Hate crimes

The forum for ranting, raving, complaining and praising
User avatar
sighyoung
Mayor of GRB
Posts: 38643
Joined: April 17 06, 7:42 pm
Location: Louisville

Re: Hate crimes

Post by sighyoung »

Leroy wrote:Good post sigh. I'll reconsider my position.
Well, you've caused me to temper mine. I think there are many instances of, say, teenage knuckleheads assaulting somebody, where it is, tragically but simply, knuckleheaded assault.

User avatar
haltz
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 22630
Joined: November 9 06, 6:45 am
Location: a proud midwestern metropolis

Re: Hate crimes

Post by haltz »

sighyoung wrote:
Leroy wrote:Good post sigh. I'll reconsider my position.
Well, you've caused me to temper mine. I think there are many instances of, say, teenage knuckleheads assaulting somebody, where it is, tragically but simply, knuckleheaded assault.
yeah, I love the spirit of the law, but there's a large grey area that scares me. It's not really unique to hate crime legislation either.

planet planet
http://tinyurl.com/2e4x5hy
Posts: 24904
Joined: April 15 06, 6:25 pm
Location: St. Louis

Re: Hate crimes

Post by planet planet »

The "group think" mentality of hate crimes is unique as well. With the exception of "The Accused", rape is typically a singular activity.

User avatar
cards2468
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 14745
Joined: October 28 06, 11:10 pm
Location: LOVE IT OR LEAVE IT

Re: Hate crimes

Post by cards2468 »

planet pujolsian wrote:The "group think" mentality of hate crimes is unique as well. With the exception of "The Accused", rape is typically a singular activity.
So what about the gang crimes on the Metro that has led to many people refusing to take Metro and those who don't have a choice to be terrified when riding?

User avatar
sighyoung
Mayor of GRB
Posts: 38643
Joined: April 17 06, 7:42 pm
Location: Louisville

Re: Hate crimes

Post by sighyoung »

cards2468 wrote:
planet pujolsian wrote:The "group think" mentality of hate crimes is unique as well. With the exception of "The Accused", rape is typically a singular activity.
So what about the gang crimes on the Metro that has led to many people refusing to take Metro and those who don't have a choice to be terrified when riding?
Nobody is gainsaying the traumatic effects of violent crime, or its broader poisoning effect on civic society. But I think my examples were akin to domestic terrorism--the systematic use of violence for political or economic coercion. Certainly, when hate crime legislation was drafted, this is what was being addressed, as it had occurred before and during the Civil Rights movement. As ghostrunner, Leroy, and haltz are suggesting, the daily impact of such laws has been much more broad and imprecise, rendering the laws problematic.

But your questions equate all traumatic violence, to the point where distinctions collapse. If so, why do we have laws against terrorism if, as your questions suggest, all crimes cause terror?

User avatar
cards2468
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 14745
Joined: October 28 06, 11:10 pm
Location: LOVE IT OR LEAVE IT

Re: Hate crimes

Post by cards2468 »

sighyoung wrote:
cards2468 wrote:
planet pujolsian wrote:The "group think" mentality of hate crimes is unique as well. With the exception of "The Accused", rape is typically a singular activity.
So what about the gang crimes on the Metro that has led to many people refusing to take Metro and those who don't have a choice to be terrified when riding?
Nobody is gainsaying the traumatic effects of violent crime, or its broader poisoning effect on civic society. But I think my examples were akin to domestic terrorism--the systematic use of violence for political or economic coercion. Certainly, when hate crime legislation was drafted, this is what was being addressed, as it had occurred before and during the Civil Rights movement. As ghostrunner, Leroy, and haltz are suggesting, the daily impact of such laws has been much more broad and imprecise.

But your questions equate all traumatic violence, to the point where distinctions collapse. If so, why do we have laws against terrorism if, as your questions suggest, all crimes cause terror?
I'm not necessarily no crime should be defined as terrorism or as a hate crime, but I do think the definition should be revised. When a person or group targets homosexuals, it is not a hate crime. When women are targeted, it's not a hate crime. When white people are targeted, it is not a hate crime. The definition of "hate crime" served its purpose in history, but obviously society changes and the definition should change too

User avatar
sighyoung
Mayor of GRB
Posts: 38643
Joined: April 17 06, 7:42 pm
Location: Louisville

Re: Hate crimes

Post by sighyoung »

cards2468 wrote:
sighyoung wrote:
cards2468 wrote:
planet pujolsian wrote:The "group think" mentality of hate crimes is unique as well. With the exception of "The Accused", rape is typically a singular activity.
So what about the gang crimes on the Metro that has led to many people refusing to take Metro and those who don't have a choice to be terrified when riding?
Nobody is gainsaying the traumatic effects of violent crime, or its broader poisoning effect on civic society. But I think my examples were akin to domestic terrorism--the systematic use of violence for political or economic coercion. Certainly, when hate crime legislation was drafted, this is what was being addressed, as it had occurred before and during the Civil Rights movement. As ghostrunner, Leroy, and haltz are suggesting, the daily impact of such laws has been much more broad and imprecise.

But your questions equate all traumatic violence, to the point where distinctions collapse. If so, why do we have laws against terrorism if, as your questions suggest, all crimes cause terror?
I'm not necessarily no crime should be defined as terrorism or as a hate crime, but I do think the definition should be revised. When a person or group targets homosexuals, it is not a hate crime. When women are targeted, it's not a hate crime. When white people are targeted, it is not a hate crime. The definition of "hate crime" served its purpose in history, but obviously society changes and the definition should change too
Actually, many African Americans have been charged with and convicted of hate crimes against whites, for instance. These laws apply quite broadly.

But I certainly agree with you--the definition should probably be revised.

Post Reply