Dark Knight

[thrill]

I know it's not the common stance on this, but I think Gyllenhall's more attractive.

There, I said it.

I'm with you

What's it like being blind? I hear your hearing is redonk.

[Popeye_Card]

I know it's not the common stance on this, but I think Gyllenhall's more attractive.

There, I said it.

I'm with you

I'm on board. Katie is attractive enough, but kinda plain. Maggie looks more "interesting". I think it's the eyes, and the kinda weird smile.

[TimeForGuinness]

I know it's not the common stance on this, but I think Gyllenhall's more attractive.

There, I said it.

I'm with you

What's it like being blind? I hear your hearing is redonk.

hey now...i dunno why...but there is just something about Maggie that is just really attractive

[clevername]

that's what I never get about this comparison. I can see people finding Holmes more attractive, that's fine. I don't get all the people who exclaim that Gyllenhall's just flat out ugly and seemingly doing it regardless of the comparison.

And that was around before the whole Dark Knight thing came about.

[ThatGuy]

The jowls are sorta weird looking to me.

[Michael]

I know it's not the common stance on this, but I think Gyllenhall's more attractive.

There, I said it.

I'm with you

Madness.

[ghostrunner]

It's not that I find Katie Holmes unattractive, but she's not a very good actress IMO and that always brings a movie down.

[JL21]

I prefer Maggie, if we're doing the "Who's hotter?" thing. But that's primarily for two reasons.

1. Katie Holmes = married to Tom Cruise

2. Maggie runs circles around Katie Holmes as an actress

On the big, bad list of 50 actresses I'd most like to do the worm with, neither would be on the list.

[OmahaCard79]

Maggie is odd to me. Look at her pics on imdb. Sometimes, she looks really attractive to me. Other times, even in red carpet pics, she looks really, really, really bad.

FWIW, I think she looked really good in TDK.

[InvincibleCakeEater]

I know it's not the common stance on this, but I think Gyllenhall's more attractive.

There, I said it.

I'm with you

What's it like being blind? I hear your hearing is redonk.

hey now...i dunno why...but there is just something about Maggie that is just really attractive

I think it's because she looks like Jake