MLB Off-season 2025-'26 (Cardinals)

Discuss all things Cardinals Baseball
Post Reply
User avatar
Famous Mortimer
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 3961
Joined: November 14 14, 5:23 am
Location: Cherokee

Re: MLB Off-season 2025-'26 (Cardinals)

Post by Famous Mortimer »

ghostrunner wrote: ↑
January 30 26, 12:26 pm
I've come to think it should be someone roughly top 50, pretty much ready to go, or just don't bother.
Why would a team trade a player like that, though?

Let me put it a different way. Is there a team with a need at a position Donovan is decent at, with a top 50 prospect blocked for multiple years, who you think would make the trade? Perhaps this is just getting ready to have him still be a Cardinal, and I'm cool with that too, but I don't think that was the value he was expected to bring back at the beginning of the offseason.

WAR God
Veteran Player
Posts: 1171
Joined: August 2 22, 8:47 am

Re: MLB Off-season 2025-'26 (Cardinals)

Post by WAR God »

Famous Mortimer wrote: ↑
January 30 26, 8:24 pm
ghostrunner wrote: ↑
January 30 26, 12:26 pm
I've come to think it should be someone roughly top 50, pretty much ready to go, or just don't bother.
Why would a team trade a player like that, though?

Let me put it a different way. Is there a team with a need at a position Donovan is decent at, with a top 50 prospect blocked for multiple years, who you think would make the trade? Perhaps this is just getting ready to have him still be a Cardinal, and I'm cool with that too, but I don't think that was the value he was expected to bring back at the beginning of the offseason.
Because for many teams, they’re at the point on the win curve where an extra win or two is extremely valuable. Donovan is versatile, which provides lineup insurance and give him a better shot at producing his floor.

There’s also a good chance that the prospect we’re talking about reaches the majors and becomes Jordan Walker.

User avatar
Famous Mortimer
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 3961
Joined: November 14 14, 5:23 am
Location: Cherokee

Re: MLB Off-season 2025-'26 (Cardinals)

Post by Famous Mortimer »

WAR God wrote: ↑
January 31 26, 6:24 am
Famous Mortimer wrote: ↑
January 30 26, 8:24 pm
ghostrunner wrote: ↑
January 30 26, 12:26 pm
I've come to think it should be someone roughly top 50, pretty much ready to go, or just don't bother.
Why would a team trade a player like that, though?

Let me put it a different way. Is there a team with a need at a position Donovan is decent at, with a top 50 prospect blocked for multiple years, who you think would make the trade? Perhaps this is just getting ready to have him still be a Cardinal, and I'm cool with that too, but I don't think that was the value he was expected to bring back at the beginning of the offseason.
Because for many teams, they’re at the point on the win curve where an extra win or two is extremely valuable. Donovan is versatile, which provides lineup insurance and give him a better shot at producing his floor.

There’s also a good chance that the prospect we’re talking about reaches the majors and becomes Jordan Walker.
I was trying to get you to think of a hypothetical. It's easy to say "I want a top 50 prospect for Donovan" but significantly more difficult to work out, at the end of January, a team that'd be willing to make that trade.

User avatar
Popeye_Card
GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
Posts: 31085
Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am

Re: MLB Off-season 2025-'26 (Cardinals)

Post by Popeye_Card »

I’m not understanding why you are so hung up on this. A top 50-ish prospect is a perfectly reasonable return for Donovan. If nobody is currently willing to offer that, so be it. Don’t need to drop the price just to get rid of him.

User avatar
ghostrunner
GOAT
Posts: 30870
Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm

Re: MLB Off-season 2025-'26 (Cardinals)

Post by ghostrunner »

The thing is, we’re talking here about getting a short term bat so this lineup scores some runs. Donovan is part of that market right now, just via trade. And they have him already. He’s a bird in the hand. Ideally for this team it’d be someone with more power but you can still sign an outfielder who moves around making spot starts. And if not, this team is likely not contending for two seasons anyway.

The Mariners are a good fit because they’re contending and they have hitters, but they could still use one or two guys to put them over the top. We talked in this thread about Laz Montes from their system who’s at 43 on MLB. Even there, phins for one wasn’t too high on him. I think they need to be picky because the downside of not trading is 2 years of a productive player who can move just about anywhere depending on how the near future unfolds. So either get someone with high future upside and/or someone who can contribute right away. If you can’t, then don’t worry about it. If this farm system can turn around in the next year or two, Donovan still buys you some time. I think it being January works in our favor for that reason. We’re not desperate.

I think the ideal situation is they trade him for the high prospect and then sign Suarez at third if he’s willing. Not sure I would be if I were him.

I’d be fine trading Donovan and Jojo for that prospect return, and I wonder if that’s also been offered and turned down. If so, then I think just trade Jojo for some lower prospect and leave it at that.

Slider
All-Star
Posts: 1645
Joined: July 23 08, 2:36 pm

Re: MLB Off-season 2025-'26 (Cardinals)

Post by Slider »

Well, Giants won’t be a trade partner. Another hit to Donovan’s value.

User avatar
heyzeus
Everday Unicorn
Posts: 43331
Joined: April 21 06, 10:14 am
Location: Austin, TX

Re: MLB Off-season 2025-'26 (Cardinals)

Post by heyzeus »

ghostrunner wrote: ↑
January 31 26, 11:52 am
The thing is, we’re talking here about getting a short term bat so this lineup scores some runs. Donovan is part of that market right now, just via trade. And they have him already. He’s a bird in the hand. Ideally for this team it’d be someone with more power but you can still sign an outfielder who moves around making spot starts. And if not, this team is likely not contending for two seasons anyway.

The Mariners are a good fit because they’re contending and they have hitters, but they could still use one or two guys to put them over the top. We talked in this thread about Laz Montes from their system who’s at 43 on MLB. Even there, phins for one wasn’t too high on him. I think they need to be picky because the downside of not trading is 2 years of a productive player who can move just about anywhere depending on how the near future unfolds. So either get someone with high future upside and/or someone who can contribute right away. If you can’t, then don’t worry about it. If this farm system can turn around in the next year or two, Donovan still buys you some time. I think it being January works in our favor for that reason. We’re not desperate.

I think the ideal situation is they trade him for the high prospect and then sign Suarez at third if he’s willing. Not sure I would be if I were him.

I’d be fine trading Donovan and Jojo for that prospect return, and I wonder if that’s also been offered and turned down. If so, then I think just trade Jojo for some lower prospect and leave it at that.
Suarez just signed a 1/$15 deal with the reds. I know he's a flawed player in a number of ways, but also: He hit 49 HR last year.

User avatar
ghostrunner
GOAT
Posts: 30870
Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm

Re: MLB Off-season 2025-'26 (Cardinals)

Post by ghostrunner »

Well, I guess he would've been willing.

jagtrader
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12659
Joined: June 5 06, 10:01 am

Re: MLB Off-season 2025-'26 (Cardinals)

Post by jagtrader »

Playing in a stadium that’s a graveyard for home runs doesn’t help.

User avatar
TGantz
R-E-S-P-E-C-T...What Dr Pepper Means to Me
Posts: 6698
Joined: July 27 06, 11:59 pm
Location: The Lou

Re: MLB Off-season 2025-'26 (Cardinals)

Post by TGantz »

Who is back up 1B for Burly? Saggese or Fermin? Pages?

Gonna be a long season.

Post Reply