New HWY 40/64 -the good the bad and the ugly

The forum for ranting, raving, complaining and praising
Post Reply
User avatar
Popeye_Card
GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
Posts: 31089
Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am

Re: New HWY 40/64 -the good the bad and the ugly

Post by Popeye_Card »

cards2468 wrote: This is another serious issue with St. Louis. You can never tear anything down. This is why the city has gone to hell and surrounding towns have declined tremendously. Chicago might have a lot of construction as well as Boston, but they have no problem tearing down old decrepit crap to make way for the new and improved.

Highway 40 was never fit to be an interstate. St. Louis should have cut its losses and built a new length of interstate... preferably 1 that features its own bridge rather than having a single bridge carrying the traffic of 4 interstates.
Um, I very much prefer that we don't tear down historic buildings or cut highways through historic districts. So that's not a serious issue at all in my book. It would be a very serious issue to me if they proposed a new highway. Not tearing down old buildings isn't why portions of St. Louis have declined. Middle-class "white flight" is why portions of St. Louis have declined.

There is a plan for a new length of interstate with it's own bridge. I-70 is going to cross the river north of downtown, and is supposed to be the through-traffic highway. If and when they can ever finalize the financing for the $1 billion bridge.

As we've stated on here, Hwy 40 isn't really a through-traffic interstate. It's mostly local traffic going between downtown and west county, and all points in-between. There's a large volume of traffic that goes back and forth between those points. Short of building another highway that parrallels it (good luck getting folks in Clayton volunteering to build it in their backyard), we have what we have.

Traffic in StL isn't that bad at all, outside of the large volumes during rush hour on highways. There are much, much worse cities in regards to traffic design.

BenNX74205
All-Star
Posts: 2541
Joined: April 18 06, 2:57 pm

Re: New HWY 40/64 -the good the bad and the ugly

Post by BenNX74205 »

Popeye_Card wrote:
cards2468 wrote: This is another serious issue with St. Louis. You can never tear anything down. This is why the city has gone to hell and surrounding towns have declined tremendously. Chicago might have a lot of construction as well as Boston, but they have no problem tearing down old decrepit crap to make way for the new and improved.

Highway 40 was never fit to be an interstate. St. Louis should have cut its losses and built a new length of interstate... preferably 1 that features its own bridge rather than having a single bridge carrying the traffic of 4 interstates.
Um, I very much prefer that we don't tear down historic buildings or cut highways through historic districts. So that's not a serious issue at all in my book. It would be a very serious issue to me if they proposed a new highway. Not tearing down old buildings isn't why portions of St. Louis have declined. Middle-class "white flight" is why portions of St. Louis have declined.

There is a plan for a new length of interstate with it's own bridge. I-70 is going to cross the river north of downtown, and is supposed to be the through-traffic highway. If and when they can ever finalize the financing for the $1 billion bridge.

As we've stated on here, Hwy 40 isn't really a through-traffic interstate. It's mostly local traffic going between downtown and west county, and all points in-between. There's a large volume of traffic that goes back and forth between those points. Short of building another highway that parrallels it (good luck getting folks in Clayton volunteering to build it in their backyard), we have what we have.

Traffic in StL isn't that bad at all, outside of the large volumes during rush hour on highways. There are much, much worse cities in regards to traffic design.
Totally agree with you Popeye. 64/40 in St. Louis IS NOT a through-traffic highway. These days it's for West County to head downtown. Whenever it originally became an interstate, in St. Louis it probably still served that same purpose. If you're going west of St. Louis, and you're on 64, you are switching to a different highway basically right after you cross the bridge into Missouri.

64/40 is basically an interstate in name only in the St. Louis area. Hell, my parents still call it "highway 40." I didn't know it was Interstate anything until I went to college and ended up taking it all the way there (which was pretty freaking awesome from a MapQuest perspective).

And "not tearing old crap down" isn't why St. Louis is stagnating. It's the aforementioned white flight as well as a bit of historical mismanagement. St. Louis made it's mark as a riverboat town. They chose to ignore the possibility that riverboats would not continue to be the backbone of commerce when the railroad was introduced, and instead let Chicago become the railway hub, and drive it into one of the largest metropolitan areas in the nation.

User avatar
cards2468
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 14745
Joined: October 28 06, 11:10 pm
Location: LOVE IT OR LEAVE IT

Re: New HWY 40/64 -the good the bad and the ugly

Post by cards2468 »

Walk around St. Louis and look at all the abandoned buildings. It's an eyesore and a joke. I got my dad a book for xmas that shows St. Louis from the 30's 40's and 50's and images of the same locations today. It's incredible how down hill a city can go. Go to any other city and tell me how many abandoned warehouses you see within a 100 yards of downtown. Or how about the abandoned bridge that was half torn down that used to carry Spring from Forrest Park? Does this [expletive] really have historical value?

User avatar
Popeye_Card
GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
Posts: 31089
Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am

Re: New HWY 40/64 -the good the bad and the ugly

Post by Popeye_Card »

cards2468 wrote:Walk around St. Louis and look at all the abandoned buildings. It's an eyesore and a joke. I got my dad a book for xmas that shows St. Louis from the 30's 40's and 50's and images of the same locations today. It's incredible how down hill a city can go. Go to any other city and tell me how many abandoned warehouses you see within a 100 yards of downtown. Or how about the abandoned bridge that was half torn down that used to carry Spring from Forrest Park? Does this [expletive] really have historical value?
Yes.

Some of the most beautiful areas of the city today were half-crumbling slums 30 years ago. I don't want to lose anything that can realistically be saved. When you tear it down, you remove St. Louis' unique character, and it might as well be Indianapolis, Columbus, or any other non-descript mid-major city. No thanks.

User avatar
Maclowery
Child Pot Activist
Posts: 7742
Joined: June 15 06, 7:27 am
Location: NYC

Re: New HWY 40/64 -the good the bad and the ugly

Post by Maclowery »

Downtown St Louis sucks. But that's a big improvement from ten years ago, when it was a nightmare. It's weird to explain to my friends who live in Chicago permanently that there are about four areas - all less than a few blocks total - that are 'walkable' in the sense they are at least interesting, have open stores/restaurants/bars/cultural draws.

I'm not some Chi-town homer or something; I plan on settling down in St Louis Land, but there is so much that could happen to beautify the downtown area that isn't happening. I'm no economist or urban planner, so I can't really be constructive about it. It's just not a city you can park a car and walk around in. Again, I'm referring to the immediate downtown; ie, within a mile or so of the Arch. Delmar and the Central West End are fun and vibrant, but they're way out.

Freed Roger
Seeking a Zubaz seamstress
Posts: 26073
Joined: September 4 07, 1:48 pm
Location: St. Louis

Re: New HWY 40/64 -the good the bad and the ugly

Post by Freed Roger »

Maclowery wrote:Downtown St Louis sucks. But that's a big improvement from ten years ago, when it was a nightmare. It's weird to explain to my friends who live in Chicago permanently that there are about four areas - all less than a few blocks total - that are 'walkable' in the sense they are at least interesting, have open stores/restaurants/bars/cultural draws.

I'm not some Chi-town homer or something; I plan on settling down in St Louis Land, but there is so much that could happen to beautify the downtown area that isn't happening. I'm no economist or urban planner, so I can't really be constructive about it. It's just not a city you can park a car and walk around in. Again, I'm referring to the immediate downtown; ie, within a mile or so of the Arch. Delmar and the Central West End are fun and vibrant, but they're way out.
it doesn't help that the biggest developer in St. Louis went broke and abandoned numerous projects downtown in midstream. Ironically the guys business was called Pyramid I believe.

User avatar
cards2468
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 14745
Joined: October 28 06, 11:10 pm
Location: LOVE IT OR LEAVE IT

Re: New HWY 40/64 -the good the bad and the ugly

Post by cards2468 »

Popeye_Card wrote:
cards2468 wrote:Walk around St. Louis and look at all the abandoned buildings. It's an eyesore and a joke. I got my dad a book for xmas that shows St. Louis from the 30's 40's and 50's and images of the same locations today. It's incredible how down hill a city can go. Go to any other city and tell me how many abandoned warehouses you see within a 100 yards of downtown. Or how about the abandoned bridge that was half torn down that used to carry Spring from Forrest Park? Does this [expletive] really have historical value?
Yes.

Some of the most beautiful areas of the city today were half-crumbling slums 30 years ago. I don't want to lose anything that can realistically be saved. When you tear it down, you remove St. Louis' unique character, and it might as well be Indianapolis, Columbus, or any other non-descript mid-major city. No thanks.
I watched this crap happen first hand when I worked for the Covington Community Council. Nothing could ever be built because of historic preservation societies. People couldn't even buy more efficient window sills for their homes because of preservation laws. Covington remains a crumbling piece of crap across the river from Cincinnati while Newport is actually growing into a decent city buy finding a good balance between tearing down and preserving. St. Louis has been on a downhill slide for the past 50 years and the city should really learn that it's time to turn a corner and join the rest of the world.

User avatar
Popeye_Card
GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
Posts: 31089
Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am

Re: New HWY 40/64 -the good the bad and the ugly

Post by Popeye_Card »

Actually, the city of St. Louis is very much on the rise. Not just downtown and the CWE. Most of South city is pretty nice. No, its not downtown Chicago. It doesn't have to be. There are plenty of members on this forum--including myself--who live in South city and love it. I will agree that there are still slums in this city. There probably always will be, even if you razed places and built new ones. But its not like other big cities don't have these problems. Ever been to South Chicago?

User avatar
cards2468
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 14745
Joined: October 28 06, 11:10 pm
Location: LOVE IT OR LEAVE IT

Re: New HWY 40/64 -the good the bad and the ugly

Post by cards2468 »

Popeye_Card wrote:Actually, the city of St. Louis is very much on the rise. Not just downtown and the CWE. Most of South city is pretty nice. No, its not downtown Chicago. It doesn't have to be. There are plenty of members on this forum--including myself--who live in South city and love it. I will agree that there are still slums in this city. There probably always will be, even if you razed places and built new ones. But its not like other big cities don't have these problems. Ever been to South Chicago?
Clamor all you want about South city and various suburban areas, but it doesn't change the fact that St. Louis is filled with abandoned crap holes that need to be torn down. Every city has a bad area... but at least it's just an area they have an not the city as a whole...

User avatar
Popeye_Card
GRB's most intelligent & humble poster
Posts: 31089
Joined: April 17 06, 11:25 am

Re: New HWY 40/64 -the good the bad and the ugly

Post by Popeye_Card »

Just so that we are clear here, the whole city of St. Louis is crap and should be torn down?

If you think that, you should get out more. Just walk around Soulard and think about how much better it would look if it was torn down and filled in with suburban style housing 50 years ago. Or walk down 18th street in Lafayette Square and think about how much cooler it would be if those dang preservationists hadn't stood up for a slum and just let the city build it's north-south distributor highway like they wanted. Walk around the new houses built between Lafayette Square and LaSalle Park and wonder if the city is better off building places like that in the place of the old stuff.

I'm a proud preservationist. Tearing down "old crap" doesn't take care of the problems. It just builds projects in their place. If you want to live in a city that's clean and new, by all means move there. Please leave St. Louis to the thousands of hard working preservationists who are doing our best to make this city great, and not just another bland midwestern city..

Post Reply