I agree with this, but this is still a pretty sick story.Leroy wrote:I would suggest that any act of violence is a hate crime. I don't know why one would be worse than another.
Hate crimes
- cards2468
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 14745
- Joined: October 28 06, 11:10 pm
- Location: LOVE IT OR LEAVE IT
Re: Hate crimes
- sighyoung
- Mayor of GRB
- Posts: 38643
- Joined: April 17 06, 7:42 pm
- Location: Louisville
Re: Hate crimes
If the act of violence is also used to terrorize or control a broader community (such as a lynching), or to spur a wider range of attacks on a community (such as ethnic cleansing), I would think that would be taken into account.Leroy wrote:I would suggest that any act of violence is a hate crime. I don't know why one would be worse than another.
I don't think that applies to every act of violence based on prejudice, however.
- ghostrunner
- GOAT
- Posts: 30871
- Joined: April 18 06, 9:40 pm
Re: Hate crimes
I agree with that, but I'm not a fan of special legislation when it comes to this kind of thing. I don't know why it's more illegal to kill some people and not others, or why the punishment should be greater. Especially when the act of simply hating is perfectly legal.sighyoung wrote:If the act of violence is also used to terrorize or control a broader community (such as a lynching), or to spur a wider range of attacks on a community (such as ethnic cleansing), I would think that would be taken into account.Leroy wrote:I would suggest that any act of violence is a hate crime. I don't know why one would be worse than another.
I don't think that applies to every act of violence based on prejudice, however.
As far as deterrence, I doubt anyone mentally tacks on the extra months or years of a potential sentence when they decide to do something like this. If the laws are there to just make a statement that this isn't okay, that's not what laws are for. Societal pressure has to do that job. In fact, I'd imagine the laws likely have a reverse effect of ticking off the people who hold these views and lend weight to the idea that "liberal" government is intrusive.
Not to mention the possibility of the law being mistakenly applied based on what someone thinks motivations may have been.
-
AWvsCBsteeeerike3
- "I could totally eat a pig butt, if smoked correctly!"
- Posts: 27578
- Joined: August 5 08, 11:24 am
- Location: Thinking of the Children
Re: Hate crimes
people that are found guilty of hate crimes just ought to be shot in the head. If you're ignorant enough to try to hurt or kill someone because they are different than you, then you ought to forfeit all your inherent rights, including life.sighyoung wrote:If the act of violence is also used to terrorize or control a broader community (such as a lynching), or to spur a wider range of attacks on a community (such as ethnic cleansing), I would think that would be taken into account.Leroy wrote:I would suggest that any act of violence is a hate crime. I don't know why one would be worse than another.
I don't think that applies to every act of violence based on prejudice, however.
That said, I wish the law and the media would pay attention to ALL hate crimes, not just ones committed by a certain ethnicity.
- Sutter'sBeard
- is the oscar meyer weiner kid
- Posts: 3140
- Joined: July 25 06, 1:02 pm
- Location: Decatur, IL
Re: Hate crimes
Agreed, I don't think it would matter to me if someone punched me in the face because they wanted to take my donut or if it was because I was white.Leroy wrote:I would suggest that any act of violence is a hate crime. I don't know why one would be worse than another.
- docellis
- America's Most Beloved Twitter Joke Thief
- Posts: 24741
- Joined: April 18 06, 6:54 pm
Re: Hate crimes
Love crimes are better.
- sighyoung
- Mayor of GRB
- Posts: 38643
- Joined: April 17 06, 7:42 pm
- Location: Louisville
Re: Hate crimes
I hope mrs. sigh attacks me tonight.docellis wrote:Love crimes are better.
- sighyoung
- Mayor of GRB
- Posts: 38643
- Joined: April 17 06, 7:42 pm
- Location: Louisville
Re: Hate crimes
I can understand some posters' concerns, and in many instances, I would agree. In others, though, I think there is a qualitative difference in the kind of crime being committed.
An extreme example, but a true one--I knew a man from Mississippi whose entire community was marched out one day to watch a black man be eviscerated in front of them. To the murdered man, yes, murder was murder, but the impact on the community was horrible, too.
Or my great uncle, a decorated hero during World War I, who escaped lynching only because he was warned in time not to wear his uniform in his small Kentucky town. Another veteran wasn't warned, and was promptly lynched--again, as a lesson to the local community that armed, trained black men would not be allowed to step out of their places.
Hate crime legislation was intended to recognize the terroristic intent of some of these acts--not to say that a minority life is more precious than a white life. Is such legislation effective, or the concept of terroristic intent applicable to all such crimes? Ghostrunner raises some very good objections.
But as I said, whether or not such legislation is wiped off the books, I would still want some recognition--at least in sentencing--of the social impact of some of these acts.
An extreme example, but a true one--I knew a man from Mississippi whose entire community was marched out one day to watch a black man be eviscerated in front of them. To the murdered man, yes, murder was murder, but the impact on the community was horrible, too.
Or my great uncle, a decorated hero during World War I, who escaped lynching only because he was warned in time not to wear his uniform in his small Kentucky town. Another veteran wasn't warned, and was promptly lynched--again, as a lesson to the local community that armed, trained black men would not be allowed to step out of their places.
Hate crime legislation was intended to recognize the terroristic intent of some of these acts--not to say that a minority life is more precious than a white life. Is such legislation effective, or the concept of terroristic intent applicable to all such crimes? Ghostrunner raises some very good objections.
But as I said, whether or not such legislation is wiped off the books, I would still want some recognition--at least in sentencing--of the social impact of some of these acts.
- cards2468
- Hall Of Famer
- Posts: 14745
- Joined: October 28 06, 11:10 pm
- Location: LOVE IT OR LEAVE IT
Re: Hate crimes
Those are horrific acts of hatred, but when a girl is raped on Lindell Blvd between Grand and Vandeventer, is that not a major social impact on women, or even men who worry about their female loved ones, who live in this vicinity?sighyoung wrote:I can understand some posters' concerns, and in many instances, I would agree. In others, though, I think there is a qualitative difference in the kind of crime being committed.
An extreme example, but a true one--I knew a man from Mississippi whose entire community was marched out one day to watch a black man be eviscerated in front of them. To the murdered man, yes, murder was murder, but the impact on the community was horrible, too.
Or my great uncle, a decorated hero during World War I, who escaped lynching only because he was warned in time not to wear his uniform in his small Kentucky town. Another veteran wasn't warned, and was promptly lynched--again, as a lesson to the local community that armed, trained black men would not be allowed to step out of their places.
Hate crime legislation was intended to recognize the terroristic intent of some of these acts--not to say that a minority life is more precious than a white life. Is such legislation effective, or the concept of terroristic intent applicable to all such crimes? Ghostrunner raises some very good objections.
But as I said, whether or not such legislation is wiped off the books, I would still want some recognition--at least in sentencing--of the social impact of some of these acts.
- Leroy
- a bad penny always turns up
- Posts: 25229
- Joined: April 17 06, 12:27 pm
- Location: Hanging out with my redneck, white socks and Blue Ribbon beer.
- Contact:
Re: Hate crimes
Good post sigh. I'll reconsider my position.



