Fangraphs rundown of Cardinals' Top 53 prospects

Discuss all things Cardinals Baseball
phins
Sobbing quietly during Fox programming
Posts: 12085
Joined: June 9 06, 3:51 pm

Re: Fangraphs rundown of Cardinals' Top 53 prospects

Post by phins »

Popeye_Card wrote: ↑
February 10 26, 9:30 am
I like that we run pretty deep with 40+ rated prospects.

I don't like that 55 is the top end. It would be nice to have a potential superstar or two in the pipeline. Tough to get excited when the top end is solid players / occasional All-Star ceilings.

EDIT: I guess to be fair, if Rodriguez continues to catch at a passable defensive level and continues to mash, his bat could be pretty special at the position.
Also to be fair, FanGraphs has two prospects in all of baseball rated above a 55 currently.

One being a Brewers prospect sucks of course.

User avatar
CardsofSTL
All Hail the GDT Master
Posts: 70085
Joined: April 26 11, 6:06 am
Location: Columbus, OH

Re: Fangraphs rundown of Cardinals' Top 53 prospects

Post by CardsofSTL »

phins wrote: ↑
February 10 26, 7:38 pm
CardsofSTL wrote: ↑
February 10 26, 9:30 am
GeddyWrox wrote: ↑
February 10 26, 8:58 am
Cho and Davis caught my eye on that list too.
Cho is going to be a good player.
I would say that Cho has almost zero chance to become a good player at this point. I'm surprised he was on the main list. I'd much rather have Deniel Ortiz if forced to choose and he's most likely a 1B, with very little chance of being a good player as well.
I like his name so it's going to happen.

User avatar
Popeye_Card
GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
Posts: 31085
Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am

Re: Fangraphs rundown of Cardinals' Top 53 prospects

Post by Popeye_Card »

phins wrote: ↑
February 10 26, 7:40 pm
Popeye_Card wrote: ↑
February 10 26, 9:30 am
I like that we run pretty deep with 40+ rated prospects.

I don't like that 55 is the top end. It would be nice to have a potential superstar or two in the pipeline. Tough to get excited when the top end is solid players / occasional All-Star ceilings.

EDIT: I guess to be fair, if Rodriguez continues to catch at a passable defensive level and continues to mash, his bat could be pretty special at the position.
Also to be fair, FanGraphs has two prospects in all of baseball rated above a 55 currently.

One being a Brewers prospect sucks of course.
Is the prospect pool that poor right now, or are they being aggressively conservative with their FV ratings?

User avatar
Fan_In_NY
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 5410
Joined: April 18 06, 7:22 pm
Location: Birthplace of Baseball- Hoboken, NJ

Re: Fangraphs rundown of Cardinals' Top 53 prospects

Post by Fan_In_NY »

Popeye_Card wrote: ↑
February 10 26, 8:07 pm
phins wrote: ↑
February 10 26, 7:40 pm
Popeye_Card wrote: ↑
February 10 26, 9:30 am
I like that we run pretty deep with 40+ rated prospects.

I don't like that 55 is the top end. It would be nice to have a potential superstar or two in the pipeline. Tough to get excited when the top end is solid players / occasional All-Star ceilings.

EDIT: I guess to be fair, if Rodriguez continues to catch at a passable defensive level and continues to mash, his bat could be pretty special at the position.
Also to be fair, FanGraphs has two prospects in all of baseball rated above a 55 currently.

One being a Brewers prospect sucks of course.
Is the prospect pool that poor right now, or are they being aggressively conservative with their FV ratings?
I think they are only done with 1/3 of the teams so I do anticipate the number of 60+ prospects to increase a bit. But they also are only looking at the first 6 years of service time. 60 FV would mean all-star caliper and I think its tough to feel too confident than anyone in the minors right now would be an all-star in the first 6 years of service (with the exception of an "every team must have one pity pick"). Obviously some of these prospects will become all-stars and will exceed this 55 or 60 grade - but its probably their 80th percentile outcome and I think FG is looking at their 50th percentile outcome.

User avatar
Felix The Cat
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 8069
Joined: January 9 08, 5:30 pm

Re: Fangraphs rundown of Cardinals' Top 53 prospects

Post by Felix The Cat »

phins wrote: ↑
February 10 26, 7:40 pm
Popeye_Card wrote: ↑
February 10 26, 9:30 am
I like that we run pretty deep with 40+ rated prospects.

I don't like that 55 is the top end. It would be nice to have a potential superstar or two in the pipeline. Tough to get excited when the top end is solid players / occasional All-Star ceilings.

EDIT: I guess to be fair, if Rodriguez continues to catch at a passable defensive level and continues to mash, his bat could be pretty special at the position.
Also to be fair, FanGraphs has two prospects in all of baseball rated above a 55 currently.

One being a Brewers prospect sucks of course.
That guy in PIT will probably be rated even higher, right? ESPN has Griffin as their top prospect in baseball

phins
Sobbing quietly during Fox programming
Posts: 12085
Joined: June 9 06, 3:51 pm

Re: Fangraphs rundown of Cardinals' Top 53 prospects

Post by phins »

Felix The Cat wrote: ↑
February 10 26, 10:53 pm
phins wrote: ↑
February 10 26, 7:40 pm
Popeye_Card wrote: ↑
February 10 26, 9:30 am
I like that we run pretty deep with 40+ rated prospects.

I don't like that 55 is the top end. It would be nice to have a potential superstar or two in the pipeline. Tough to get excited when the top end is solid players / occasional All-Star ceilings.

EDIT: I guess to be fair, if Rodriguez continues to catch at a passable defensive level and continues to mash, his bat could be pretty special at the position.
Also to be fair, FanGraphs has two prospects in all of baseball rated above a 55 currently.

One being a Brewers prospect sucks of course.
That guy in PIT will probably be rated even higher, right? ESPN has Griffin as their top prospect in baseball
Most likely. Last year they had seven players above a 55.

A 55 prospect is a STUD in their view.

It's not fun to continually read me preach about how hard it is for any prospect to become an actual star, I'm sure, but the comment above is correct that FG is projecting 50th percentile outcomes (which is all that any decent model is trying to do).

Every prospect has wide error bars, but the "most likely outcome" is the projection.

In essence, saying that the most likely outcome for a prospect to be a star before he's ever played a game is huge.

Some read "Star" as Mike Trout/Albert Pujols etc. but those are their own world. No one is most likely to become that. A star is a 3 WAR player as your most likely outcome.

With the Cardinals having 50+ prospects with perceived major league talent and another round of lots of picks to go, the most likely outcome in aggregate is that one of them pops and becomes a true franchise type (4-WAR most likely player).

Adding to it they're moving along a timeline when the core should assemble together, I'd say the FO is structuring it the way I would.

Post Reply