4 team divisions is not great imo. If you can show the league is truly competitive through some combination of rules changes, then maybe. But I’d prefer to establish that first.
The Braves could have that division locked down for years. The AL West could conceivably be mediocre for a similar stretch.
Possibly. But I would also avoid drawing up divisions based on how competent or inept current organizations/ownerships are. In your example, Miami and Atlanta are similar large markets. Tampa is also pretty large. The revenue pools available are competitive with each other - that Tampa and Miami haven’t figured out how to tap into that shouldn’t place them in an easier division.
The Cubs would have a huge market advantage vs. the Cards, Brewers, and Reds. Much like they do today in the Central, that they haven’t figured out how to consistently take advantage of.
I think smaller divisions with unbalanced schedules would be the best route. I would also hope that they shorten the regular season to 154 games to better support the expanded playoffs. To better incentivize having a better record, I would give higher seeded teams 2 home-1 road-2 home advantages in 5 game series, and 3-2-2 for 7 game series. Want the extra home game postseason revenue? Spend more to win more.
I’m just using the current situation as an example. My point is it’s that much easier to end up with a weak division that nevertheless sends a “champion” to the playoffs. A smaller pool of competition for each. Or you could end up with longstanding imbalances enabled by teams like Miami, Tampa, etc that don’t seem to care.
A lot depends on any other rule changes so I guess we’ll see, but I’d rather not go down that road at all. I’d rather have the current number of wild cards in larger divisions than 4 have each.
Interesting article in The Atlantic about a new book coming out titled, "Make Me Commissioner: I Know What’s Wrong With Baseball and How to Fix It."
What Not to Fix About Baseball
To borrow a baseball term of art (okay, a cliché), Jane Leavy is an elite spitballer. No one is better built than Leavy, a crafty veteran sportswriter, for between-innings repartee, wry asides, and tossed-off ideas for improving her beloved sport—and maybe even keeping its ever-looming obsolescence at bay for another decade or three.
Leavy’s suggestions for spicing up baseball reflect the essence of spitballing—a pastime within a pastime. Baseball’s most devoted fans have a long tradition of complaining loudly about what’s wrong with the game and insisting that they’d run it better if given the chance. Surely, they are smarter than any clueless manager or hapless commissioner. They can be insufferable.
But not Leavy, not ever. She has a distinctly kinetic way of making her case, like a rollicking tour guide through a stuffy museum. She also knows there’s only so much that can be done to renovate the tradition, given its creaky foundations. “Baseball is still a nineteenth-century construct, born at a time when pocket watches were in vogue,” Leavy writes in her latest romp through the sport, Make Me Commissioner: I Know What’s Wrong With Baseball and How to Fix It.
If you are going to move the Pirates and the Phillies out of the NL (they've been in the NL for the last 138+ years) and the White Sox out of the AL (been 125 years) at this point I think you can just eliminate the American League and National League nomenclature. Also I find it funny that the White Sox and Cubs aren't part of the "Great Lakes" division. Just find some random AL and NL Presidents from the 1930s and name the divisions after them like the NHL did back in the 1970s.