jim wrote:I predict Cub fans will stop talking about Steve Bartman when Cardinal fans stop talking about Don Denkinger. And on that day, hell will reach a high of -40F.
I think the difference is that Denkinger unjustly affected the outcome of the game.
Bartman was minding his own business, and did what almost any of us would have done. Denkinger failed to do a job that he was being paid to do.
Alou catching that ball was an extreme long shot. Orta being out was a "sure thing".
There are pretty distinct difference, in my opinion.
jim wrote:I predict Cub fans will stop talking about Steve Bartman when Cardinal fans stop talking about Don Denkinger. And on that day, hell will reach a high of -40F.
Exactly. Every fanbase has a villain (or two, or three) that they LOVE to hate, and blame this villain for losing the most important game of their lifetime. This may be media driven, but the fans LOVE it and eat it up with a passion. On a similar note, sports reporters will find a way to turn every team in the playoffs into the "underdog" or "hard luck" type of story. Every team.
jim wrote:Did you read "Reversing the Curse"? Many Card fans will shy away from that one, but it's really a good book that really gave me some insight into the suffering (and hate of the Yankees). On jim's recommended list.
I haven't, but will add it to my book list, even though I hate Dan Shaughnessy. That's how powerful the jim seal of approval is for a book- it overcomes my loathing of Shaughnessy.
I would like to see someone track down the names of some of the other idiots that were sitting around Bartman when he caught the ball. If you watch the video of it you'll see at least 4-5 other dumbasses trying to do the same thing he did but no one tried crucifing them,in fact,some of them imediatly turned on him.
Hudler wrote:I would like to see someone track down the names of some of the other idiots that were sitting around Bartman when he caught the ball. If you watch the video of it you'll see at least 4-5 other dumbasses trying to do the same thing he did but no one tried crucifing them,in fact,some of them imediatly turned on him.
Preach on, brother! Bartman's hand wasn't the only one up there. Where are the other souvenir seekers?
Socnorb11 wrote:So do you think it's worse to get to the World Series, and fail to win, as opposed to not getting there at all? I'm not sure. Maybe it is worse. As a Cardinal fan, 2004 was awfully painful.......... so I can see that.
I think it's much, much, much worse to get there and lose than it is to not get there at all. You can't have your hopes dashed if you don't have hope.
I gotta disagree here. I'd take the 2004 Cardinals season over the 2007 season any day. When you make it to the world series that means you've had 6 months and over 162 games to enjoy. Sure it hurts when it's all over, but it only hurts so bad because it was so great. Going into a season with no hope, like Pirates fans and Royals fans have to do, would be the worst.
Bartman is a fan who scored a great seat for a pivotal playoff game - one that could have sent his team to its first World Series in 58 years. I can only imagine how psyched I would've felt in his situation. And then one foul ball and his life is forever changed, and he becomes a pariah. Media concoction or not, he now lives in virtual seclusion shrouded by his family and coworkers. He gets all the sympathy I can muster.
"Dan May, a law student watching on TV last week at Murphy’s Bleachers as the Cubs closed in on the division title, said: “If he came in right now, I wouldn’t shoot him. But I’d break his knees.”"
Ah Dan, you're about to become another proud member of my profession. I couldn't be happier. Thanks for making sure that I will have to say "But I'm really a good person, I swear" every time I tell someone that I'm a lawyer. For the rest of my life.