good think you don't live in IowaMichael wrote:Jim Hendry's Chins wrote:Iowa passed a law quite a while back making it illegal to picket/protest at funerals. I have no idea why more states haven't.
That doesn't sound constitutional. i'm not a fan of that law.
Westboro morons showing up at college kids' funerals
- Jim Hendry's Chins
- Fringe Major League Player
- Posts: 106
- Joined: July 30 06, 9:56 pm
- Location: watching the Cubs, God help me
Re: Westboro morons showing up at college kids' funerals
- Jim Hendry's Chins
- Fringe Major League Player
- Posts: 106
- Joined: July 30 06, 9:56 pm
- Location: watching the Cubs, God help me
- Radbird
- There's someone in my head but it's not me
- Posts: 62390
- Joined: April 18 06, 5:08 pm
- Location: LF Bleachers @ Busch II
Re: Westboro morons showing up at college kids' funerals
Ha - I guess we simultaneously disagree...Michael wrote:Jim Hendry's Chins wrote:Iowa passed a law quite a while back making it illegal to picket/protest at funerals. I have no idea why more states haven't.
That doesn't sound constitutional. i'm not a fan of that law.
I understand the constitutional aspect, but I think that allowing someone to be buried without disruption is a reasonable restriction on "freedom of speech". There are plenty of other opportunities/venues to express your views about somebody.
- cardsfansince82
- is shooing asian children away from his fridge.
- Posts: 27776
- Joined: May 17 06, 10:23 pm
- Location: at the gettin' place
Re: Westboro morons showing up at college kids' funerals
I can't come up with a single scenario where it would be reasonable to picket or protest at a funeral. Even if one exists, you would be more likely to incite a riot than bring about any positive outcome.Michael wrote:Jim Hendry's Chins wrote:Iowa passed a law quite a while back making it illegal to picket/protest at funerals. I have no idea why more states haven't.
That doesn't sound constitutional. i'm not a fan of that law.
- sighyoung
- Mayor of GRB
- Posts: 38643
- Joined: April 17 06, 7:42 pm
- Location: Louisville
Re: Westboro morons showing up at college kids' funerals
That statute seems reasonably written, because it allows a privacy perimeter around the funeral, and states concerns about public disruptions and potential rioting.
I can't imagine that courts would allow anybody to shut down free speech altogether, and I'm sure judges would have to decide how much of a buffer is reasonable, and to what extent the statute hampers free speech.
I can't imagine that courts would allow anybody to shut down free speech altogether, and I'm sure judges would have to decide how much of a buffer is reasonable, and to what extent the statute hampers free speech.
-
Michael
- GRB Founder
- Posts: 35304
- Joined: December 31 69, 6:00 pm
- Location: Chicago, IL
- Contact:
Re: Westboro morons showing up at college kids' funerals
Obliviously they shouldn't be allowed to actually go to the funeral however being outside of it is within their rights. I want the right to protest whatever the heck I want as long as I'm not completely destructive. Sometimes freedom can mean other people are going to piss you off when they exercise their rights however the cost is well worth the benefits.
- Radbird
- There's someone in my head but it's not me
- Posts: 62390
- Joined: April 18 06, 5:08 pm
- Location: LF Bleachers @ Busch II
Re: Westboro morons showing up at college kids' funerals
Dad sues ‘Thank God for Dead Soldiers’ church
Now, more than four years after his son died in a Humvee accident in Iraq, Snyder's legal battle is headed to the Supreme Court. And his tireless efforts have drawn support from across the country, including a wave of donations after he was ordered to pay the church's court costs — a $16,500 judgment that the congregation plans to use for more protests.
Snyder won the first round decisively, when a jury in federal court in Baltimore awarded him $10.9 million in damages in October 2007. A judge later reduced the award to $5 million.
Last September, the 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals reversed the verdict, ruling Westboro's protest was constitutionally protected speech.
Appeals court ruling
The Supreme Court agreed last month to consider whether the protesters' actions, no matter how provocative and upsetting, are protected by the First Amendment. The case will be argued in the fall.
Then something unexpected happened: The appeals court ordered Snyder to pay Westboro $16,510 in court costs. While it's not unusual for the losing party in a civil case to be required to pay some costs, it rarely happens when an individual sues a private entity, especially when the case is still active, experts say.
Margie Jean Phelps, one of Fred Phelps' daughters and an attorney, will argue the case before the Supreme Court. She has said the church plans to use the money from Snyder to stage more protests. That's what's so upsetting to Snyder, who says he would drop the matter if the church stopped picketing funerals.
- Joe Shlabotnik
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 24292
- Joined: October 12 06, 2:21 pm
- Location: Baseball Ref Bullpen
- Contact:
Re: Westboro morons showing up at college kids' funerals
So if we can't protest at Phelp's funeral, can we come back that night and piss on his grave?Radbird wrote: I understand the constitutional aspect, but I think that allowing someone to be buried without disruption is a reasonable restriction on "freedom of speech". There are plenty of other opportunities/venues to express your views about somebody.
- cards2468
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 14745
- Joined: October 28 06, 11:10 pm
- Location: LOVE IT OR LEAVE IT
Re: Westboro morons showing up at college kids' funerals
how about granting americans the right to bury the deceased in peace?
that way protesting at a funeral is only illegal because in infringes on the rights of others
that way protesting at a funeral is only illegal because in infringes on the rights of others
- Leroy
- a bad penny always turns up
- Posts: 25228
- Joined: April 17 06, 12:27 pm
- Location: Hanging out with my redneck, white socks and Blue Ribbon beer.
- Contact:
Re: Westboro morons showing up at college kids' funerals
Up here, a couple of friends of ours son was killed in Iraq a couple of years ago. There were rumblings that these nuts were going to protest, and another rumor that some anti war people would be there as well. Local bikers got together and formed some group and made sure that everything was peaceful. They didn't mind protests, just wanted the family to have a decent funeral ceremony. Thumbs up from me.




