent contest, but if I’m forced to make a pick right now, the Giants get my bet.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
It seems like CES is forgotten man in Cincinnati. Is there still room for him on that roster?
Steve Adams
I’ve never been a big CES guy. Power-over-hit with minimal defensive value and sub-par walk rates who’s on the short side of a 1B platoon. He still has options left and is only 25, so they’ll probably hang onto him through the offseason, but I’m not bullish on the long-term outlook, whether it be in Cincinnati or elsewhere.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Who was your favorite player when you were a kid?
Steve Adams
I was born in the mid-80s and grew up in Minnesota, so Kent Hrbek, Kirby Puckett and — because of course — Ken Griffey Jr.
Dad’s side of the family is from Chicago so I always enjoyed Ryne Sandberg, Shawon Dunston and Andre Dawson.
And Chipper and Andruw a bit later. Jim Thome, too.
I guess I had quite a few, haha.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Would you trade Paul Skenes for Nick Kurtz?
Steve Adams
Nope.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Steve Adams' NL Central comments
- mikechamp
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 11769
- Joined: April 17 06, 5:05 pm
- Location: Southwestern Illinois
- heyzeus
- Everday Unicorn
- Posts: 43331
- Joined: April 21 06, 10:14 am
- Location: Austin, TX
Re: Steve Adams' NL Central comments
"Liberatore and McGreevy will get rotation looks next year"
Looks? [expletive] man, that's all we [expletive] got! Pallante is not rotation material. There's no one else on the horizon. Maybe Quinn Matthews if he's healthy through spring training, but that's uncertain. We're gonna need 1-2 rotation filler signings yet again, and that's assuming we can't trade Gray. Spoiler alert, we're probably not going to be able to trade gray. 36 year old starters with 4.43 ERAs, full NTCs, and $35 million salaries tend not to have huge trade value.
Looks? [expletive] man, that's all we [expletive] got! Pallante is not rotation material. There's no one else on the horizon. Maybe Quinn Matthews if he's healthy through spring training, but that's uncertain. We're gonna need 1-2 rotation filler signings yet again, and that's assuming we can't trade Gray. Spoiler alert, we're probably not going to be able to trade gray. 36 year old starters with 4.43 ERAs, full NTCs, and $35 million salaries tend not to have huge trade value.
- mikechamp
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 11769
- Joined: April 17 06, 5:05 pm
- Location: Southwestern Illinois
Re: Steve Adams' NL Central comments
I hear you, but there are always diamonds in the rough that you can get on 1-year deals.
For example: I know it's going to look like hindsight, but I was secretly hoping the Cards were going to sign Boyd to a 1-year deal this past offseason. (I have been enjoying his productivity on my fantasy team all season.)
A 1-year pact with Jordan Montgomery (for a partial 2026 and a club option for 2027) or a flyer on Paul Blackburn, Merrill Kelly or Jakob Junis could fit the bill.
For example: I know it's going to look like hindsight, but I was secretly hoping the Cards were going to sign Boyd to a 1-year deal this past offseason. (I have been enjoying his productivity on my fantasy team all season.)
A 1-year pact with Jordan Montgomery (for a partial 2026 and a club option for 2027) or a flyer on Paul Blackburn, Merrill Kelly or Jakob Junis could fit the bill.
- vinsanity
- Chili dog truther
- Posts: 8836
- Joined: July 3 06, 2:19 pm
- Location: Indianapolis
Re: Steve Adams' NL Central comments
I'd let Verlander throw some innings, could be an interesting signing from a ticket sales perspective for the FO.
Since the squad isn't competing next year and Bloom will finally be in-charge at Winter Meetings, do you look at moving Herrera and Donovan for arms? Maybe one of Bernal/Rodriguez? Anyone can DH; Saggese isn't anything to write home about but he and Wetherholt can hold down the keystone without Donovan.
Since the squad isn't competing next year and Bloom will finally be in-charge at Winter Meetings, do you look at moving Herrera and Donovan for arms? Maybe one of Bernal/Rodriguez? Anyone can DH; Saggese isn't anything to write home about but he and Wetherholt can hold down the keystone without Donovan.
- mikechamp
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 11769
- Joined: April 17 06, 5:05 pm
- Location: Southwestern Illinois
Re: Steve Adams' NL Central comments
He holds a subscriber-only chat once a week. They put the first part on their main page as a teaser for what you're missing out on if you're a non-subscriber. By chance, the one and only question they showed today was this:
-----------------------------------------------------------------
If Sonny Gray agreed to waive his NTC, what could the Cardinals expect to get in return? How underwater is his contract? Thanks!
Steve Adams
I don't really think there's any surplus value there. You can say there's no such thing as a bad one-year deal, but Gray is being paid $35MM next year and has a $5MM buyout on a 2027 option. Is he getting $40MM if he goes to the open market and says he'll only sign a one-year deal? I doubt that. Even if you think it's not that much of an overpay, there's no excess value. I think they'd probably have to cover part of the salary to get anything of real note.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------
If Sonny Gray agreed to waive his NTC, what could the Cardinals expect to get in return? How underwater is his contract? Thanks!
Steve Adams
I don't really think there's any surplus value there. You can say there's no such thing as a bad one-year deal, but Gray is being paid $35MM next year and has a $5MM buyout on a 2027 option. Is he getting $40MM if he goes to the open market and says he'll only sign a one-year deal? I doubt that. Even if you think it's not that much of an overpay, there's no excess value. I think they'd probably have to cover part of the salary to get anything of real note.
-----------------------------------------------------------------

