Arthur Dent wrote:I'd be suspicious of any publication claiming to be impartial that uses the term "partial birth abortion".
It's usually in quotes, or "'so-called' partial birth abortion."
I respect that it's perhaps exceedingly rare, but I don't see why that means it shouldn't be addressed and maybe treated differently than an early term abortion. The fact that something is hypothetical doesn't mean it's not a valid question, particularly on a topic that is so important to a large part of the population. The law covers all sorts of seemingly odd contingencies.
And I'm still unclear why partially delivering the fetus and aborting is medically preferable to just delivering it alive. Every story I hear about this, they go into little detail about the medical issues involved, which is frustrating. If we're down to nothing but illegal procedures, what sort of late term abortions was this doctor performing?
Like thrill, I'm more or less apathetic on the issue. But I do get the feeling that for whatever reason, we never get in depth reporting on what these late term procedures are. The specific reporting I have heard on partial birth abortions (I don't know what else you should call it) states that the baby is delivered except for the head, which is then essentially destroyed. Is that an incomplete description? Whether or not the fetus is deformed, I don't get why that has any bearing on whether it needs to be aborted instead of simply removed alive. In any case, that's the first time I've heard anything about deformity being a reason for the procedure. Not suggesting it isn't the case, just pointing out that there's a huge lack of information on this that should be coming from the pro-choice side if they believe those procedures are reasonable.
I guess I could do more research on the issue. I'm just trying to explain the position of most people who aren't that familiar with the specifics. Opponents of late term abortions are glad to give you a description of what's involved, whereas people who want to keep the option don't want to say much of anything about the procedures or why they're necessary. It's easy to see why abortion opponents have more widespread support on these issues.
I could also flip the question back on those against only late term abortions and ask why a 6 month old fetus is more "valid" than one that's 3 months old.