Steve Adams' NL Central comments

Discuss all things Cardinals Baseball
Post Reply
User avatar
mikechamp
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 11769
Joined: April 17 06, 5:05 pm
Location: Southwestern Illinois

Steve Adams' NL Central comments

Post by mikechamp »

These comments came from a chat with MLB Trade Rumors' writer Steve Adams that occurred on January 27. (If you like him, you can find him on Twitter @Adams_Steve and Bluesky @adams-steve.bsky.social.)

Same number of questions this week, and still no bonus Q&As this time. Enjoy anyway!

The link to the entire chat can be found here: https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2026/01/ ... t-103.html

-----------------------------------------------------------------
Peralta return higher than the Burnes return? Any moves left for the Brewers this offseason?

Steve Adams
They’re pretty comparable returns — two top prospects on the back-end of most top-100 lists. I think the prospects themselves here are a bit more interesting than the Hall/Ortiz combo they got from Burnes, but they also got a Competitive Balance draft pick for Burnes, which has plenty of value itself. I imagine the Brewers will still look into some low-cost bullpen/bench additions as guys who are lingering on the market bring their demands down and accept lesser deals just to get into camp somewhere.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Jett Williams and Josh Knoth for CJ Abrams. Who says no?

Steve Adams
Washington, pretty easily.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Are the Giants still engaged with Brendan Donovan after signing Bader?

Steve Adams
No reason that adding Bader at a reasonable rate would take them out of the running for Donovan. If anything, Bader made the team better, which gives them more of an impetus to punt some future value to get their hands on Donovan.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Mountcastle and a low level prospect for JoJo?

Steve Adams
I don’t think that does much for the Cardinals. Mountcastle is a buy-low veteran who can be kept through 2027 via a club option. There’s no real long-term value there unless he bounces back and becomes a trade chip himself this summer, but acquiring him runs the risk of him continuing to struggle while also cutting into the playing time of someone like Alec Burleson. He’s also more expensive than Romero. If/when the Cardinals move Romero, I expect it’ll just be for a prospect or two.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Seattle should pivot to a CJ Abrams or Nico Hoerner or Matt Shaw and avoid Brendan Donovan… if possible. The value seems FAR better for what they’d seemingly be giving up.

Steve Adams
I think Abrams is a great fit in Seattle, sure. Donovan would be, too. I feel like the asking price on Hoerner and/or Shaw would be prohibitive relative to the immediate need in Seattle. I mean, sure Hoerner would be a nice upgrade, but they’d need to deal from the MLB roster, negating some of the value they get back, and it wouldn’t be cheap to add him regardless. Someone — Mariners, Pirates, Red Sox, Reds, Royals — should give up some good talent to get Abrams though. I think there’s another gear there, and he’s still only 25 with three years of club control remaining.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Who will the Nats start on the mound on Opening Day?

Steve Adams
I would imagine their Opening Day starter is whichever veteran they throw a year and $5-10MM at in the next few weeks. They need at least one source of steady innings in there. Tyler Anderson, Tomoyuki Sugano, Jose Quintana, Martin Perez, etc. … someone along those lines.

Mikolas if they really just want bulk innings (which would be defensible).
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Where do you see Goldy signing and when he goes to the HOF will it be as a Dback or a Cardinal?

Steve Adams
Back to Arizona makes a ton of sense. Could see any of the Padres, Reds, Angels trying to jump in on the cheap, but D-backs work nicely and probably have some extra motivation since it’ll go over so well with the fans. I imagine some fans will bristle at the cavalier assumption that Goldy is a HOFer, but I think he’s got a pretty clear-cut case and imagine he goes in as a D-back (especially if he re-signs there this winter).
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Garrett Mitchell: Over/under 100 games and 100 wRC+?

Steve Adams
Garrett Mitchell has barely played 100 games in the past three seasons combined. Easy under on games played for me, and I don’t think he makes close to enough contact to confidently project him as even an average hitter.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Is it correct to believe the Reds have not done one thing to make the team better going into 2026 than 2025? The starting pitching has one more year of experience which may help. Is it also safe to say that without a TV deal for the team, the chances of anything being added is very slim?

Steve Adams
I guess the bullpen feels a little better to me than it did with Suter, Gibaut, Barlow back there. Burke, Johnson and Ferguson are all fine additions. But, I think they way overpaid to keep Pagan and the moves on the offensive side of things have been pretty lackluster, so I can’t push back too heavily on the idea that they’re not much better than they were in 2025 (barring huge steps forward from guys like McLain, Marte, Chase Burns, etc).
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Do the Rangers employ an actual strategy of not spending more than 5M on a reliever? With bullpen contracts so expensive, could it be effective for teams to enter the season with mediocre pens and then attempt to fix them at the deadline if the team is competitive?

Steve Adams
They haven’t spent big on relievers recently, but that’s more due to having minimal payroll flexibility. As recently as 2024, they were spending $10MM+ on David Robertson (albeit with some deferrals, I think). We see teams take this piecemeal approach often, and the Rangers’ 2025 season feels like a pretty rare success story.

The Cubs have gone with the flea market approach to bullpen building for like seven years now, and last year was really the first time it worked for them.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
The Brewers have 2 closers in Megill and Uribe. Any rumor talk in the hot stove that one or the other is available in trade? The Giants have a terrible bullpen and could use one of these top arms.

Steve Adams
Mets, Yankees and others were looking at Megill earlier in the winter:
https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2025/12/ ... loser.html

I have to think that with Peralta’s $8MM off the books, a trade involving Megill is less likely now.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
True or false: Provided he pitches to his norms as a Cardinal, JoJo Romero will get the Cardinals more at the trade deadline than in the offseason.

Steve Adams
I don’t think there’s a real scenario where he nets them demonstrably more than he does right now, but I do think there’s a real scenario where he takes a step back and/or gets hurt and sufficiently deflates his trade value (as we saw last year when the Cards held onto Ryan Helsley too long).
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Eugenio Suarez a good fit for the Brewers? Potentially move Durbin to 2B, Turang to short?

Steve Adams
Milwaukee isn’t spending that kind of coin.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Why would the Pirates be in on any possible SS trade when #1 prospect Konnor Griffin is the near future?

Steve Adams
Is this in reference to me listing them for CJ Abrams earlier?

Abrams is a bad shortstop who’d be better off playing 2B or 3B.

But he can hit, he can run, and he’s 25 with three years of club control remaining.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Logan Allen, Juan Brito, Angel Genao for Brendan Donovan?

Steve Adams
Too much for CLE to give up.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
There’s no way the Red Sox can give up Early or Tolle for one year of Nico Hoerner right? That would be beyond insane.

Steve Adams
I’d be very, very surpised
-----------------------------------------------------------------
What fan base do you see the most of in your chats? And, the least of?

Steve Adams
Depends what’s in the news at a given moment, really. I would say in general, smaller-market teams like the Brewers and Pirates tend to make up a smaller portion of the audience. But this week I’m getting peppered with Brewers questions since they just executed a major trade. Early in the offseason, when the Bucs were throwing $120MM+ at Kyle Schwarber, I was getting tons of Pirates questions. I guess if I had to choose on team I get the fewest about… maybe the Rays? But again, I got plenty on them after the Baz and Lowe trades, so it’s all dependent on what’s topical at a given moment.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Who is the back up catcher in MIL this year?

Steve Adams
I feel like they’ll sign someone cheap or claim someone in camp. Doubt they limit Jeferson Quero to a backup role when he needs to be getting everyday ABs for his development

Doesn’t need to be anyone exciting. Any of Christian Vazquez, Reese McGuire, Luke Maile, Jonah Heim, etc. could be fine.
-----------------------------------------------------------------

phins
Sobbing quietly during Fox programming
Posts: 12085
Joined: June 9 06, 3:51 pm

Re: Steve Adams' NL Central comments

Post by phins »

Logan Allen is a generic BOTR pitcher. He has several years of control, so you probably value him as a borderline 45+/50 prospect.

Juan Brito is a 40 prospect.

Angel Genao has a chance to be a 55 prospect.

With the price of cost-controlled starting pitching and the upside runway of Genao, I do agree that's a bit much for Donovan. That's probably the realm you'd ask for in a Donovan/Romero trade and take out Brito.
Logan Allen, Juan Brito, Angel Genao for Brendan Donovan?

Steve Adams
Too much for CLE to give up.

User avatar
Famous Mortimer
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 3961
Joined: November 14 14, 5:23 am
Location: Cherokee

Re: Steve Adams' NL Central comments

Post by Famous Mortimer »

phins wrote: ↑
January 27 26, 10:38 pm
Logan Allen is a generic BOTR pitcher. He has several years of control, so you probably value him as a borderline 45+/50 prospect.

Juan Brito is a 40 prospect.

Angel Genao has a chance to be a 55 prospect.

With the price of cost-controlled starting pitching and the upside runway of Genao, I do agree that's a bit much for Donovan. That's probably the realm you'd ask for in a Donovan/Romero trade and take out Brito.
Logan Allen, Juan Brito, Angel Genao for Brendan Donovan?

Steve Adams
Too much for CLE to give up.
Is this appreciably different to this:
phins wrote: ↑
January 20 26, 7:40 pm
These chats must be run by fans of other NL Central teams the way they get after the Cardinals.

Most analysts agree the price for Donovan is a 50 FV prospect for each year of control remaining plus a lottery ticket as sweetener.

Matt Shaw is a 50 or 55 prospect, depending on who you ask. And this guy thinks just Shaw is too high of a price? Either my expectations are too high or these chat analysts are living in a world where Donovan is an average player.
Because it sounds like his value has dropped

phins
Sobbing quietly during Fox programming
Posts: 12085
Joined: June 9 06, 3:51 pm

Re: Steve Adams' NL Central comments

Post by phins »

Famous Mortimer wrote: ↑
January 28 26, 7:36 am
phins wrote: ↑
January 27 26, 10:38 pm
Logan Allen is a generic BOTR pitcher. He has several years of control, so you probably value him as a borderline 45+/50 prospect.

Juan Brito is a 40 prospect.

Angel Genao has a chance to be a 55 prospect.

With the price of cost-controlled starting pitching and the upside runway of Genao, I do agree that's a bit much for Donovan. That's probably the realm you'd ask for in a Donovan/Romero trade and take out Brito.
Logan Allen, Juan Brito, Angel Genao for Brendan Donovan?

Steve Adams
Too much for CLE to give up.
Is this appreciably different to this:
phins wrote: ↑
January 20 26, 7:40 pm
These chats must be run by fans of other NL Central teams the way they get after the Cardinals.

Most analysts agree the price for Donovan is a 50 FV prospect for each year of control remaining plus a lottery ticket as sweetener.

Matt Shaw is a 50 or 55 prospect, depending on who you ask. And this guy thinks just Shaw is too high of a price? Either my expectations are too high or these chat analysts are living in a world where Donovan is an average player.
Because it sounds like his value has dropped
What's your deal?

Post Reply