Brett Favre.

The forum for ranting, raving, complaining and praising
Post Reply
Faceman
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 4800
Joined: May 23 06, 11:56 am
Location: Memphis, TN

Re: Brett Favre.

Post by Faceman »

Socnorb11 wrote:
omaha_red wrote:he may be the biggest icon of any team or city ever and he's destroying it all in one week.
Jordan/Bulls
Elway/Broncos
Montana/49ers
Ruth/Yankees
Lemieux/Penguins


........just to name a few.

But you're right, he's tarnished the legacy in a big big way.
I read the comment differently. New York, Chicago have had multiple huge stars. You are talking about possibly the greatest passer ever (not my opinion, but some would say) in a town of Green Bay.

NY: Ruth shares the spotlight with Jeter, Namath, Willis Reed
SF: Jerry Rice, Barry Bonds
Pit: Clemente, Stargell, Harris, Bradshaw,

Favre's Icon status is greater than most because of his setting.

User avatar
Radbird
There's someone in my head but it's not me
Posts: 62390
Joined: April 18 06, 5:08 pm
Location: LF Bleachers @ Busch II

Re: Brett Favre.

Post by Radbird »

Faceman wrote:
Socnorb11 wrote:
omaha_red wrote:he may be the biggest icon of any team or city ever and he's destroying it all in one week.
Jordan/Bulls
Elway/Broncos
Montana/49ers
Ruth/Yankees
Lemieux/Penguins


........just to name a few.

But you're right, he's tarnished the legacy in a big big way.
I read the comment differently. New York, Chicago have had multiple huge stars. You are talking about possibly the greatest passer ever (not my opinion, but some would say) in a town of Green Bay.

NY: Ruth shares the spotlight with Jeter, Namath, Willis Reed
SF: Jerry Rice, Barry Bonds
Pit: Clemente, Stargell, Harris, Bradshaw,

Favre's Icon status is greater than most because of his setting.
Let's not forget about Starr, Hornung, Nitschke or Lombardi, just to name a few.

I hardly think Brett is alone on the stage of Packer greats.

User avatar
TheoSqua
Next Gen Wart
Posts: 8951
Joined: April 22 06, 6:53 pm
Location: St. Louis
Contact:

Re: Brett Favre.

Post by TheoSqua »

Meh, this won't ruin his legacy.

Did Joe Montana playing for the cheifs ruin his legacy?
How about Jordan playing for the Wizards?
Jerry Rice in Oakland?
Gretzky in New York?
Emmit Smith in Arizona?

I'm sure the same thing with Edmonds in Chicago and Bruce in San Fran will happen.

Once they retire, the stupid few years on another team, wether it's cause by the player or the team being stupid, isn't remembered near as much as the legacy they created with that team.

Socnorb11
The Last Word
Posts: 21909
Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am

Re: Brett Favre.

Post by Socnorb11 »

TheoSqua wrote:Meh, this won't ruin his legacy.

Did Joe Montana playing for the cheifs ruin his legacy?
How about Jordan playing for the Wizards?
Jerry Rice in Oakland?
Gretzky in New York?
Emmit Smith in Arizona?

I'm sure the same thing with Edmonds in Chicago and Bruce in San Fran will happen.

Once they retire, the stupid few years on another team, wether it's cause by the player or the team being stupid, isn't remembered near as much as the legacy they created with that team.
I don't think any of those players held their teams hostage and jerked their teams around the way that Favre is. I believe all of those players left their teams on good terms.

tscards
Veteran Player
Posts: 1233
Joined: April 20 06, 6:28 pm
Location: Sioux Falls, SD

Re: Brett Favre.

Post by tscards »

Socnorb11 wrote:
TheoSqua wrote:Meh, this won't ruin his legacy.

Did Joe Montana playing for the cheifs ruin his legacy?
How about Jordan playing for the Wizards?
Jerry Rice in Oakland?
Gretzky in New York?
Emmit Smith in Arizona?

I'm sure the same thing with Edmonds in Chicago and Bruce in San Fran will happen.

Once they retire, the stupid few years on another team, wether it's cause by the player or the team being stupid, isn't remembered near as much as the legacy they created with that team.
I don't think any of those players held their teams hostage and jerked their teams around the way that Favre is. I believe all of those players left their teams on good terms.
Agree. Would be an entirely different situation if he didn't give his retirement speech, change his mind, change it again, be a jerk.... If the Packers just simply released him at the end of a season & he played this year for another team, I'd be entirely ok with it ... disappointed, maybe, but ok. This crap is not ok.

phins
Sobbing quietly during Fox programming
Posts: 12085
Joined: June 9 06, 3:51 pm

Re: Brett Favre.

Post by phins »

Emmitt Smith did not want to leave...the Cowboys ushered him out when he wasn't ready to quit.

Isaac Bruce: Same thing.

Joe Montana: Same thing.

Joe Namath: Same thing.

The difference? Brett Favre can still play, and play well. If he couldn't, guess what the Packers would do with him? Tell him to retire or be released.

Favre is wrong in the way he has waffled on his decision, but if the Packers really were forcing a decision he wasn't ready to make, I don't think he's completely to blame, and I don't think he's doing anything terribly wrong other than coming off as a baby to the media. Favre should be able to play as long as he wants to, and a team will have him, just like the other guys who lost their luster.

Again, my only problem with him in all of this is the flip-flopping he has done.

Socnorb11
The Last Word
Posts: 21909
Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am

Re: Brett Favre.

Post by Socnorb11 »

phinstd wrote:Emmitt Smith did not want to leave...the Cowboys ushered him out when he wasn't ready to quit.

Isaac Bruce: Same thing.

Joe Montana: Same thing.

Joe Namath: Same thing.

The difference? Brett Favre can still play, and play well. If he couldn't, guess what the Packers would do with him? Tell him to retire or be released.

Montana could still play...... he just wasn't healthy. When he got healthy, he led the Chiefs to the AFC Championship Game. I don't recall Emmett Smith being "ushered out".

The real difference is that none of those players held their teams hostage when they decided it was time to go, and none of them threw their ex-team under the bus the way that Favre has. And none of them flip-flopped as much as Favre has. Those are pretty substantial differences, in my opinion.

If Favre can still play, why don't you think the Packers are welcoming him back?

User avatar
JL21
NPR & THT Contributor
Posts: 36109
Joined: April 18 06, 7:44 am
Location: Chocolate City

Re: Brett Favre.

Post by JL21 »

Montana was a huge baby on his way out of SF. The Niners had Steve Young, who was younger and was the future of the franchise.

I wouldn't use Montana as an example of how an icon should behave when departing their original franchise.

phins
Sobbing quietly during Fox programming
Posts: 12085
Joined: June 9 06, 3:51 pm

Re: Brett Favre.

Post by phins »

Socnorb11 wrote:
phinstd wrote:Emmitt Smith did not want to leave...the Cowboys ushered him out when he wasn't ready to quit.

Isaac Bruce: Same thing.

Joe Montana: Same thing.

Joe Namath: Same thing.

The difference? Brett Favre can still play, and play well. If he couldn't, guess what the Packers would do with him? Tell him to retire or be released.

Montana could still play...... he just wasn't healthy. When he got healthy, he led the Chiefs to the AFC Championship Game. I don't recall Emmett Smith being "ushered out".

The real difference is that none of those players held their teams hostage when they decided it was time to go, and none of them threw their ex-team under the bus the way that Favre has. And none of them flip-flopped as much as Favre has. Those are pretty substantial differences, in my opinion.

If Favre can still play, why don't you think the Packers are welcoming him back?
I see no differences other than you don't like the way Favre has handled it. All sports greats past their primes, with younger players ready to take their spots, with fans of that team ready to move on in some circles, and ready to bring him back in others. Favre is doing what is right by him, just like NFL teams do over and over again. Get yours Brett, when they're done with you, they'll certainly be done with you.

I'm not going to address the last part, as you really didn't just ask if Brett Favre can still play after the season he put up last year. He is better than at least half the NFL QB's out there.

The NFL is the one sport I have no problem with players using every drop of leverage they can get, anytime they can get it. The system is set up great for owners, teams, fans, everyone but the players. You have the power for a minute Brett, use it to get what you want, while you can. If he wasn't being whiney about it, and just stood strong in his decision, I wouldn't have any problem at all with Favre.
Last edited by phins on July 17 08, 11:11 am, edited 1 time in total.

Socnorb11
The Last Word
Posts: 21909
Joined: June 21 06, 8:45 am

Re: Brett Favre.

Post by Socnorb11 »

JL21 wrote:Montana was a huge baby on his way out of SF. The Niners had Steve Young, who was younger and was the future of the franchise.

I wouldn't use Montana as an example of how an icon should behave when departing their original franchise.
My recollection wasn't that good, and I couldn't find anything online to indicate that he left on bad terms. That doesn't mean it's not true, however.

The point is that I don't think he ever held them hostage, or threw them under the bus in prime time.

Post Reply