These comments came from a chat with MLB Trade Rumors' Mark Polishuk that occurred on December 28.
Some very interesting questions this time, and one bonus question about Ohtani's effect. Enjoy the read!!
The link to the entire chat can be found here: https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2025/12/ ... at-96.html
-----------------------------------------------------------------
If the Cubs sign Bregman do they move Shaw? Will the Cubs sign Bregman?
Mark Polishuk
The Cubs’ focus seems to be on starting pitching, so if they have a particularly big move in them this winter, it’ll probably be in the rotation.
Their interest in Bregman might be limited to seeing if he’s willing to take a shorter-term deal, or if a longer-term deal isn’t out there.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Pirates agreed to O’Hearn deal on the 23rd. It’s the 28th now and still not official and no corresponding 40 man move. Is this abnormal?
Mark Polishuk
Not over the holidays, when a lot of front offices are more or less shut down.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Are the Pirates building around Paul Skenes? Does the Lowe trade and the O’Hearn signing signal that?
Mark Polishuk
Most definitely. The Bucs realize they have something special in Skenes, and are being more aggressive than usual in trying to make a win-now push.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Mark, please tell me the Reds have something bigger planned than JJ Bleday and Dane Myers. As a fan, I am so disappointed.
Mark Polishuk
This certainly won’t be it for the Reds, or at least one would certainly think not. It’s a pair of depth acquisitions with upside, and maybe a sign that Cincinnati could be looking to move out of its incumbent outfield options.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Are you as disappointed in the Reds as I am this winter?
Mark Polishuk
I haven’t been wowed by their moves or anything, but obligatory “it’s only late December” caveat.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
It seems like there is so much overlap of interest in Tucker / Bichette / Bregman / Bellinger that one signing really impacts the next. Which of those dominoes do you see falling first?
Mark Polishuk
In theory Okamoto might technically be the first domino, just because he has his posting window up on January 4. But, if Okamoto signs with Pittsburgh or San Diego or some other team that isn’t in on the bigger names you mentioned, it won’t exactly shake up the market.
If I had to pick one, it might be Bichette back with Toronto. There’s some obvious history there, and the Sox are the only other team really linked to Bo this winter. And, if the Red Sox are really this reluctant about inking players to longer-term deals, that leaves the Jays as the best fit for Bichette’s contract demands.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
When will the Cards deal Brendan? It is getting old hearing rumors and not trading him. I cannot imagine being his family!
Mark Polishuk
Plenty of players have spoken about the difficulty of constantly being included in trade rumors, whether it’s in-season or during the offseason. For Donovan, this is at least nothing new, since teams have been showing interest in him for years.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
With the Zombro promotion, do you think the Cubs can recreate the success with their veteran bullpen like they did last year? Seems like the Cubs are gambling that they’ll get the same position player production that they got last year. I like Ballesteros and Caissie but I’m not sure they can replace Tucker’s stats/threat in the lineup.
Mark Polishuk
I like all of the Cubs’ bullpen moves, actually. As much as Hoyer takes heat for not spending bigger in the bullpen specifically, he isn’t wrong about the year-to-year volatility of relief pitching. He has stretched his pen budget a bit more than usual, but the end result is a good group of veterans with upside.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Will there ever be another Ohtani? He seems to be the best overall player that there ever was.
Mark Polishuk
Ohtani is definitely a one-in-one for now, but the fascinating next step of his legacy will be his influence on the next generation of players (in both Japan and all over the world). Maybe a few more players will take the leap of trying to be real two-way players, and we’ll see a “new Ohtani” emerge… though then that player will have to be not just a two-way guy, but elite in both areas.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Mark Polishuk's NL Central comments
- mikechamp
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 11769
- Joined: April 17 06, 5:05 pm
- Location: Southwestern Illinois