Updated: Ownership and Jeff Gordon

Discuss all things Cardinals Baseball
jim
Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
Posts: 50393
Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm

Re: Updated: Ownership and Jeff Gordon

Post by jim »

I think it's legit to complain about both .... they are kind of different animals. In general, too much money is being spent and it's being driven by a couple of teams. That's argument number 1. But that doesn't mean, that given the realities, that I don't want our team to spend what it takes to put a winning team out there.

The Red Sox are a strange animal when you look at it. It's a unique situation that allows them to have gobs and gobs of money to bring in tremendous talent, yet be in a situation where they absolutely must be smart with it or they will get trounced by a team spending signficantly more than them.

I think DeWitt, like all baseball owners, is the natural enemy because owners view baseball as a business, fans view it as a game. It's oil and water, fan and owner, game and business. Always has and always will.

User avatar
cpebbles
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 8829
Joined: August 30 07, 12:28 pm

Re: Jeff Gordon has his head so far up DeWitt's.....

Post by cpebbles »

greenback44 wrote:The Cardinals don't have to overtake the Cubs to make the playoffs.
Nominal Wild Card contention is a claim that many clubs can make at this point, not an excuse to invest millions of dollars at the possible expense of more legitimate title aspirations in the near future. The most optimistic projection I've seen has us at 13% to make the playoffs. The $8 million in lost payroll would still only be expected to buy us about two wins, which bumps us all the way up to about a 20-25% chance at the WC, under the most optimistic projections. By MARCEL, it puts us two wins over .500.
I've read two predictions many times over the last couple of years. The first is that the Cardinals will spend the money when bad contracts come off the books (I hate that phrase) and the second is that they will trade some good prospects when the time is right (or a little bit differently, that the lack of trades is a consequence of having a crap farm system, which has now been rectified). I'll believe it when I see it, because I'm convinced Luhnow was brought into the fold to institute Moneyball, and in a Moneyball world winning 90 games on $70 million is better than winning 95 games on $120 million. Luhnow's a businessman, and Moneyball is great business even if it's not great baseball.

Systemic issues aren't compelling to me (especially when Strauss is reporting the Cardinals have already sold 2.7 million tickets), since it's too easy to say alternatively "the economy is terrible!" or "the market for free agents is crazy!" to explain away inaction. What matters is relative position, and the Cardinals are not now and, with St. Louis dying, likely never will be in a position where a top tier player, especially a top tier starting pitcher, is more valuable to them than to the usual big market suspects.
Well, given the moves of this front office I'd say that "Moneyball" is absolutely nothing but a meaningless buzzword to them. There is an obviously greater emphasis on developing their own talent, but that is hardly exclusively the M.O. of teams with tight-fisted front offices. Regardless, $120 million is not a feasible payroll figure for this team unless DeWitt and company choose to operate at an enormous operating loss each year, which is not a sustainable business plan in a limited market like St. Louis.

I honestly don't see the Cardinals going the way of the immediately post-Gord Ash Blue Jays, but even if I'm wrong the team's reluctance to operate at an eight-figure net loss is hardly evidence of that. The ownership group by all accounts went into their own pocket to keep the team from the early part of this decade together in order to get the stadium built. Anyone who was disappointed that the new stadium didn't lead to increased payroll is right to be upset about having been taken in by team propaganda, but payroll was not immediately slashed, it was just maintained (Leading to a nice yearly profit in line with what other teams are making) and there was nothing to suggest that the case would be otherwise right up until the recession became a fact that most teams were planning for.

Half of the teams in baseball have lowered their payrolls for next season. Of those that didn't, the majority of them were active very early in free agency. I agree about looking at relative position, and the Cardinals are dropping from 11th to 12th in opening day payroll. They are hardly the only ones making an issue of this economy.

User avatar
Jmodene
Still waiting for someone to use a Weird Al song
Posts: 15528
Joined: April 18 06, 5:54 pm
Location: Las Vegas, NV

Re: Updated: Ownership and Jeff Gordon

Post by Jmodene »

jim wrote: I think DeWitt, like all baseball owners, is the natural enemy because owners view baseball as a business, fans view it as a game. It's oil and water, fan and owner, game and business. Always has and always will.
This is quite true. Check out some of the various histories of the Cards, and you'll find that Sam Breadon and Branch Rickey were chided far more so than Dewitt for being "cheap", way back when, both by fans and especially by the media (J. Roy Stockton, in particular, with his "Sam, you sliced the baloney too thin" comment in 1946).

(Yes, I know that the word "media" didn't really exist in 1946 - I typed it out before I realized I should have said "newspapers".) ;)

jim
Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
Posts: 50393
Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm

Re: Updated: Ownership and Jeff Gordon

Post by jim »

Jmodene wrote:
jim wrote: I think DeWitt, like all baseball owners, is the natural enemy because owners view baseball as a business, fans view it as a game. It's oil and water, fan and owner, game and business. Always has and always will.
This is quite true. Check out some of the various histories of the Cards, and you'll find that Sam Breadon and Branch Rickey were chided far more so than Dewitt for being "cheap", way back when, both by fans and especially by the media (J. Roy Stockton, in particular, with his "Sam, you sliced the baloney too thin" comment in 1946).

(Yes, I know that the word "media" didn't really exist in 1946 - I typed it out before I realized I should have said "newspapers".) ;)
Yep, it's always been.

I have an inalienable right as a fan to complain about owners. It's part of my job description. It's not only a right, but a responsibility.

User avatar
Jmodene
Still waiting for someone to use a Weird Al song
Posts: 15528
Joined: April 18 06, 5:54 pm
Location: Las Vegas, NV

Re: Updated: Ownership and Jeff Gordon

Post by Jmodene »

Of course, it's that way in all walks of life - the people controlling whatever commodity you want is naturally at odds with the buying public, trying to deliver as little as possible for as much return as possible. (How do you think casinos have done business all these years?)

The question, of course, is whether we actually do have the right to complain when we're not satisfied. It's harder in the entertainment field (and baseball falls under that category) because the commodity being given is somewhat intangible - you can send back a bad steak at a restaurant, but it's harder to send back a bad movie, or a bad concert, or a bad baseball team - all we can really do is refuse to partake further.

Which reminds me of Connie Mack in the 1940's, telling A's fans "We can promise our patrons good baseball and nothing else."

jim
Red Lobster for the seafood lover in you
Posts: 50393
Joined: May 1 06, 2:41 pm

Re: Updated: Ownership and Jeff Gordon

Post by jim »

Jmodene wrote:Of course, it's that way in all walks of life - the people controlling whatever commodity you want is naturally at odds with the buying public, trying to deliver as little as possible for as much return as possible. (How do you think casinos have done business all these years?)

The question, of course, is whether we actually do have the right to complain when we're not satisfied. It's harder in the entertainment field (and baseball falls under that category) because the commodity being given is somewhat intangible - you can send back a bad steak at a restaurant, but it's harder to send back a bad movie, or a bad concert, or a bad baseball team - all we can really do is refuse to partake further.

Which reminds me of Connie Mack in the 1940's, telling A's fans "We can promise our patrons good baseball and nothing else."
I could stop spending my money and following the game, but that's not likely. So I'll just continue to complain, secretly content with nothing more than good baseball.

User avatar
Jmodene
Still waiting for someone to use a Weird Al song
Posts: 15528
Joined: April 18 06, 5:54 pm
Location: Las Vegas, NV

Re: Updated: Ownership and Jeff Gordon

Post by Jmodene »

Well, as they say, a bad baseball game is still better than a good almost anything else. ;)

greenback44
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 11665
Joined: June 26 06, 8:54 pm
Location: In a Small Town with Jack and Diane

Re: Jeff Gordon has his head so far up DeWitt's.....

Post by greenback44 »

cpebbles wrote:The most optimistic projection I've seen has us at 13% to make the playoffs. The $8 million in lost payroll would still only be expected to buy us about two wins, which bumps us all the way up to about a 20-25% chance at the WC, under the most optimistic projections.
Tails are much fatter than these distributions present, but that's an issue tangential to this discussion. Suffice to say that the SD would be 6 wins (what these projections have been showing) if you know the team's talent with absolutely certainty, which isn't possible obviously.

FYI FWIW RLYW ran ZiPS through DMB and found 17.5%. Not a huge difference, but it is better (and I believe it's pre-Reyes (EDIT: Nope, but only 62 innings from Carpenter apparently)) and there are few teams that could benefit more from that extra $8 million than the Cardinals, especially at a time when wins are can be bought on the cheap.
I honestly don't see the Cardinals going the way of the immediately post-Gord Ash Blue Jays, but even if I'm wrong the team's reluctance to operate at an eight-figure net loss is hardly evidence of that.
The evidence is that they haven't given up a draft pick for a free agent in seven years. Since the Haren deal four years ago, Terry Evans is the best prospect they've traded away to acquire major league talent, and while these teams have hardly been good, the Cardinals have been in pennant races the last three seasons, putting them very much in a position to benefit from such trades. Turning this around, aside from spare parts, there's hardly any evidence that they have any interest in adding talent at the major league level. The economy can give some cover this year (well, there are those 2.7 million tickets sold, so maybe not)and Soriano's and Zito's contracts can be used to excuse prior years' behaviors, but if DeWitt's waiting for the libertarians' Perfect Market, then you could be waiting on DeWitt for a while.

The Jocketty Era is over. This isn't Huizenga/Loria, nor is it the return of the brewery years, so I'm not interested in righteous indignation over the issue. But a change has happened, and when the team goes from the Edmonds and Kile trades to waiting for Pete Kozma and PJ Boggsworth, I can understand why some folks are disappointed.

User avatar
Captain Redbird
Fringe Major League Player
Posts: 147
Joined: January 25 09, 7:33 pm

Re: Updated: Ownership and Jeff Gordon

Post by Captain Redbird »

I understand baseball is a business, but part of the fun is to aquire new players. "Gordo" apparently doesn't want us to get new players. Everytime he opens his mouth, a babie cries.
Just read this beauty:

http://www.stltoday.com/stltoday/sports ... enDocument

:? :x

User avatar
Captain Redbird
Fringe Major League Player
Posts: 147
Joined: January 25 09, 7:33 pm

Re: Updated: Ownership and Jeff Gordon

Post by Captain Redbird »

Here is yet another great story from this idiot: http://www.stltoday.com/stltoday/sports ... enDocument

If we let Greene go...we'll have money for other needs...
If we let Glaus go...we'll have money for other needs...
If we let Ankiel go...we'll have money for other needs...

How does this nut have a job? It's okay to kiss @ss for DeWallet, but not twice a week!

Post Reply