Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Discuss all things Cardinals Baseball
Post Reply
User avatar
mikechamp
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 11769
Joined: April 17 06, 5:05 pm
Location: Southwestern Illinois

Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Post by mikechamp »

These comments came from a chat with MLB Trade Rumors' Mark Polishuk that occurred on November 16.

Same number of questions this week, but no bonus questions. Enjoy the read!!

The link to the entire chat can be found here: https://live.jotcast.com/chat/mlbtr-chat-22984.html

-----------------------------------------------------------------
Which player rumored to be on the trade block would you be surprised not get traded?

Mark Polishuk
Pretty much any of the Cardinals' veterans. Unlikely last season, I fully expect St. Louis to go ahead and actually move some of all of these players.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Do you think there is any chance of Brendan Donovan being traded to the Yankees?

Mark Polishuk
There's a definite chance. New York has had interest in Donovan for a few years, so even though the positional fit isn't as clear as it once was, the Yankees surely are still giving it some consideration.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Would you anticipate someone like Donovan to be traded later after several free agents are signed? His versatility makes him a fit for those who miss out the FA targets.

Mark Polishuk
It makes for an interesting chess game for Chaim Bloom. For all we know, he has a couple of offers right now that meet whatever threshold he has in mind for an "acceptable" trade return for Donovan. Whenever such an acceptable offer emerges, it's then on Bloom to either decide to take it, or see if any better is still out there.

As you note, some teams are working on different timelines than others, so they might focus more on free agents before turning to the trade market. Last year's backfired Arenado trade is a reminder of how the timing of these deals and offers is a key aspect of offseason business, which also might weigh heavily on the Cardinals' minds.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
What are the chances the Dodgers hold the line in free agency this year as opposed to going for a Tucker or Bellinger? 4 of their top 5 prospects are outfielders so hearing about them having interest in an outfielder seems weird to me. Edman's ankle is supposed to be fully healthy by spring training, doesn't that make him the likely CF with Teoscar in LF and Pages in RF?

Mark Polishuk
If you're the Dodgers, you never really need to "hold the line." If you sign Tucker then need room for your prospects later, Pages or one of Teoscar/Edman could be traded. Or, a couple of the outfield prospects could be sent elsewhere in trades for other roster needs.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
With a very limited SS market and teams like the Braves, Pirates and others looking, would the Jays be able to find any value trading Leo Jimenez? He's out of options and seems down on the Jays IF depth chart, especially if Bichette returns. But he was a decently ranked prospect and looks to have skills to be a potential second-division starter.

Mark Polishuk
Jimenez indeed seems expendable in Toronto, but at least some other teams might not be too keen on a player who's out of options. I wouldn't expect a ton back on the trade front.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
If the Sox can re-sign Bregman, or a free agent like Okamoto (I prefer the RH bat), could the Red Sox deal Marcelo Mayer for a pitcher? Thinking of a Bubba Chandler type.

Mark Polishuk
That would be a very fun type of trade. I don't think Boston is really ready to move Mayer before they have more of an idea of what he is.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
True/False: Wetherholt makes opening day roster?

Mark Polishuk
Leaning towards false. He doesn't have much experience at Triple-A ball, so the Cards might want to give him a bit more seasoning before bringing him up.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
What do you make of the Cubs opting to stay significantly under the CBT and aligning contracts to expire with the current CBA while other teams charge ahead and pay the CBT penalties or sign decade long deals?

Mark Polishuk
Seems a little short-sighted for a team that could be real contenders in 2026. There's a chance that waiting too long for the CBA makes the Cubs miss a window here.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Do you believe that Cubs actually have interest in dealing a package for Joe Ryan and/or Byron Buxton?

Mark Polishuk
Ryan moreso than Buxton, but sure, what team wouldn't have interest in either of those two?
-----------------------------------------------------------------
What are the realistic expectations for the Pirates to improve their offense?

Mark Polishuk
Trade a quality pitching prospect for a quality young hitter who becomes a long-term answer for the lineup. Or, trade a quality pitching prospect for an established hitter who becomes a short-term answer.

The built-in other observation is that the Pirates have identified whether there's something amiss with the way they're developing hitters, or if they're just picking the wrong players.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Spencer Jones, Cam Schlittler, George Lombard for Skenes and Brian Reynolds. Who says no?

Mark Polishuk
Pittsburgh would want more than that for Skenes alone.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------

Spider John
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 10952
Joined: May 18 06, 10:09 pm
Location: East of the middle of West Tennessee

Re: Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments

Post by Spider John »

True/False: Wetherholt makes opening day roster?

Mark Polishuk
Leaning towards false. He doesn't have much experience at Triple-A ball, so the Cards might want to give him a bit more seasoning before bringing him up.
Goold said in today's chat that the plan is for Weatherholt to be in the opening day lineup this year.

Post Reply