There is a bear joke that always puzzled me. It never fails to get a laugh from those who haven't heard it, provided they are drunk. Yet if you think about it, it makes no sense.
it goes something like this:
old joke wrote:"A bear and a rabbit are taking a [expletive] in the woods. The bear asks the rabbit, "Hey, do you ever have problems with [expletive] sticking to your fur?" the rabbit says "No, why?" so the bear grabs the rabbit and wipes his ass with it.
but if you think about it, if you were going to wipe your ass with the rabbit wouldn't you WANT the [expletive] to stick to the rabbit's fur? What would be the use of wiping your ass with something that [expletive] DIDN'T stick to? And yet the joke totally won't work that way.