Dumb students who plagiarize

The forum for ranting, raving, complaining and praising
User avatar
a_smith
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 4561
Joined: September 20 06, 10:55 am

Re: Dumb students who plagiarize

Post by a_smith »

Hungary Jack wrote:Is the best ammunition for a meeting with little [expletive], helicopter rents, and their counsel simply to present the body of work "authored" by little [expletive], followed by a copy of the original source? Perhaps a copy of the university policy on plagiarism also.
one would think. But denial is a powerful tool in the hands of a parent. "it wasn’t my fault. The professor is a hard ass. The professor is unfair. I didn’t know the policy, etc. It was an honest mistake when I picked out the paper from the file in my frat house.” Are all things that work on parents. Tears are amazing things in swaying parents.
Just to keep the rant going- I am really sick of grading crappy papers.
At another institution I taught a summer course, that a student would pass if the student didn’t miss a class and didn’t sleep (more than a little bit). Not my rules, just the expectation for the class. A student who lived in the area, was a graduating senior who needed a ______________ class to finish a degree. Student then was going to a rather prestigious MBA program. Student's admittance is contingent upon completing the degree. Degree is contingent upon completing my class. My class is contingent upon not sleeping and not missing class. The student just needs a pass. Not even a grade. Just a pass.

Student plagiarizes on both of the papers in the class(very clearly bought the papers). I cant prove the purchase, what i can do is show 15 different sources that have verbatim quotations. This wasn’t even a good job on her part. Some of the plagiarized material used page numbers from different editions than the ones used in class (that's a givaway).

Student for some reason is delusional and thinks she can talk her way out this. She still sends her transcript to new prestigious university. New prestigious university then says that her admittance is under review because of academic dishonesty. She never had to tell them. She could have deferred for a year, and taken the course at a local community college or some other school.

I sit through a meeting, with her, her mother and the letter she submitted on her behalf to the plagiarism committee. Her letter was incoherent, and worse contained several falsehoods that were easily disproved by my showing the syllabus to the committee. Ooopsie. Her mother makes impassioned appeal that she has never done anything like this before and that we should be lenient because she has been accepted in MBA program, has learned her lesson, has been a great student and has always been a hard worker. I point out that she still plagiarized and that we wonder about the quality of her work given that she plagiarized in an introductory level class. That doesn’t go over well. Mother argues that student needs MBA for future earnings

In the entire 1 hour meeting, student doesn’t speak once. Mom did it for her.

She loses appeal, she gets kicked out of MA program, and still has to retake the class.

Arthur Dent
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12542
Joined: April 25 06, 6:43 pm
Location: Austin

Re: Dumb students who plagiarize

Post by Arthur Dent »

a_smith wrote:Mother argues that student needs MBA for future earnings
Confirming that it's only the paper and not the education that matters?
Last edited by Arthur Dent on May 15 09, 4:56 pm, edited 1 time in total.

User avatar
Hungary Jack
Mother Earth
Posts: 19536
Joined: July 24 06, 6:03 am
Location: In Cognito

Re: Dumb students who plagiarize

Post by Hungary Jack »

Arthur Dent wrote:
a_smith wrote:Mother argues that student needs MBA for future earnings
Confirming that it's only the paper and not the educations that matters?
There is a lot of truth to that, AD. In general, an MBA from a prestigious school can get you an outstanding job opportunity (e.g offer from Goldman Sachs, McKinsey, or GE) that you might not otherwise get, but what you do with it from there is largely up to you, and not the paper. IIRC, several studies show that 10 years post-MBA, where you got the degree from matters little.

So if this womanchild that smith describes is as helpless as she sounds, she can get her prestigious MBA and get a good job, but she probably won't last unless she gets a clue pretty quick.

I hear nothing but horror stories about Millennials and their helicopter parents. I'd almost be afraid to hire one for my business.

Arthur Dent
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 12542
Joined: April 25 06, 6:43 pm
Location: Austin

Re: Dumb students who plagiarize

Post by Arthur Dent »

Hungary Jack wrote:I hear nothing but horror stories about Millennials and their helicopter parents. I'd almost be afraid to hire one for my business.
I was born in 1981. Does that make me a millennial? While I'm sure my generation contains its share of turds, so do all generations. I hear those baby boomers are going to cause the downfall of society. Stories about "kids these days" deserve a lot of skepticism.

User avatar
Radbird
There's someone in my head but it's not me
Posts: 62390
Joined: April 18 06, 5:08 pm
Location: LF Bleachers @ Busch II

Re: Dumb students who plagiarize

Post by Radbird »

My daughter would be horrified if we tried to interfere or correspond with her professors on her behalf. I don't think we've even attempted to do anything like that since grade school.

User avatar
sighyoung
Mayor of GRB
Posts: 38643
Joined: April 17 06, 7:42 pm
Location: Louisville

Re: Dumb students who plagiarize

Post by sighyoung »

a_smith, does your college or university have an Academic Discipline committee, or is this some sort of honor court? Wherever this is heading, they've dealt with hundreds of such cases--and the chairs of these discipline committees are very good about moving hearings along, and keeping proceedings within bounds. There should also be policies concerning whether or not students may bring lawyers into such a disciplinary hearing.

Finally, there may be an adviser who is connected with such committees or trial hearings. It would be reassuring to speak with him or her concerning what to expect, and how best to prepare for the hearing. As you probably know, keep copies of everything, including relevant correspondence.

Sorry to rattle on like on overly protective uncle.

User avatar
EastonBlues22
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 4798
Joined: May 7 06, 11:31 pm

Re: Dumb students who plagiarize

Post by EastonBlues22 »


Spider John
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 10952
Joined: May 18 06, 10:09 pm
Location: East of the middle of West Tennessee

Re: Dumb students who plagiarize

Post by Spider John »

EastonBlues22 wrote:RateYourStudents

Wow! A blast from the past. Where ya been, Easton?

User avatar
a_smith
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 4561
Joined: September 20 06, 10:55 am

Re: Dumb students who plagiarize

Post by a_smith »

sighyoung wrote:a_smith, does your college or university have an Academic Discipline committee, or is this some sort of honor court? Wherever this is heading, they've dealt with hundreds of such cases--and the chairs of these discipline committees are very good about moving hearings along, and keeping proceedings within bounds. There should also be policies concerning whether or not students may bring lawyers into such a disciplinary hearing.

Finally, there may be an adviser who is connected with such committees or trial hearings. It would be reassuring to speak with him or her concerning what to expect, and how best to prepare for the hearing. As you probably know, keep copies of everything, including relevant correspondence.

Sorry to rattle on like on overly protective uncle.
you've done this too i see.

been through the block a few times on this. I wish someone had given me this advice my first year teaching. I learned the hard way to cover my arse.

User avatar
haltz
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 22630
Joined: November 9 06, 6:45 am
Location: a proud midwestern metropolis

Re: Dumb students who plagiarize

Post by haltz »

I'm really getting a kick out of this story and smith's commentary on the whole thing. This sort of thing is fascinating to me. The rare times I'm enrolled in a college course, I really just try and do my work and have as little contact with anyone in the classroom as possible, so if this sort of thing is prevalent now I guess I missed it.

What I don't understand is how people think they are fooling anyone when they do this. What's sort of easy is to take some information and put it in your standard horse-[expletive] ~4 pg paper form, but what's hard is copying sentences and paragraphs down verbatim and trying to string them together so that it flows at all. Even changing the words around. Just ends up being hilariously awkward, and way more trouble than it's worth, resulting in a paper that sucks. I tried this once because I was short on time and sleep and it ended up taking me 4X longer than just pounding out some BS paper.

If you want to cheat just do it the old fashioned way and pay some kid to write the paper for you. There's definitely someone out there that will write you a technically sound paper for some beer money.

PSB. I like that.

Post Reply