These comments came from a chat with MLB Trade Rumors' writer Steve Adams that occurred on November 18. (If you like him, you can find him on Twitter @Adams_Steve and Bluesky @adams-steve.bsky.social.)
Enjoy the questions this week. I added 1 bonus Q&A about an offseason procedural strategy.
The link to the entire chat can be found here: https://live.jotcast.com/chat/chat-with ... 23003.html
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Do you think the Blue Jays are the favourites to sign Tucker?
Steve Adams
I don't think there's any one individual favorite at this point, but the Jays are among the five to six most plausible and likeliest landing spots, sure.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
You think Shota will sign a new deal with the Cubs or leave? I'm still not sold that he wants out of town. Thanks.
Steve Adams
He basically turned down two years and $30MM from them when he declined his player option (since exercising it would've given him another $15MM player option).
Maybe he prefers the one-year, higher-AAV route, but then he's just a free agent again ahead of a potential work stoppage? I tend to think he'll reject and get three years elsewhere -- very likely at less than the $57.75MM he'd have made if the Cubs had exercised his option.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Mitch Keller for Jarren Duran. Who says no?
Steve Adams
Keller is good but not worth Duran.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Shota seems like an obvious candidate to take the QO... you predict 3/45.
If he takes the QO then that means, he just needs 2/23 without a QO hanging over his head.
Thoughts?
Steve Adams
Pitchers get hurt all the time and the trend lines on him are down. If he can lock in 3/45 right now, a lot of people would consider that better than accepting and trying again.
Tyler Anderson rejected a $19.65MM QO to sign for 3/40.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Donovan to Yanks. What would a pitching return look like? Warren or Gil plus one of their top 5 pitch prospects?
Steve Adams
Warren + a 50 FV pitching prospect (Ben Hess, Bryce Cunningham, etc) doesn't feel crazy to me. Might to the Yankees -- but I'm probably not as high on Warren as some. (Not that I think he's bad or anything, to be clear.)
-----------------------------------------------------------------
The Reds WILL sign a big bat this off season.
Steve Adams
Sign or acquire, I agree. Almost picked them to sign Pete Alonso. I think he's totally viable.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Pittsburgh in the running for Naylor and Schwarber?! Could Alonso be in their sights?
Steve Adams
I think Alonso's going to cost less than Schwarber.
I also imagine the Pirates probably prefer left-handed power, since PNC Park is where righty power goes to die. Ben Cherington has even referenced this in the past. Doesn't completely eliminate the possibility of going for a righty power bat like Alonso, Eugenio Suarez, etc. -- but I think lefties generally make a bit more sense.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Of the international players, who gets the most money in what order? Any surprise team get any signings?
Steve Adams
Our Top 50 list is based on earning power/expected contracts:
https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2025/11/ ... tions.html
If the Pirates are serious about going after Naylor/Schwarber, then I don't see any huge reason they couldn't pursue a Murakami or Okamoto. They don't really have much of a foothold in NPB, but every team has to take a first step in that regard at some point (and they've spent more modestly on KBO talent in the past).
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Who are the 3 most likely to accept the QO?
Steve Adams
Gleyber and Imanaga are the only ones for me who really feel like they should even consider it (though as I referenced earlier, I think Imanaga can do decently on a three-year deal ... it's just a question of if he considers something like 42-45 over three preferable to 22 over one. Some guys will, some guys won't).
I can see why some would think Grisham or Woodruff should accept, but I think they should both reject without too much fretting.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
The Reds trade for Ward or Greene?
Steve Adams
Is this trade FOR Riley Greene? If so, no, I can't see Greene being available.
I also can't see them trading Hunter Greene.
As I continue to say weekly, I'm going to keep putting Brady Singer-for-Taylor Ward out there until it becomes reality, ha. Works well for both clubs.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Austin Hays: Who is his next team and what is his next contract like?
Steve Adams
I'd expect him signing another one-year deal in the $5-6MM range -- though I guess something like the 2/13 the Royals gave Hunter Renfroe a few years back wouldn't totally stun me.
He'll go to a team that's not viewing him as a starter. Hays just increasingly feels like he's going to be a Randal Grichuk type -- sign a string of one-year deals around $4-7MM per season, depending on the quality of his prior platform. Guards, Giants, Royals, Pirates, Rox all really struggled against LHP last year. Any team with a LHH corner feels like a viable fit.
Even Austin Hays himself can't accurately tell you who his next team is right now. Nor could the GM/president of the team that'll eventually sign him.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Tyler O’Neill and a prospect for Mitch K? Wracking my brain for a MLB trade to match Mitch’s contract. Is this it?
Steve Adams
O'Neill has negative value. Keller does not. Including TON in the trade gets the O's further away from getting Keller.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
After learning about the Rangers shopping Adolis Garcia, who are some candidates to trade for him?
Steve Adams
That the Rangers will shop Garcia has been readily apparent for a couple months now. There's no way he's back next year. Highlighted him and Jonah Heim on our Top 40 trade candidate list 2-3 weeks back:
https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2025/11/ ... eason.html
Giants, Tigers, Guardians, Royals, Reds, Marlins all jump to mind as easy fits, but Texas might also just non-tender him.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------
With the deadline to tender a contract two days after the deadline to add players to the 40-man roster for the Rule 5 draft, why doesn't every team DFA planned non-tenders by today's deadline rather than waiting two days and not being able to fill those roster spots with spots with trades? This has been happening more each year, but at least a dozen likely nontenders remain by the second deadline. Sure, there may be a handful who get traded or sign a deal before Friday, but far more end up just being nontendered with the roster spot left open.
Steve Adams
Some of those clubs are planning to fill those spots with free agents or trade acquisitions anyhow. If anyone has a prospect they're sure will be taken (or feel there's a decent chance will be taken), and minimal roster space beyond the non-tender candidates on the roster, then sure they'll DFA a Jonathan India, Adolis Garcia, Jonah Heim, etc.
If you're planning to add two big league starters, multiple relievers and an outfielder eventually anyhow, then it doesn't really matter. If anything, you don't want that 40-man spot occupied by someone you might have to DFA and lose via waivers anyhow; you run the risk that maybe he'd have gone unclaimed in the Rule 5 but another club just claims him post-DFA since they wouldn't be required to carry him on the active roster all year.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Steve Adams' NL Central comments
- mikechamp
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 11769
- Joined: April 17 06, 5:05 pm
- Location: Southwestern Illinois