Steve Adams' NL Central comments

Discuss all things Cardinals Baseball
Post Reply
User avatar
mikechamp
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 11769
Joined: April 17 06, 5:05 pm
Location: Southwestern Illinois

Steve Adams' NL Central comments

Post by mikechamp »

These comments came from a chat with MLB Trade Rumors' writer Steve Adams that occurred on January 6. (If you like him, you can find him on Twitter @Adams_Steve and Bluesky @adams-steve.bsky.social.)

Tons of questions this week. I added 1 bonus Q&A about some of the best players to have their careers cut short by injury. Enjoy the discussion!

The link to the entire chat can be found here: https://live.jotcast.com/chat/chat-with ... 23446.html

-----------------------------------------------------------------
Cijnte and Montes for Donovan, who says no?

Steve Adams
I think both is too steep for the Mariners to pay. Have a hard time seeing the Cardinals turn that down.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Boras gets blamed a lot for allegedly leaking information about interested teams to drive up contract offers. How true are these accusations and how much do you think this kind of information unfairly gets fans' hopes up that their team is actually in on FAs when they are not realistic destinations (thinking specifically of the Pirates' connection to Okamoto and the ridiculous assertion that they are "in" on Bellinger)?

Steve Adams
90% of agents/agencies put things out to the media -- it's not a Boras-specific thing.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
As the off-season progresses and teams firm up depth charts, does a trade of Brendan Donovan or Ketel Marte become less likely?

Steve Adams
I've said repeatedly that I don't think Marte will move -- even if I am admittedly working on something regarding which teams are the best fits in a trade based on need/payroll/young pitching supply -- and I'd be shocked if Donovan is a Cardinal on Opening Day.

On Marte: I don't think it happens, but it's obviously being discussed, and it's of immense interest to our readers, so I think it's worth looking at without overplaying the likelihood. There's obviously a non-zero chance he goes ... I just think it's far likelier he stays put.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Does Pittsburgh have a realistic shot at signing Geno? What other FAs/ trades could they pull off to field a competitive team while they still have Skenes?

Steve Adams
Sure, I don't think Suarez is unreasonable there. At this point, I'd take the under on our 3/63 prediction from November, and even if that were the stopping point, the Pirates could make that offer.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Am I wrong to be upset with the Reds penny pinching ways?

Steve Adams
I'd be pissed off if I were a Reds fan. Plenty of offseason left, so maybe they pull a rabbit out of the hat, but this team's rotation is off-the-charts talented, and they seem committed to just spending notable money on Emilio Pagan and taking a bargain-bin approach to the lineup... all coming off a postseason berth.

Given the apparent lack of spending power this winter, I'm all the more perplexed as to why they acquired Ke'Bryan Hayes. Love the glove, of course, and there's something to be said for bolstering run prevention when you already have such a talented pitching staff, but allotting $7.5MM annually to a glove-only third baseman is a weird move for a team in dire need of some real offensive help.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
If offering some combo of Acuna/Mauricio/Vientos, would MItch Keller be a logical trade target for Stearns to address SP?

Steve Adams
Could see Vientos having some appeal, but I wouldn't move Keller for him alone and don't think the others have a ton of value right now.

Also feel like if the Mets are trading for a starter, they should aim for more ceiling than Keller anyhow.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Out of Nico Hoerner, Brendan Donovan, or Bo Bichette, who is most likely to come over to the Giants? With the fact that we're afraid to spend big on pitching, we're poised to bring over a big bat... right?

Steve Adams
I'd be so surprised if the Cubs trade Hoerner, and even more surprised if the Giants met Bichette's asking price.

Donovan seems realistic and attainable, so he's the easy answer for me.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
There have been reported offers for Donovan from the Giants being Whisenhunt, Kilen and a lottery ticket low A pitcher. Your thoughts on that as the return?

Steve Adams
That's not really what Katie Woo reported at The Athletic. She said Whisenhunt and Kilen had been discussed with the Giants -- not necessarily in the same trade package.

If the Giants offered both players and a lower-level prospect, I think it'd be a strong offer.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Where will Kyle Tucker sign?

Steve Adams
I doubt Kyle himself knows the answer to this question right now!
-----------------------------------------------------------------
I keep reading reports that the Royals are still on some OF help. I've heard Duran, but what other possibilities are out there for them, via trade? They can't roll out the current OF that they have. Thanks!

Steve Adams
Yeah they definitely need more help in the OF. Duran and Abreu from Boston make sense, of course, but other names I could realistically see on the market include Alec Burleson, Lars Nootbaar, Brenton Doyle, Mickey Moniak, Trevor Larnach, Matt Wallner, maybe one of Dylan Beavers/Colton Cowser (if the O's are getting a quality starter back), Nathan Lukes, Jake Meyers, Teoscar Hernandez... plenty more I'm sure I'm spacing on.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
For a team that finished with the best record in baseball last year...what's the catch?...trade away a versatile utility player who finished 4th in ROY voting and a leverage flamethrower arm...rumors swirling about moving our ace...help me make sense of this...

Steve Adams
Standard operating procedure for the Brewers. They're always going to be open to trading stars as they approach free agency. More often than not, they'll probably do it. (Hader, Burnes, Williams, Lucroy) Sometimes they don't (Adames)

Collins was a great story in '25 but a clear regression candidate at the plate (somewhat heavy BABIP, poor batted-ball metrics, etc.) They've liked Zerpa forever and clearly think they can make him a big weapon. I wouldn't bet against Milwaukee's pitching development (or player development in general).

I'm sure there are some modest additions in the offing, but the Brewers are only rarely going to be a team to make a huge splash in free agency, and they sort of did that by making the QO to Woodruff and keeping him at $22.05MM.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Should the Reds trade Elly in his last year?

Steve Adams
He's controlled for four more years.

Unless you're asking me if they should trade De La Cruz in like... the 2028-29 offseason. In which case, my answer is, "Who knows what the team, payroll, league, etc. will look like by then".
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Do you see the Cardinals making anymore moves?

Steve Adams
They'll trade Donovan and Romero at least.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Don't you think Geno Suarez would be a perfect DH in Cincy?

Steve Adams
He'd be a fine fit there. I doubt the Reds are spending at the necessary level to get him, but it'd be a perfectly sensible reunion, sure.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Possible fallback plans for the Pirates at 3B other than Suarez?

Steve Adams
There's just not a lot. Look to the Rangers and see if they'll move Josh Jung? Try to pry Addison Barger out of Toronto?
-----------------------------------------------------------------
I have seen reports the Cardinals may simply release Arenado if a trade is not worked out. Could you see them actually doing this?

Steve Adams
Chaim Bloom has said definitively, on record, multiple times that releasing Arenado is not an option.

I know Buster Olney wrote today that "it'll be interesting to see if they do it."

They will not.

I suppose if Arenado asks for his release so he can go sign somewhere else, maybe that changes things, but short of that, there's no reason not to trust Bloom when he said it's not a consideration.

It's so rare for a baseball ops leader to make a definitive statement like that on the record, and he's done it multiple times now.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Do Hayden Birdsong, Casey Schmitt and Erik Miller get (1-year rental) Nico Hoerner from the Cubs? Who says no?

Steve Adams
Not taking that offer for Hoerner if I'm the Cubs.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Freddy Peralta is pitching for what team by opening day?

Steve Adams
The Brewers.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Should I be concerned that Ryan O’Hearn hasn’t officially signed yet?

Steve Adams
Nah, deals struck around the holidays are always kind of wonky.

We're still getting DFA resolutions for guys who were designated like three weeks ago. It's the one time of the year where all rules regarding the timing of moves seems to go out the window.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Ryan just had his first kid. He’s locked in.

Steve Adams
Oh there you go. I didn't realize this. That certainly would help to explain the slower-than-expected timeline of his deal becoming official, too.
And hey, good for him!
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Which jersey will Arenado play his next game in?

Steve Adams
Honestly, I'd guess the Cardinals first and foremost. I just don't see any trade value. Angels probably next on the list, but St. Louis will need to be eating like $30MM of the $37MM they owe him.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Who are your top five players whose injuries stopped them from being truly great?

Steve Adams
Grady Sizemore immediately comes to mind
Mark Prior
Byron Buxton ... still good, but imagine if he wasn't on the IL for half the season every year

Tons more, I'm sure. Just going off the cuff here and focusing more on recent names than delving back into my childhood years in the 80s/90s.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Justin Morneau? David Wright?

Steve Adams
Two good ones -- Wright more so than Morneau, but man, that season Morneau was having when he took that concussion at second base. Oof. Joe Mauer, too, if we're talking about Twins from that era. Hell, throw Francisco Liriano in the mix.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Bo Jackson

Steve Adams
Indeed.

Fun and useless fact -- I went to college with Bo's son! Bo was at my graduation from my tiny D-3 college in southern Minnesota. My then-brother-in-law almost passed out when he saw him.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Steve Adams
Going to wrap up here, but lots of good names from the crowd on some potential greats who were cut down by injuries.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Eric Davis could’ve been one of the best to ever do it.

Josh Hamilton

Travis PRONK Hafner

JR Richard

Rocco Baldelli could've been great too if he wasn't hurt all the time...

Ben Sheets was incredible when he wasn't injured, still one of the greatest curve balls I've ever seen. You knew it was coming and just couldn't hit it.

Tony Conigliaro - for the injured list!

top 5 players injuries stopped from being great? PRINCE FIELDER?!
-----------------------------------------------------------------

phins
Sobbing quietly during Fox programming
Posts: 12085
Joined: June 9 06, 3:51 pm

Re: Steve Adams' NL Central comments

Post by phins »

Paying all but $7M of the remaining contract on Arenado for two years? That seems like a really low valuation of Arenado.

User avatar
Famous Mortimer
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 3961
Joined: November 14 14, 5:23 am
Location: Cherokee

Re: Steve Adams' NL Central comments

Post by Famous Mortimer »

That's why I couldn't do a job like this. I'd tell too many people to shut up with their stupid trade suggestions and their complete inability to remember anything other than whatever site is open in the other tab at that second.

Post Reply