Rant: The Common Era, Before the Common Era

The forum for ranting, raving, complaining and praising
User avatar
Maclowery
Child Pot Activist
Posts: 7742
Joined: June 15 06, 7:27 am
Location: NYC

Re: Rant: The Common Era, Before the Common Era

Post by Maclowery »

I completely agree. It's not for any kind of clarity or optimization, like how we should be using metric measurement instead of our wacky system. It's just a very goofy separation of church and state deal that I don't really see a need for.

User avatar
JCShutout
MacGyver of Underwear
Posts: 13368
Joined: April 18 06, 7:53 am
Location: South City

Re: Rant: The Common Era, Before the Common Era

Post by JCShutout »

redbirdjazzz wrote:
JCShutout wrote:I don't really understand this rant. You're critiquing people of getting offended by two letters when you are getting offended about one extra letter. There is an acceptance that European and US history aren't the only histories in town. All cultures have calendars based off of their religious traditions. Why don't we use the Chinese calendar? They're going to be the major superpower soon.
You're still using the same dates and the same calendar. It's an empty gesture at political correctness to change the letters without changing the meaning. Why is it the Common Era?
Because language and how we use it has a lot of meaning, imo. It implies a more open understanding of the importance of other cultures in an easy to apply way. A lot of European and US imperialism has come under the flag of Christianity, so I can appreciate someone from a different culture who would prefer a different distinction. Its kinda like saying, ours is better than yours in some ways. Re-creating a calendar (captain's log, stardate 4425.73) would be too difficult, so a simple and easy suggestion is just a nice thing to do.

And I'm not necessarily saying its something we have to do, I just don't see it as rant-worthy.

Then again, why do I say Hebrew Scriptures and not Old Testament when I'm referring to the same set of texts?

User avatar
redbirdjazzz
Perennial All-Star
Posts: 4921
Joined: April 17 06, 10:50 am
Location: Columbia, MO

Re: Rant: The Common Era, Before the Common Era

Post by redbirdjazzz »

JCShutout wrote:
redbirdjazzz wrote:
JCShutout wrote:I don't really understand this rant. You're critiquing people of getting offended by two letters when you are getting offended about one extra letter. There is an acceptance that European and US history aren't the only histories in town. All cultures have calendars based off of their religious traditions. Why don't we use the Chinese calendar? They're going to be the major superpower soon.
You're still using the same dates and the same calendar. It's an empty gesture at political correctness to change the letters without changing the meaning. Why is it the Common Era?
Because language and how we use it has a lot of meaning, imo. It implies a more open understanding of the importance of other cultures in an easy to apply way. A lot of European and US imperialism has come under the flag of Christianity, so I can appreciate someone from a different culture who would prefer a different distinction. Its kinda like saying, ours is better than yours in some ways. Re-creating a calendar (captain's log, stardate 4425.73) would be too difficult, so a simple and easy suggestion is just a nice thing to do.

And I'm not necessarily saying its something we have to do, I just don't see it as rant-worthy.

Then again, why do I say Hebrew Scriptures and not Old Testament when I'm referring to the same set of texts?
Absolutely language use is extremely meaningful, but I don't think the Hebrew Scripture/Old Testament thing is a good comparison to the BC/BCE distinction. When you say "Hebrew Scriptures" you do mean something different than just "Old Testament." You're imbuing it with a subtly different historical context even if the physical scriptures are the same. The only commonality in a "Common Era" beginning in 1 AD is the birth of Jesus. In many ways, I think calling it the "Common Era" is less sensitive to non-Christians, because they're getting lumped into that commonality.

User avatar
cards2468
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 14745
Joined: October 28 06, 11:10 pm
Location: LOVE IT OR LEAVE IT

Re: Rant: The Common Era, Before the Common Era

Post by cards2468 »

Wouldn't Hebrew Scriptures refer to the Tanakh? The Old Testament is different from the Tanakh in terms of context as well as physical structure.

User avatar
JCShutout
MacGyver of Underwear
Posts: 13368
Joined: April 18 06, 7:53 am
Location: South City

Re: Rant: The Common Era, Before the Common Era

Post by JCShutout »

redbirdjazzz wrote:
JCShutout wrote:
redbirdjazzz wrote:
JCShutout wrote:I don't really understand this rant. You're critiquing people of getting offended by two letters when you are getting offended about one extra letter. There is an acceptance that European and US history aren't the only histories in town. All cultures have calendars based off of their religious traditions. Why don't we use the Chinese calendar? They're going to be the major superpower soon.
You're still using the same dates and the same calendar. It's an empty gesture at political correctness to change the letters without changing the meaning. Why is it the Common Era?
Because language and how we use it has a lot of meaning, imo. It implies a more open understanding of the importance of other cultures in an easy to apply way. A lot of European and US imperialism has come under the flag of Christianity, so I can appreciate someone from a different culture who would prefer a different distinction. Its kinda like saying, ours is better than yours in some ways. Re-creating a calendar (captain's log, stardate 4425.73) would be too difficult, so a simple and easy suggestion is just a nice thing to do.

And I'm not necessarily saying its something we have to do, I just don't see it as rant-worthy.

Then again, why do I say Hebrew Scriptures and not Old Testament when I'm referring to the same set of texts?
Absolutely language use is extremely meaningful, but I don't think the Hebrew Scripture/Old Testament thing is a good comparison to the BC/BCE distinction. When you say "Hebrew Scriptures" you do mean something different than just "Old Testament." You're imbuing it with a subtly different historical context even if the physical scriptures are the same. The only commonality in a "Common Era" beginning in 1 AD is the birth of Jesus. In many ways, I think calling it the "Common Era" is less sensitive to non-Christians, because they're getting lumped into that commonality.
I am arguing that whomever came up with the idea is trying to use language with a different historical context. I don't think its perfect, which is why I don't necessarily think its something we have to do, but I can appreciate the attempt at being more respectful. If someone came up with a better way to organize the calendar or whatnot, great.

I was more reacting to those who seemed to be ranting against any change for the sake of trying to be respectful/PC/whatnot.

User avatar
JCShutout
MacGyver of Underwear
Posts: 13368
Joined: April 18 06, 7:53 am
Location: South City

Re: Rant: The Common Era, Before the Common Era

Post by JCShutout »

cards2468 wrote:Wouldn't Hebrew Scriptures refer to the Tanakh? The Old Testament is different from the Tanakh in terms of context as well as physical structure.
Depending on what denomination of Christianity you are, the OT and Tanakh and Hebrew/Jewish Scriptures are essentially the same (aside from the books accepted by the Catholic Church), and the physical structure differences are incredibly minimal (two books in one tradition are seen as one book in another and a couple a bound in different orders) IIRC from some classes about 5 years ago.

User avatar
cards2468
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 14745
Joined: October 28 06, 11:10 pm
Location: LOVE IT OR LEAVE IT

Re: Rant: The Common Era, Before the Common Era

Post by cards2468 »

JCShutout wrote:
cards2468 wrote:Wouldn't Hebrew Scriptures refer to the Tanakh? The Old Testament is different from the Tanakh in terms of context as well as physical structure.
Depending on what denomination of Christianity you are, the OT and Tanakh and Hebrew/Jewish Scriptures are essentially the same (aside from the books accepted by the Catholic Church), and the physical structure differences are incredibly minimal (two books in one tradition are seen as one book in another and a couple a bound in different orders) IIRC from some classes about 5 years ago.
Didn't the Catholic Church remove a few books though?

User avatar
AdmiralKird
MBA, CPA, CFA, CFP, JD, PE, MD
Posts: 10178
Joined: March 7 07, 4:50 pm
Location: Tycho Crater, Luna

Re: Rant: The Common Era, Before the Common Era

Post by AdmiralKird »

The idea of having two very similar names (both include the common era and the same two initials) would from a technical standpoint be inferior in usage to BC/AD, and would create confusion.
http://atheism.about.com/od/ideasforatheistactivism/a/BCE-CE-Years.htm wrote:Perhaps it isn't much, but every time you use BCE and CE instead of BC and AD, you are refusing to submit yourself and your writings to a Christian agenda that is all about asserting dominion over culture, politics, society, and even your very thought processes. Sometimes it is the little things, however, that keep resistance alive and active.
I could not sit down and have a beer with someone like this.

User avatar
heyzeus
Everday Unicorn
Posts: 43332
Joined: April 21 06, 10:14 am
Location: Austin, TX

Re: Rant: The Common Era, Before the Common Era

Post by heyzeus »

JCShutout wrote:
cards2468 wrote:Wouldn't Hebrew Scriptures refer to the Tanakh? The Old Testament is different from the Tanakh in terms of context as well as physical structure.
Depending on what denomination of Christianity you are, the OT and Tanakh and Hebrew/Jewish Scriptures are essentially the same (aside from the books accepted by the Catholic Church), and the physical structure differences are incredibly minimal (two books in one tradition are seen as one book in another and a couple a bound in different orders) IIRC from some classes about 5 years ago.
There are different Hebrew scriptures out there, numerous ones. I believe your Old Testament is our Torah, ie, the first five books (genesis, exodus, leviticus, deuteronomy, numbers). Also, I've never known a Jewish person to be offended by reference to the "Old Testament." It's cool. We know it's pretty old.

User avatar
haltz
Hall Of Famer
Posts: 22630
Joined: November 9 06, 6:45 am
Location: a proud midwestern metropolis

Re: Rant: The Common Era, Before the Common Era

Post by haltz »

huh, I always thought the Torah referred to the whole thing.

In Christianity the old testament refers to the first 39 (I think that's the numbers) books of the bible (this is also essentially a BC/AD split). The first five that are attributed to Moses are called the pentateuch AFAIK.

Post Reply