Beltran and Andruw Jones to Hall Of Fame
-
jagtrader
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 12659
- Joined: June 5 06, 10:01 am
Re: Beltran and Andruw Jones to Hall Of Fame
Hall of Fame voting is largely justifying each person's inconsistencies. But Andy Pettitte getting 48 percent is an extraordinary case of many writers being completely full of [expletive].
- Famous Mortimer
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 3961
- Joined: November 14 14, 5:23 am
- Location: Cherokee
Re: Beltran and Andruw Jones to Hall Of Fame
I look forward to seeing it.
I went back and checked, and they're even closer comps than I remembered. Lester has a touch over 200 more strikeouts, but also walked almost 200 more guys. Within the WAR margin of error...they're extremely similar by the numbers. Maybe by the time their election comes round, 200 wins will be the new benchmark the writers will go for. I (partially) change my mind.
I went back and checked, and they're even closer comps than I remembered. Lester has a touch over 200 more strikeouts, but also walked almost 200 more guys. Within the WAR margin of error...they're extremely similar by the numbers. Maybe by the time their election comes round, 200 wins will be the new benchmark the writers will go for. I (partially) change my mind.
- Popeye_Card
- GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
- Posts: 31085
- Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am
Re: Beltran and Andruw Jones to Hall Of Fame
I don't think Pettitte, Wainwright, or Lester will ever make it. And that's ranking them in order of likelihood.
There's several WS rings among that group, but 0 Cy Youngs. Pettitte's best finish was 2nd, once, back when wins were the primary driver for voters. Wainwright generally did better - two 2nds, two 3rds - but I would also argue that for much of his career he wasn't even the best SP on his own team (Carpenter, who fell off the HoF ballot in his first year despite 2 rings, 1 Cy, plus a 2nd and 3rd finish). Lester's best finish was 2nd, and honestly I just don't see a case for him beyond his 3 rings.
There's several WS rings among that group, but 0 Cy Youngs. Pettitte's best finish was 2nd, once, back when wins were the primary driver for voters. Wainwright generally did better - two 2nds, two 3rds - but I would also argue that for much of his career he wasn't even the best SP on his own team (Carpenter, who fell off the HoF ballot in his first year despite 2 rings, 1 Cy, plus a 2nd and 3rd finish). Lester's best finish was 2nd, and honestly I just don't see a case for him beyond his 3 rings.
- cardinalkarp
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 18744
- Joined: May 4 06, 8:44 am
Re: Beltran and Andruw Jones to Hall Of Fame
Not being able to throw a ball to first base should disqualify him immediately.
- Popeye_Card
- GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
- Posts: 31085
- Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am
Re: Beltran and Andruw Jones to Hall Of Fame
That is a good point with that ballot. Every single player ahead of him has either eventually made it into the Hall, has the steroid stink on them, and/or has been given a second (sometimes third) shot through a different vote.dmarx114 wrote: ↑January 21 26, 8:09 amEdmonds fell victim to an over crowded ballot. Look how insane this was:
https://www.baseball-reference.com/awar ... 2016.shtml
13 guys ended up getting into the HOF at some point. And the steroid guys (Bonds, Clemens, McGwire, Sheffield, Sosa) and Schilling took up plenty of votes as well.
I think Edmonds will get in some day. Same with Lofton.
Hopefully Edmonds gets another shot.
-
jagtrader
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 12659
- Joined: June 5 06, 10:01 am
Re: Beltran and Andruw Jones to Hall Of Fame
Utley is the second base version of Edmonds. Playing in a big market helps.
- Popeye_Card
- GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
- Posts: 31085
- Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am
Re: Beltran and Andruw Jones to Hall Of Fame
If you want another example of a player done dirty by crowded ballots - Johan Santana. Fell off the ballot in his first year, with only 2.8%.
Given, he had an injury-shortened career. But here's his quick stat line - 139 wins, 2025.2 IP, 136 ERA+ (career), 5 seasons w/ ERA+ over 150, 2 Cy Youngs (5 straight top-5), 51.7 bWAR career.
Here's a comparison first-ballot HoF'er that also had an injury-shortened career: 165 wins, 2324.1 IP, 131 ERA+ (career), 4 seasons w/ ERA+ over 150, 3 Cy Youngs (4 straight top-5), 48.9 career bWAR.
That pitcher being...
While I think there is a difference, you also can't deny that Santana was the consensus Best Pitcher in Baseball for at least 3 straight seasons, and in that conversation for half a decade. And he fell off the ballot in his first year!
Given, he had an injury-shortened career. But here's his quick stat line - 139 wins, 2025.2 IP, 136 ERA+ (career), 5 seasons w/ ERA+ over 150, 2 Cy Youngs (5 straight top-5), 51.7 bWAR career.
Here's a comparison first-ballot HoF'er that also had an injury-shortened career: 165 wins, 2324.1 IP, 131 ERA+ (career), 4 seasons w/ ERA+ over 150, 3 Cy Youngs (4 straight top-5), 48.9 career bWAR.
That pitcher being...
While I think there is a difference, you also can't deny that Santana was the consensus Best Pitcher in Baseball for at least 3 straight seasons, and in that conversation for half a decade. And he fell off the ballot in his first year!

