one would think. But denial is a powerful tool in the hands of a parent. "it wasn’t my fault. The professor is a hard ass. The professor is unfair. I didn’t know the policy, etc. It was an honest mistake when I picked out the paper from the file in my frat house.” Are all things that work on parents. Tears are amazing things in swaying parents.Hungary Jack wrote:Is the best ammunition for a meeting with little [expletive], helicopter rents, and their counsel simply to present the body of work "authored" by little [expletive], followed by a copy of the original source? Perhaps a copy of the university policy on plagiarism also.
Just to keep the rant going- I am really sick of grading crappy papers.
At another institution I taught a summer course, that a student would pass if the student didn’t miss a class and didn’t sleep (more than a little bit). Not my rules, just the expectation for the class. A student who lived in the area, was a graduating senior who needed a ______________ class to finish a degree. Student then was going to a rather prestigious MBA program. Student's admittance is contingent upon completing the degree. Degree is contingent upon completing my class. My class is contingent upon not sleeping and not missing class. The student just needs a pass. Not even a grade. Just a pass.
Student plagiarizes on both of the papers in the class(very clearly bought the papers). I cant prove the purchase, what i can do is show 15 different sources that have verbatim quotations. This wasn’t even a good job on her part. Some of the plagiarized material used page numbers from different editions than the ones used in class (that's a givaway).
Student for some reason is delusional and thinks she can talk her way out this. She still sends her transcript to new prestigious university. New prestigious university then says that her admittance is under review because of academic dishonesty. She never had to tell them. She could have deferred for a year, and taken the course at a local community college or some other school.
I sit through a meeting, with her, her mother and the letter she submitted on her behalf to the plagiarism committee. Her letter was incoherent, and worse contained several falsehoods that were easily disproved by my showing the syllabus to the committee. Ooopsie. Her mother makes impassioned appeal that she has never done anything like this before and that we should be lenient because she has been accepted in MBA program, has learned her lesson, has been a great student and has always been a hard worker. I point out that she still plagiarized and that we wonder about the quality of her work given that she plagiarized in an introductory level class. That doesn’t go over well. Mother argues that student needs MBA for future earnings
In the entire 1 hour meeting, student doesn’t speak once. Mom did it for her.
She loses appeal, she gets kicked out of MA program, and still has to retake the class.



