docellis wrote:But he won. I e-mailed him a list of things that I would like (for him to choose from).
You did the right thing.
The real fun by my estimation is in knowing that the person got something that they wanted, thereby avoiding a situation in which they're forced to pretend that they like what you got them when they really don't.
I agree, you sent him a list of things that you might want so at you're not sure exactly what you're getting.
Men in general are not that good at picking out Christmas presents.
docellis wrote:But he won. I e-mailed him a list of things that I would like (for him to choose from).
You did the right thing.
The real fun by my estimation is in knowing that the person got something that they wanted, thereby avoiding a situation in which they're forced to pretend that they like what you got them when they really don't.
I agree, you sent him a list of things that you might want so at you're not sure exactly what you're getting.
Men in general are not that good at picking out Christmas presents.
Men, by their very nature, are randomly inconsiderate. Sometimes they just can't pick up on hints that women drop, or lack the creativity to think-outside-the-box and get them something that really surprises them.
What usually ends up happening is that they panic trying to find the best possible gift, and end up giving the worst possible gift.
In my experience, women can be pretty terrible gift-givers as well. I think the difference is, men forget about it and move on. If a woman gets a bad gift from her mate, she never forgets it.
In alot of cases women tend to just buy what they want. Picking out something like clothes is damn near impossible so that rules that out.
I tried the lingerie route this year and we'll see how that goes. I bought my wife a gift card in the past so she could go pick out what she wants/likes but she would always say "I want YOU to pick me out something", so I tried that this year.
In the case of buying her a bosu ball. Its kind of a risky gift because I don't want her to get it and think "does this mean that he thinks I should start working out?" That's not the case but its still got the risk factor to it.
Then I got her a couple other things that she had hinted that she had wanted but she more than likely realizes she's going to get them.
I guess its a combo of two things. Women tend to be hard to buy for and men just aren't that good at picking things out that women would like.
Edit: So I'm definitely trying this year to think of somethings that she didn't just put on a list but that doesn't necessarily mean she's going to like them. I'm keeping my fingers crossed though!
You did good. A bosu ball is on the list I gave my boyfriend.
I think I am getting my boyfriend an external hard drive filled with all the music he ever downloaded (so he can bring it back and forth to work to listen to there, or to share with his friends), some type of Makers Mark gift set, and some random cigar gift set.
In my specific case, I have succeeded in giving some ridiculously good presents to women, be it mom, a friend, or a girlfriend. These few successes have made me overly perfectionistic about it.
I just can't bring myself to buy, say, a CD or a nice hat or something unless it's something I know she'd open and get weak-in-the-knees happy that I thought of it.
In terms of this Christmas, I'm under even more pressure as the current She has hinted that her present found for me is, as far as she's currently concerned, perfect for me. And she knows me pretty well, so I'm pretty sure she's going to 'win' this year. Luckily her birthday is a few weeks off so I have time to think of something great for that one.
Back to my original beef, this is assuming she returns successfully from her trip to Illogical Island.
I'm lucky at xmas time, because most of my lady friends have had a pretty big appreciation for my woodworking talents, and I can always make them a surprise gift that wins me some big points. A bit more time-consuming than buying something, but it's worth it for the brownie points.
But I'm terrible shopping for everyone else. I'm almost willing to call a truce with my parents--don't buy me anything, and I won't get you anything--deal?
I think its fun to think of what someone else would want, but there is always the fear of giving the wrong thing. I'm usually able to get something outside of the box and good though.
I've found that if there is sincere effort, it doesn't usually matter if its not perfect. Then again, I usually go for the REALLY personal gift. In the past I've gotten a book signed by a favorite author, gotten a nice, hardcover copy of a favorite text, art is nice if you really know the person... etc.