If JJ has a Carroll or a PCA season, I can see the Cardinals signing him long term either after this year or next year.Fan_In_NY wrote: ↑March 24 26, 7:14 amDo we have any amount of data showing that the Cardinals front office won't sign star level in-house talent to extensions or for their second contract? The Cardinals have been so devoid of talent they haven't had this issue come up at all recently, so I don't think we can conclude that - especially not knowing the competitiveness of the team 6 years from now. Also the draft picks would be valuable to the team to replenish the farm system. The Diamondbacks got an extra pick for Corbin Carroll winning the ROY and took Ryan Waldschmidt who is their #1 top prospect right now #34 overall by Keith Law and #59 per MLB. So the clock of control for Carroll started 1 year earlier, but you also got a potential 6 more years of another player who can be a contributor-star.cardsfantx wrote: ↑March 23 26, 10:00 pmIf he’s really good and wins, an extra year of control is way more important (esp for a owner going on the cheap), than any draft pick we may receiveFan_In_NY wrote: ↑March 23 26, 8:47 pmWell if JJ wins the rookie of the year or finishes top 3 in MVP the next 3 seasons the Cards will get an extra draft pick after the first round. Right now JJ is the 3rd favorite, behind Nolan McLean and Konnor Griffin.cardsfantx wrote: ↑March 23 26, 3:19 pmI dunno...if we're gonna be real bad, JJ doesn't need to be on the roster and burn a year of control
if we're trying be ok, then Velázquez 100% needs to be on the roster. he at least has pop
Spring Training 2026
-
dmarx114
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 25482
- Joined: December 20 07, 2:45 pm
Re: Spring Training 2026
-
jagtrader
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 12659
- Joined: June 5 06, 10:01 am
Re: Spring Training 2026
The amazing part about sending down Velazquez is he’d probably bat 4th or 5th if he was on the team.
- ghostrunner
- GOAT
- Posts: 30870
- Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm
Re: Spring Training 2026
I think there's a few things going on -
Most important thing is that Velazquez isn't very good, regardless of what he did in ST. He had a 81 OPS+ in 2024, and neither the Pirates nor the Royals wanted to call him up last year. I don't know if they said it was a competition, but Bloom has been pretty consistent in saying that ST isn't going to decide anything. Velazquez would hit more HR than Walker if I had to bet, so normally I think there'd be a good argument there (probably him in LF, Church in RF) but Walker is obviously a last ditch effort they're making this season regardless.
Church and Saggese are some part of the team for the future.
Fermin and Saggese both give them more options day to day.
I think there's an argument for why not just waive Fermin and call up Prieto if you need him, but if they don't end up thinking Saggese works in the OF, Fermin is the only player that can play all over. They really didn't get a good look at Saggese out there due to him being gone for the WBC.
So I get it and it's really whatever. How much more does Velazquez get this team over Fermin? Not a lot. And Velazquez probably doesn't stay up once Noot is back unless Walker continues to be terrible (a reasonable possibility).
Most important thing is that Velazquez isn't very good, regardless of what he did in ST. He had a 81 OPS+ in 2024, and neither the Pirates nor the Royals wanted to call him up last year. I don't know if they said it was a competition, but Bloom has been pretty consistent in saying that ST isn't going to decide anything. Velazquez would hit more HR than Walker if I had to bet, so normally I think there'd be a good argument there (probably him in LF, Church in RF) but Walker is obviously a last ditch effort they're making this season regardless.
Church and Saggese are some part of the team for the future.
Fermin and Saggese both give them more options day to day.
I think there's an argument for why not just waive Fermin and call up Prieto if you need him, but if they don't end up thinking Saggese works in the OF, Fermin is the only player that can play all over. They really didn't get a good look at Saggese out there due to him being gone for the WBC.
So I get it and it's really whatever. How much more does Velazquez get this team over Fermin? Not a lot. And Velazquez probably doesn't stay up once Noot is back unless Walker continues to be terrible (a reasonable possibility).
- Lesson
- Grandmaster Flashchat
- Posts: 6630
- Joined: February 4 10, 4:35 pm
Re: Spring Training 2026
After Robert signed with White Sox, DeWitt and Mozeliak went on record as saying one of the factors as to why they didn't offer more was due to the cost of the second contract if he had performed well for his first.
- heyzeus
- Everday Unicorn
- Posts: 43331
- Joined: April 21 06, 10:14 am
- Location: Austin, TX
Re: Spring Training 2026
The Cards ownership shows its higher level thinking yet again. You can't ever get burned on a terrible second contract if you never sign big international free agents to a first contract.
-
jagtrader
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 12659
- Joined: June 5 06, 10:01 am
Re: Spring Training 2026
At some point, you have to play the guys who perform and not the guys you hope will perform. If Velazquez falls apart, you replace him. You don’t tell him to go earn it when half the hitters on the roster haven’t earned anything.
Does it matter in the big picture? No. Nothing does this season because they let Mozeliak cripple the franchise for half a decade. But maybe they can set a standard that you actually need to play well to be on the team.
Does it matter in the big picture? No. Nothing does this season because they let Mozeliak cripple the franchise for half a decade. But maybe they can set a standard that you actually need to play well to be on the team.
- Fan_In_NY
- Perennial All-Star
- Posts: 5410
- Joined: April 18 06, 7:22 pm
- Location: Birthplace of Baseball- Hoboken, NJ
Re: Spring Training 2026
That was 9 years ago and now there is a different head of baseball operations so it don't know if that edict is still in place. I don't think it is smart baseball, but it also could have been expressed as part of labor negotiations as i believe back in 2017 when Robert signed there was no International Signing cap/budget/bonus pool so owners pleading/complaining about how much labor is going to cost in anticipation of negotiating a new CBA and new international signing rules. By the way, Robert has been paid $76M for about 13.7 WAR.heyzeus wrote: ↑March 24 26, 12:43 pmThe Cards ownership shows its higher level thinking yet again. You can't ever get burned on a terrible second contract if you never sign big international free agents to a first contract.
- ghostrunner
- GOAT
- Posts: 30870
- Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm
Re: Spring Training 2026
I think it’s fair to think a good spring doesn’t mean someone performed well enough to land a spot. It’s one thing if you’re Walker and looking exactly like you have been for two years. But if you’re putting up a career high in OPS then maybe it’s not something to take too seriously. Gorman should have one of DH or 3rd if that’s the standard.
- st.lewis11
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 15773
- Joined: June 14 06, 10:17 pm
- Location: Small southern IL town, 40 min from STL
Re: Spring Training 2026
Just my opinion, but with Velazquez in left, Chase Davis in center, and Joshua Baez in right, I feel Memphis will have a better OF than St Louis.
- TGantz
- R-E-S-P-E-C-T...What Dr Pepper Means to Me
- Posts: 6698
- Joined: July 27 06, 11:59 pm
- Location: The Lou
Re: Spring Training 2026
Certainly more power with the Memphis OF. Church and Scott can run circles around Memphis defensively. Fermin hits for average and Walker has potential to be the best OF in the organization or the worst so no idea what to expect.st.lewis11 wrote: ↑March 24 26, 7:56 pmJust my opinion, but with Velazquez in left, Chase Davis in center, and Joshua Baez in right, I feel Memphis will have a better OF than St Louis.



